ノンバイナリー10年、テストステロン5年、そして与えられた名前に戻る
女性 · 脱トランジション75
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はデトランズィションした女性で、ほぼ10年間ノンバイナリーとして社会的トランズィションをし、2024年にデトランズィションを始める前に5年以上テストステロンを使用していました。今は、私が性別ディスフォリアと呼んでいたものは、内面化された女性嫌悪、女性であることへの恐れ、幼少期の性的虐待、そして幼い頃から身体が性的対象化されたことに根ざしており、教師として大都市へ引っ越した後の仲間の影響で強まったと理解しています。精神的な目覚め、より小さな大学都市での時間、そして最終的にジェンダー批判的な視点を読んだことがデトランズィションへ私を導き、以来、顔の毛を除去し、ハーバリスト/鍼灸師からエストロゲンを含むハーブを始め、与えられた名前を再び受け入れ始めました。卵管と卵巣を摘出したことを後悔し、二重乳房切除については両義的で、デトランズィション中にトランス女性として読まれることを恐れています。今は自分の女性の身体に心地よく自認し、行動する前に待ち、あらゆる角度から情報を集めるよう他人に勧めています。
全文
I have been self-assured, strong-willed and confident in most areas of life throughout my life — so much so that I convinced myself and others that I was trans. The definition of being trans broadened to include the things I was experiencing, and I was sure I was experiencing gender dysphoria based on those broadened definitions.
I was never around trans people in college. Once I moved to a large city to work as a teacher, I was suddenly surrounded by leftists and anarchists who convinced me through their own experiences that my discomfort with my body — especially how it had been sexualized from a young age — would be alleviated by taking testosterone. I identified as non-binary for years, even being fully convinced I'd never medically alter my body in spite of my discomfort with it as a sexualized body. I never wanted to be a man, but I was deeply fearful of being a woman and had been told throughout my life via words and actions that I was never being a girl or woman 'right'. As a 'failed woman' on testosterone, at least I could fall away from many of the societal expectations and standards I was being held to. Like many others, I never said these things to myself directly. A set of feelings that were then labeled more broadly by the world I inhabited suddenly gave me boxes to inhabit — the promise of being understood for once in my life, in deeply profound ways.
I experienced a lot of fear around being a girl, and becoming a woman. I dealt with a lot of internalized misogyny, had a history of disordered eating and self harm — I was not taught how to feel at home in my body and viewed it as the enemy. What I thought was dysphoria was maladaptive behaviors to experiencing misogyny in the world and being sexually abused etc. I saw the way women in my life were treated and I didn't want any part of it. I tried to escape as soon as I could.
I was sure of what I was doing, eventually sure of top surgery and the results, and became increasingly uncomfortable with being treated as a man. Being excluded from women's spaces, including bathrooms, has felt deeply uncomfortable and painful for me — I use the bathroom at home or family spaces in public wherever possible. Not being able to inhabit women's spiritual spaces has felt increasingly painful.
I've questioned being on testosterone nearly the entire time I've been on it, going off and on at times, and continued to seek the comfort of distancing myself from being treated and seen as a woman. I am now five+ years on T and nearly ten years socially transitioned as nonbinary. For the first time I'm realizing I hadn't experienced gender dysphoria until the world saw and treated me as a man, despite never identifying as one.
I research everything thoroughly into the ground, from all angles. However, I didn't seek any gender critical rhetoric because of the dehumanization of those who are gender critical from the 'trans community'. It was framed as 'humanizing' vs 'dehumanizing'. I have found that the gender critical community by and large has a lot more space for the coexistence of experience and views. The rigid views coming from the 'trans community' are a violence to me, often one that denies resources to anyone pushing against the rhetoric. I was sent the BITE model for cults and can easily recall many instances for nearly every bullet point in the list. It's wild how much coercion is centered in the 'community'. If folks meant what they said — they would accept you at all stages of choice. Instead, so many feel attacked when someone detransitions/desists. I feel it's because to consider someone else desisting might lead to me considering it for myself — and I'm terrified of doing that. That's why the 'born this way' and 'you were never really trans' narratives are so reinforced.
After 6 years in the big city, I moved to a smaller college town. Now that I've been here nearly three years, I've had so much time and space to heal and move through things I didn't know were plaguing me. This past month (May 2024), bigger realizations occurred to me, and they continue to occur at a fast pace.
I've learned that the ego creates a sense of urgency — if it feels urgent, wait. Witness what happens when you wait. My spiritual awakening over a year ago and complete overhaul of how I viewed the world — being shifted to seeing myself as a spiritual being having a temporarily human experience, and belief that I chose this life path to many extents — has been the foundation for this recent realization. I'm becoming comfortable with the idea of being a woman, identifying with my female body and offering it gentleness for how it and I have been handled and treated throughout this life. I typed that a week out from having removed my facial hair, which brought me immense joy and brought me to tears. I still feel like my appearance says, 'man in drag', and I'm moving through that as gently as I can. Not all of these changes will revert, but those I care most about will. I have started taking estrogen containing herbs via my herbalist/acupuncturist, and am deeply appreciative of the holistic lens Chinese Medicine uses when treating symptoms — especially seeing them all as temporary. There's a lot to reconcile, but I can say I've never felt more comfortable with my knowledge of self, even in light of having identified as trans for nearly a decade. Tackling pronouns is next on the docket, and I'm afraid of being treated like a trans woman in the world as I detransition — which is so wild to note. I regret complicating things by removing my tubes and ovaries, and currently feel ambivalent about having had a double mastectomy. I'm unsure if this will change as I heal the underlying sexual wounds, and have a sense it's likely it might for me personally.
I never thought I'd want to reincorporate my given name until the past week (September 2024). Since then, I've embraced combining my given and chosen names, and I'm quite liking it personally. It feels like a loving integration — I'm more than who I was before all of this nonsense, and I'm not simply the being I chose to be — I'm all of it.
On the medical side, I know Aetna just explicitly stated they cover detransition procedures — I recently got onto my wife's plan. I've read of other detransitioning women having their procedures covered as well. I've argued that this is considered neglect and malpractice, with exceptions made for immunocompromising effects and for folks who were not fully informed or who were misinformed. Just in September 2024 I had an appointment for PRP hair growth and we are hoping to work with the practitioner to get insurance to cover it. I thought for sure I'd have to go the hair plugs route myself.
In my own life, I try my best to just name things as I perceive and experience them, without judging others. Judging others has, thankfully, not ever been my issue. It's always been self judgment, and I've grown and healed so much around it. I have a lot of compassion for why any of us seek escape. The idea any of us could be doing our sex 'wrong' and are failures is so confusing and painful. I have nothing but love for folks who are struggling, including men who experience AGP desires.
My advice to others on the detransition path: waiting will not harm you. If you don't feel it is a matter of life and death, and each possibility occurs to you, I urge you to wait and watch things unfold for you emotionally.