1년간의 호르몬 붕괴와 1년의 침묵
여성 · 탈전환181
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 임상적 젠더 디스포리아 진단 후 18세에 테스토스테론을 시작하고 스텔스로 살다가, 심한 질 위축, 헤어라인 손실, 외로움, 악화되는 해리 후에 디트랜지션한 여성입니다. 위축을 치료하려면 나를 해리시키는 침습적 자기 삽입이 필요했기 때문에 T를 끊었고, 거의 1년간 지속된 호르몬 붕괴 동안 심한 자살 성향으로 입원했습니다. 아직도 성기에 극도의 불편함이 있으며, 그것을 초등학교부터 시작된 10년 이상의 성적 학대와 미소지니 문화에 돌립니다. 남성화된 얼굴, 게이 남성처럼 들린다고 내가 묘사하는 목소리, 얼굴 털 제거의 한계를 포함한 영구적 변화를 후회합니다. 이제 젠더는 구성된 사회적 역할이라고 믿고, 강요된 의료화에 반대하면서 다른 사람의 이름과 대명사를 존중하며, 우울증 치료를 위해 트랜지션하지 말라고 십 대들에게 경고합니다. 적어도 7~8명의 전 남자친구가 나와 사귀는 동안 트랜지션했고 대부분 그 후 디트랜지션한 것을 죄책감으로 느낍니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and started testosterone at 18, after being clinically diagnosed with gender dysphoria. I was a textbook trans man throughout my transition — I got euphoria from he/him pronouns and binding, and when I came out to other students even conservative ones said it made total sense; the only person who pushed back was a girl who had socially transitioned and then desisted. I moved for college, took the opportunity to go stealth, and never acknowledged the 20 years of life I had lived before that because it would have destroyed the illusion. A few years later I basically forgot myself; it took almost a year and a partial psychiatric hospitalization to break out of the dissociation, remember the first 20 years of my life, and process emotions normally.
What pushed me toward detransition was a combination of things: the constant anxiety of keeping stealth and passing, even though I passed very well and was never clocked as trans after starting T and moving to a new city; having to hide that I was biologically female and had grown up as a girl, including experiences of sex-based violence, which meant cutting pieces of myself off; realizing how lonely being a man was (women didn't talk to me because approaching strange men isn't safe, men didn't talk to me because they had no reason to); and medical problems — I started losing my hairline and got severe vaginal atrophy that was incredibly painful and could only be treated by inserting medication, which felt violating. Sometimes I would curl up on the bathroom floor and cry afterward. I eventually quit testosterone because the discomfort of having to insert the atrophy treatment had to be worse than the dysphoria of detransitioning. The fear of further masculinization eventually overpowered the fear of detransition.
I also came to believe transition hadn't fixed anything. I felt uncomfortable in the box I was born in and instead of working through that discomfort I medically altered my body to put myself in another box that was equally uncomfortable. Transitioning furthered my dissociation immensely despite initially thinking it was helping. My discomfort with being female existed because I was raised in a misogynistic environment, not because I was actually a man. Transition gave me a way to feel like I had some control over my body and life despite a shitty upbringing, but the depression came back in full swing once the novelty wore off.
I have a history of sexual abuse: 10+ years (elsewhere described as a decade and a half) of sexual abuse starting in elementary school, including an ex who drugged and raped me. I've been in therapy off and on since sixth grade, but when I was 18 I saw a therapist who was overtly creepy about the sexual trauma — saying I must enjoy pain during sex, that I was so traumatized only predators would ever love me, and referring to my ex raping me as "having his way with me." That has made it very hard to address the trauma in therapy. I also find body-focused therapies (physical therapy, ERP, EMDR) distressing rather than helpful; when I had to do atrophy treatments I would dissociate for hours afterward. I've looked for a support group but the only one in my area allows friends/partners/supporters including men who aren't survivors, and I've known men who got off on my trauma, so I don't feel safe there.
I am still extremely uncomfortable with my lower anatomy — I don't like acknowledging it by name, I won't touch it without gloves, and I still wish phalloplasty were feasible for me, though surgery is not feasible in my situation. I assume this discomfort relates to the sexual abuse and to American culture treating female genitalia as gross; the vast majority of men I've dated wouldn't go down on me because it was "gross," and the only people who didn't act disgusted were some of my most abusive partners. It makes me feel like a freak of a woman, though I don't think anyone else's body is gross.
I still have my breasts (I had a mastectomy? — no: I state I still have my breasts). I have an IUD for endometriosis and recently started the pill for PMDD. When I detransitioned, my prescribing doctor risked abandoning me and I became severely suicidal during my hormone crash; I had almost a year with essentially no sex hormones, with constant muscle and joint pain and suicidality so severe I had to be hospitalized until my estrogen levels returned to normal.
Permanent changes I regret: I sound like a gay man, I was on hormones young enough to masculinize my facial bone structure, and I've hit the ceiling on how much facial hair I can remove. I regret my transition deeply and say the transition was not worth it — I could have figured out how to comfortably be a gender-nonconforming woman without doing this to myself. I also feel guilty about ex-partners: at least seven or eight boyfriends transitioned while dating me during my transition, most of whom have since detransitioned. Some came out and were rejected by family; one lost his job and was kicked off his sports team. I feel complicit in damaging these men.
On transition for others: I no longer believe anyone is intrinsically any gender — I think it's a made-up concept to create different social roles for different sexes. I don't believe in legally controlling what people do with their bodies, but medicalization shouldn't be pushed, standards need to be better ($50 template letters shouldn't approve surgery), doctors shouldn't push hormones, and side effects need to be stated far more clearly (my endocrinologist didn't even recognize vaginal atrophy). I still use the name and pronouns people want, and I've told people who came to me for advice that liking girl's TV shows or taking 'instagram baddie' selfies doesn't make you a woman. I'll discuss and keep it civil. I advise teenagers considering transition to treat depression first (and get screened for PMDD) and to spend time as an adult with real control over their life before making a massive decision — that's something I could have written myself at that age.