성별 불쾌감, 강박장애, 그리고 전환하지 않기로 한 선택
여성 · 단념579
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 디트랜지션 정체성을 가진 여성이며(실제로는 트랜지션한 적이 없지만), 여성인 것을 깊이 혐오하고 강한 성별 불쾌감을 겪지만, r/detrans 커뮤니티를 이용해 이 결정을 강화한 후 의도적으로 트랜지션하지 않기로 했습니다. 저는 강박장애가 있고 강간과 임신에 대한 오랜 강박적 공포, 호르몬 불균형(자연히 높은 테스토스테론, 낮은 에스트로겐)이 있으며, 성을 강하게 혐오하고 아마 무성애자입니다. 저는 신체 혐오와 불쾌감과 관련된 자살 사고를 겪었고, 특히 다른 사람들이 제 고통을 가볍게 여길 때 그러했습니다. 저는 하나님이 저를 의도적으로 여성으로 창조하셨다고 믿는 개신교 기독교인이며, 현재 Sexual Wholeness를 통해 어느 방향으로도 밀어붙이지 않는 치료사와 만나고 있습니다. 저는 고통스러운 중간 상태에 머물러 있습니다 — 트랜지션하지 않는 것이 저에게 옳다고 확신하지만 그것으로 행복하지는 않습니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and I have never medically transitioned, but I came to the r/detrans community largely to convince myself not to transition. I deeply, deeply hate being a girl and I deeply hate my body, especially my bottom half, and I wish I had been born a boy. I have never gone on hormones or had any surgeries, and I don't currently identify as trans, though I remain stuck in a kind of limbo—knowing that not transitioning is the right decision for me, but not being happy about it.
I have struggled with OCD since I was a teenager. Around that age I developed obsessive fears about rape and pregnancy that would play on repeat in my head nearly nonstop, every day, with little relief. I also experience intense gender dysphoria (or what I sometimes call dysmorphia—I'm still not sure of the correct term). I hate my periods in particular; they are one of the biggest sources of my hatred of my body. I am highly sex-repulsed, probably asexual though I haven't settled on whether I fit the definition, and I never intend to date, get married, or have sex. The thought of touching my own bottom half is one of the most repulsive thoughts imaginable to me, and the thought of masturbating makes me want to throw up, even though I can experience arousal and don't hate my body in those moments.
The thing I hate most about my body is its capability to become pregnant. That predates the overturning of Roe v. Wade—it has always horrified me that I have a body capable of it, to the extent that it makes me want to slash my body up (I haven't, I just want to). My absolute worst fear is being raped and getting pregnant from it. I want to be sterilized, and I've researched procedures; I learned about bilateral salpingectomy as an option that doesn't risk ectopic pregnancy, which was a relief to know about. I've also considered a hysterectomy but learned it could cause problems, including messing with my already imbalanced hormones. I have a hormonal imbalance: years ago a doctor found my testosterone was already at the level of a boy my age and my estrogen was at menopause levels. She gave me medicine (not hormones) to balance things out, and I do feel better on it. That's one of the reasons I don't think HRT would be healthy for me.
When Roe v. Wade was overturned in 2022, my OCD fears ramped up dramatically. I watched a video by a trans man on the subject that I knew I shouldn't watch, and it filled me with rage, hatred for my body, and renewed desire to transition and sterilize myself. My parents agree with the overturning. My mom has listened to me cry and scream about my gender struggles for years and would be willing to help me travel to another state for an abortion if it came to that, but she can't even offer basic compassion about how hard this is for me personally, and we often end up fighting about it. I've never told my dad about my gender struggles because I know he wouldn't understand, and I believe that if the worst happened and he knew, he would try to force me to go through with the pregnancy.
I came to r/detrans because it has been incredibly helpful in reinforcing my decision not to transition. I've found resources like the article 'Is Anyone Truly Transgender' on somenuanceplease.substack.com helpful, and the idea that transition is essentially working with a mental illness rather than treating it was one of the most eye-opening things I encountered. I don't believe in internal gender identity—I don't think you can have a boy brain in a girl's body. Mentally, everyone is just human. Yet hearing someone say I'm a boy on the inside would be 'music to my soul,' and I don't know if I'd have the strength to deny it.
I have a close trans friend (a trans girl) who is lovely and kind. Early in our friendship she offered to use he/him pronouns for me, and I cried reading the offer because I wanted to say yes so badly, but I couldn't. More recently, she shared with me how she realized she was a girl by asking herself if thinking of herself as a girl made her happy. When I ask myself the same question about being a girl, my answer is visceral horror—'No. Nononononono'—and it makes me want to crawl out of my skin. When I ask if thinking of myself as a boy makes me happy, I start crying. Her reaction was mild ('ehhh') compared to mine, which makes me feel like I must be even more clearly trans than she is. I don't know how to respond to her honestly while also making clear I don't want to transition.
I've done therapy before and found it very helpful. I stopped because of COVID—video sessions didn't work for me—and I've felt bad about going back after so long away. My previous therapist specialized in OCD and I never discussed gender issues with her. I eventually found a new therapist through Sexual Wholeness, a directory of Christian therapists who specialize in gender and sexual issues; she's wonderful and doesn't push her beliefs on me, and she's worked with people who are trans, people transitioning, and people who don't want to. I am a Protestant Christian. I believe God made each of us the sex we were born as on purpose and that transitioning is never His plan, though I acknowledge that hating my body strains my relationship with Him and makes me angry He made me this way.
I have experienced suicidal ideation related to my body hatred. At one point, people on the subreddit told me that hating my periods was 'normal dysphoria for girls' and that it happens to a lot of girls, and that comment made me feel more suicidal than I had in a very long time. Being told that my hatred of being a girl makes me like every other girl sends me into a downward spiral of loathing and suicidal thoughts. I've also mentioned that content about women and menstruation can send me into dysphoric spirals where I want to get out of my body to a painful degree and might start having suicidal ideation.
What's been helping me mentally is noticing how men and women really aren't that different—that society exaggerates differences that aren't that big or aren't really there. There's no such thing as a male brain and a female brain; we're just people. The more I see men and women as different, the more agony I feel. I've been working on questioning both society's beliefs and my own about gender, and examining what holds up, which has been slowly helping with my internalized misogyny. I also process my feelings through writing, usually fiction.
I'm not currently in a relationship and don't plan to be. I don't have many friends who understand my situation—my closest friend is trans and I worry she'd push me toward transition, and my mom struggles to understand. I've been active in the detrans community, offering support and empathy to others, sharing my favorite resources, and encouraging people to try therapy before considering transition because 'if therapy fails you you can always transition later. But if you transition first, there are some things you can never reverse.' I also advocate for therapists not pushing clients in either direction and for nuanced conversation rather than scare tactics on either side.