모든 이야기

7세부터의 성별 불쾌감, 그리고 레즈비언을 혐오한 어머니

여성 · 단념131
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

나는 디트랜지션/디시스트한 여성이다 — 의학적·사회적으로 전환한 적은 없지만, 약 6~7세부터 10대 후반까지 강한 성별 불쾌감을 겪었고 진지하게 전환을 고려했다. 나는 레즈비언이며, 나의 불쾌감은 원한을 품은 동성애혐오적인 어머니, 아동기 학대와 내게 강요된 성별 기대, 인터넷 여성혐오, PCOS, 그리고 OCD에 가까운 사고 패턴에 의해 크게 형성되었다. 나는 남성이 될 수 없다는 것, 그리고 나의 고통이 남성이 되고 싶은 데서가 아니라 여성이 되고 싶지 않은 데서 비롯되었다는 것을 깨닫고 테스토스테론을 복용하지 않기로 했다. 정신적 작업, 여성 신체에 대한 자기 수용, 그리고 나를 중립적 의미에서 단지 여성으로 재정의함을 통해, 나의 불쾌감은 이제 훨씬 덜 심각하고 종종 사라져 있다. 나는 젊은이들에 대한 일차적 대응으로서의 전환에 비판적이며, 공감, 근본 원인 탐구, 그리고 트랜스 정체성을 요구하지 않고도 불쾌감이 레즈비언들 사이에서 흔하다는 인식을 옹호한다.

