모든 이야기

15세에 사회적 전환, 재평가까지 25세를 기다렸다

여성 · 단념433
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 2023년 초 15세에 사회적으로 트랜지션하고 이후 사회적으로 디트랜지션한 디트랜지션 여성으로, 호르몬이나 수술은 전혀 받지 않았습니다. 저는 신경다양성이었고 섭식장애와 자해 이력이 성별 정체성 문제와 함께 있었으며, 중학교 시절의 고립과 팬데믹이 한몫했다고 의심합니다. 다시 소녀로 살려 한 후 제 몸에서 더 어색함을 느끼고 문제는 옷이 아니라 제 몸이라고 결론지었으며, 25세까지 재평가를 기다리기로 했습니다. 저는 얼굴 이형이 있고 어머니의 지지로 치료를 받았습니다. 저는 의문을 품고 트랜스 사람들을 지지하면서도 되돌릴 수 없는 의료 조치에는 신중합니다.

전체 이야기

I first posted in February 2023 saying I thought I was trans but wasn't 100% sure, asking what had clued other people in that they weren't trans and what warnings they had, because I really didn't want to do anything irreversible or unnecessary. I mentioned I was starting behavioral therapy with a gender specialist soon. I also said I am neurodivergent and that I thought that could affect my perception of gender, and in another comment that I'm neurodivergent and afab, which is why I second-guess things like this. In late February 2023 I got into a long, heavily downvoted argument about what a woman is. I offered my own definition — that a woman is someone who identifies with, expresses and embodies the cultural norm of femininity and feels comfort in the physical definers of a female — and said I was trying to reconnect with my womanhood to self-reflect on my transition and reasons for doing so. I said my definition was open-ended and personal, that being a woman is something someone determines by their own values, comforts and expression, and that this open-endedness is exactly why I struggle with my gender identity. I suggested things like appreciation of the ability to give birth, or connection to a female goddess if spiritual, as ways of relating to womanhood. People pushed back hard and I got defensive, saying their responses made me feel unwelcome in a community I thought could help me figure things out, and noting my flair said I was questioning my transition and looking for support. I also said I was trying to de-influence myself and look at the detrans perspective, and asked someone how they changed views to alleviate dysphoria. Someone suggested accepting my body alongside a masculine presentation, and I replied that surgery probably won't be an option for me anyway, so that might be a good path. In March 2023 I commented that I was lucky my parents were strict about internet access as a kid, otherwise I would have been 'way too deep way too early.' On March 8, 2023 I posted that I had decided to detransition socially to step back and reassess, that I hadn't done anything irreversible — no medical care or surgeries yet — but wanted to try living as a female again. I asked how to reframe how I present, how I ask people to refer to me, and my perception of myself. On March 12, 2023 I posted that I'd tried living as a girl again for about 3 days. My parents and friends never got the hang of new pronouns and never saw me as a man anyway, so the only changes were using my birth name and not binding my chest. I wrote that I'd always questioned my transition, since it was only social and I still liked makeup and feminine, soft clothing, but these days made me realize 'it's not the clothes, it's the mannequin' — that I have an issue with my body. My breasts look awkward against my boyish frame, and without makeup I look like a prepubescent boy. Being called my old name was weird because it's very feminine and never felt like me. I said I felt more awkward and isolated in my body, that my sex characteristics feel like baggy clothes that hide who I am and weigh me down, and I planned to keep trying for a few more weeks. In comments I said I'm actually 15 and that most of my issues are surrounding puberty/womanhood, and that I have facial dysmorphia and would ask my psych about it. On March 15 I said I'd decided to keep trying to live as a woman until I'm 25, 'when my brain stops developing,' to reevaluate. On March 18 I said I was super isolated and dissociated when I started identifying as trans, but that coincided with the start of middle school and then the pandemic a year later. On March 19 I said I got the 'best of both worlds' struggling with EDs and SH as well as gender identity issues at the same time, and thanked my therapist and my mom for helping me recover. Same day I said I'd decided to only do what makes me comfortable non-medically — shapewear and socially identifying as gender non-conforming — until I've mentally developed enough to understand myself better. In late March 2023 I argued against the idea that trans people are behind mass shootings, correcting claims about the Uvalde, Highland Park and Dayton shooters, and defending trans people generally while acknowledging I myself may have been misled or misidentified myself. On March 31 I thanked someone, saying 'As someone debating whether to go through with my transition or not, thank you.' On April 6, 2023 I told someone absolutely not to get an irreversible surgery in 2 days if they felt any doubt, and to wait, think, and talk with a therapist or psychiatrist about their mental state and medication. My last comment, January 3, 2024, complimented someone's appearance, saying they pass as a woman. Overall I was questioning, socially transitioned, then socially detransitioned at 15 without ever having had hormones or surgery, dealing with body dysmorphia, an eating disorder, self-harm, and confusion about whether my issues were about gender or about puberty and womanhood.