すべての体験談

7歳の性別違和、成人してホルモン、そして性別はまったくなく

男性 · 脱トランジション277
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。

Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。

AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。

要約

私はデトランジションした男性で、トランスとして自認し、一年弱HRTを続け、今は異性愛のジェンダー非適合の男性として自認しています。ディスフォリアの結果としてジェンダー・アイデンティティへの信念を完全にやめ、幼少期のメタ・アトラクションの感覚と自分が女性だという想像を7、8歳頃まで遡ります。現代のトランス活動、ノンバイナリーのアイデンティティ、egg文化、デトランジション統計に批判的で、AGP/AAPとジェンダー・ユーフォリアを本質的に同じ現象とみなしています。私のディスフォリアは主に、男性がどう見え、どう振る舞うべきかというステレオタイプに由来し、自分の状況を男性への期待と戦う機会として再定義しました。自殺念慮、自傷、自殺企図は報告していません。

全文

I joined this detrans community in late August 2025 after having already detransitioned. My experience with dysphoria ironically led me to stop believing in the concept of gender identity altogether; I think people who do believe in it are overthinking and applying sexed stereotypes to their personality traits. I've had dysphoria and what I describe as AGP for as long as I can remember — around age 7 or 8 I would pretend to be female characters when playing with friends, even kissing them, and the excitement came not from attraction to another male but from the imagined perception that I was female. I call that meta-attraction, a component of auto-sexuality. I didn't have any understanding of homosexuality or transgenderism at that age; I just liked imagining I was female and anything that affirmed being perceived as one. I was on HRT for a little less than a year before I realized it was pretty much pointless, and I settled on the fact that I'll always be a guy rather than coping with being a 'fake woman.' I am male. I now identify as a straight man who is gender non-conforming. A lot of my dysphoria comes from assumptions about how males are 'supposed to' look and act, or the assumption that I'm automatically a bad person because I'm male — I think that's bs and other people's issue if they can't see people as individuals. I've always thought females are just better in the ways I think are important, though I acknowledge that might be the bias of being a straight dude. I don't trust any detransition statistics, including the 2% figure, because the definition is vague and includes people who still internally identify as trans in some way, and many who do regret just get on with their lives without drawing attention to it. I'm critical of modern trans activism: I think being trans has been reduced to just calling yourself trans, based on an unfalsifiable, subjective concept of gender identity. I believe gender identity and sexuality are not innate or fixed but are complex and influenced by many factors. I think anyone who completely dismisses AGP and AAP is either misinformed or in defensive denial, and that 'gender euphoria' is essentially the same phenomenon with a less stigmatizing name — pleasure, often but not necessarily strictly sexual, and sometimes manifesting as romantic feelings. I also think non-binary identities are inherently sexist because they assume boys/girls and men/women are supposed to be a certain way, and I find it ironic that non-binary is developing its own stereotyped presentation. I'd rather people embrace gender non-conformity. I'm critical of 'egg culture' as toxic, and I've noted how Vtuber culture allows people to skip real-life social or medical transition while being affirmed purely based on a digital model. The hardest pill to swallow was acknowledging that detransition doesn't magically make dysphoria go away, but that being trans won't give me the opportunities growing up I feel I missed — I told someone else it will get better. I had a revelation that if I can't be a woman, I can use the opportunity to fight the expectations of men. It's still annoying to be generalized based on sex, but I see it more as their problem for not being open-minded. My advice to others is to not let others define you: don't be the expectation of what a man is, just be yourself. I'm open to the idea that someone could still take HRT and just be a GNC guy if they like the effects.