전체 이야기

I never transitioned socially or medically, but I considered it for several years in my late teens. I used to cry at night looking up sex reassignment surgery and wishing I had just been born male instead. I probably had vocal feelings of wanting to be a boy for as long as I could talk. I experienced dysphoria since I was pretty little, probably around age 6 or 7, and had on-off daydreams about transitioning from about ages 11 to 17, though I didn't have the language to understand that desire until I was an older teen. I am 23 now (as of May 2020) and a lesbian. I decided not to transition for a lot of reasons: it was expensive, I didn't want to be tied to doctors and medication my whole life, I didn't want the whole 'coming out' period of transitioning, but mostly it was that I never would be male — I would be a female person taking male hormones and that was not the same as what I wanted. It wouldn't change that my dysphoria was rooted in a lot of events in my childhood and how I was made to relate to my environment. It was never so much about being male but more that I didn't want to be female. I learned other methods to feel more at peace with my body and gone through a lot of work mentally to undo some very unhelpful thinking and behavior, and that provided me with all I need to keep my dysphoria in check and improved my life in ways I don't think transition would or could have. My relationship with my mother was central to my dysphoria. My mother very palpably resented me as a child because I was never feminine, a tomboy through and through, and I fought all her attempts to properly socialize me as her quiet, demure and feminine daughter. I cried when she put me in dresses, I cried when she forced me to wear form-fitting clothing and when taking me bra shopping. She told me I would naturally be bad at math and science and athletics because those were just things males were better at than females. My mother was also extremely homophobic, and as a young girl who very frequently got caught being too physically close with my female best friend, this distressed her immensely. My whole life I thought my parents had conspired to change my sex in the womb from male to female, that I was defective, and that my mother would have loved me if I was her second son as opposed to her only daughter — a failure in all womanly social graces. I think my bad relationship with her heavily impacted how I viewed myself as a woman in relationship to her and other girls, and my inability to recognize any commonality beyond us being female. My only logical conclusion became that I must not be female after all. My worst fear was becoming like my mother — 'a mentally ill woman was one of the last things I wanted to be' hit me hard. The only logical solution was to be as unlike her as I possibly could. I have some sympathy for my mom because I know she was also horrifically abused by her father (as were her mother and siblings), but it doesn't change that she abused me. I was always much closer to my dad because he didn't care that I wanted to only wear pants and overalls and that I had more interest in being a boy scout like my older brother and play in the mud like my younger brother. My dad doesn't care that I'm neither heterosexual nor a dress-loving, makeup-wearing future housewife. He gave me much more freedom to just be me, and it didn't inhibit him from seeing me as his daughter even when I was considered 'one of the boys.' I was raised Catholic. I'm not practicing or really religious anymore but it's still something that has been a big part of my life and somewhat continues to be. I have polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS), so I have quite a bit more androgen in my body than most female people. My period was a significant dysphoria factor for me, and the consequence of PCOS on my cycle — namely that it was severely irregular and I could go as long as seven months without my period — was unintentionally and unfortunately very helpful at the time. I've been taking better care of my body in the past few years and I believe some weight loss contributed to me experiencing a mostly regular cycle again, which was pretty unpleasant. I'm still not comfortable with menstruating now, but much better than I used to be. What helped me a lot was to stop assigning greater blame to why it was happening and just let it happen knowing it will stop in a few days. I've been using a Diva Cup for a few months and it has helped me a lot. I experience OCD-adjacent thought patterns; it was a large part of what made bouts of dysphoria so unmanageable and upsetting — circular thought contamination that serves no purpose beyond making you more upset the longer you think about it. I struggle with both dysphoria and OCD-adjacent behavior and I think the two were definitely interlinked. Internet misogyny severely alienated me from being a woman. Reading the way men talk about women in private — MGTOW, incels, ordinary frat bros — sends me into an entire day of dissociation and dysphoria. I do my best to avoid the temptation to read it as a deliberate act of self-harm. I have several non-binary friends, all female, and I see shades of this in them as well. From my many years oscillating in trans circles, the vast majority of non-binary people I've met are female and I think the nonstop, easily accessible barrage of misogyny present on nearly every corner of the internet has been a major contribution. The best thing I did with myself was stop trying to alter or reframe my thinking of my body in a way that was palatable to me when I knew it was coming from an extremely traumatized mindset and a lifetime of having restrictions and abuse imposed on me because of my sex. Regarding myself as female as a completely neutral statement that dictates nothing about how I internalize my behavior or personality made others recognizing me as female, as a woman, significantly less painful. When I was a child and young teen, before I had consciously realized I was attracted to women, anytime I fantasized about romantically interacting with women I couldn't picture anything besides this vaguely male visage that was my stand-in. My dysphoria surrounding my vagina became significantly stronger upon entering (also my first) relationship. My partner is bisexual and before dating me had been in a long-term relationship with a man. When it came to actually having sex, I couldn't stop thinking about how I wasn't him. Something that's helped mitigate my dysphoria, especially in a sexual context, is making the effort to internalize the positive attention my partner gives my body. Buying a non-phallic strap-on and using it helped — realizing I didn't really want a man's penis, I wanted the things I ascribed to a penis' worth in a relationship with a woman, which was an unhealthy way for me to relate to my own body. My breasts have always made me super dysphoric and I think wearing the wrong bra for so many years exacerbated it tenfold. The way I got most comfortable with my chest was by going braless; my breasts are about a C cup. I've always been a pretty masculine woman and though I never did go on T, I do grow a pretty visible mustache/facial hair, chest hair, and have a lower voice than most other women. I used to obsessively shave and never spoke in my natural voice and eventually I just got too tired to keep doing it. I've learned to live with that, realizing that the jealousy (of men's easier muscle development) was clouding my own perception of myself in thinking I could never be like that. I can, it's just more work and I'm okay with that now. I don't feel any gendered sense of 'being' a woman outside of being female. I think the cis/trans dichotomy is unhelpful. When I used to daydream about taking testosterone and passing and being seen as a man, the joy I derived was always in being read as male by other men; there was this twinge of pain at the idea of being read male by other women — I think it stemmed from wanting men to not perceive or form opinions on me, but being sad at the idea of not being 'seen' by women, who I functionally always felt would be the people whom I loved and would be understood by. I have met many detransitioned women in the past year. I've met several women who do not consider themselves male or trans men but who do take steps to intentionally pass as male in public — most are lesbians who have desisted or struggled with gender in the past but who do not believe themselves to have a 'gender identity'; they're just women, but are most comfortable or okay with being perceived as men to varying degrees of frequency. I find it helpful to remind myself that there are women who think and behave like this and there always will be. I am not here to talk anyone out of identifying with transness. I stress empathy with young people experiencing dysphoria: the point is not outright to scare them out of transitioning but to illustrate that transition is simply another coping mechanism for that feeling, it isn't right for everyone, it is a major life decision that will in many aspects be irreversible beyond a certain point, and it is not a fast and easy immediate fix. Accessing the root of dysphoria is necessary if emotionally distressing work, but is something that should be encouraged.