14살에 자각하고 17살에 디트랜지션
여성 · 단념첫 성별 불쾌감 13 → 사회적 전환 17 → 데시스턴스 17145
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 13~14세경부터 트랜스로 정체화한 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 16~17세에 온라인 극좌 서클에서 목소리 높은 트랜스 옹호자가 되었고, 17세에 집을 나온 후, 일부는 2021년 여름의 관계를 통해, 부재한 아버지가 남긴 공허를 채우려 했음을 깨닫고 트랜스가 아님을 알았습니다. 이제 약혼자와 약혼한 여성으로 편안히 살며, 소년 같은 취미를 유지하면서 '약혼자의 미래 아내'가 되는 것을 받아들입니다. 미성년자에게 호르몬이나 사춘기 차단제를 주는 것에 강하게 반대하며 연령 하한은 21이어야 한다고 주장하고, 우리의 존재를 지우는 사람들에 맞서 디트랜지셔너의 가시성을 옹호합니다. 디트랜지션 이후 자살 사고나 자해 이력은 밝히지 않았습니다.
전체 이야기
I first realized I was in similar shoes when I was 13-14, and I ended up telling everyone I was trans. I got deeply into the internet starting in 2017, particularly far-left circles, and I fell into this hole of transitioning. By 2020-2021 I was doing presentations about how I felt and why I was trans — I even have videos of it, though I can't bring myself to watch them anymore. I was so sure I was trans that I became regarded as the expert in my wider social circle; people sent their friends who felt like they were trans to me for advice, and people trusted me and believed I wanted the best for everyone, and I really did mean no harm. But I was only 16-17 at the time — way too young to be giving lectures on being trans or helping others on their journey. I didn't know anything about anything.
What I eventually realized was the real reason behind my wish to transition: I wanted to fill the shoes my dad left. He was always away, and he raised me partially like his son, which made me tomboyish. Once he moved away and I started using the internet more, trans influences made me believe that taking hormones and living as a man would be the solution — to replace my dad, to fill the hole within me. But I really couldn't do it. I was just what I thought a guy would be like, a somewhat okay imitation of it. I wasn't really a guy, just a girl who tried her best to look like one and feel like one. I also realized I only wanted to be a handsome guy — a guy who isn't balding, with a full head of hair, conventionally handsome. I wouldn't want to be an ugly guy; I'd rather stay a girl than be an ugly guy.
It took me having to move out at 17 to realize that I really wasn't trans or anything. I had been living a very comfortable life, not having any worries besides what I'd do tomorrow, and I had zero idea about what life is really like. In the summer of 2021 I met a guy — the funniest, nicest man out there — and we really clicked and I started to fall in love with him. With that came trust, and as I started telling him how I felt and what I thought, finally having a strong male presence helped me see my reason for transitioning clearly.
I saw that deep down I still was a woman. I wanted to collect Squishmallows, paint my room pastel colors, make my Animal Crossing island cute, and look like a pretty woman. I might be behind on being a proper woman, but I'll never be as behind as trying to be a man when I don't even know what a man feels like or what one is like. I still like my more masculine hobbies and I still go out and have mostly male friends thanks to those hobbies, but I'm also my fiancé's future wife. I look pretty and act shy and cute because that's who I really am. If 2017 me saw myself today, she wouldn't believe it — she'd hate me because I'm here and not a man — but deep down she would be happy that we ended up a womanly woman and learned to accept ourselves.
I found I am much more comfortable being a girl. It comes to me more naturally, I don't have to fake anything, and I enjoy it a lot more, even with its struggles and hardships; I prefer it to any life I could have had as a man. I can just be me with my boyishness and cute girl halves and no one cares, and I don't worry about passing because I'm just an average girl.
I never described specific medical interventions in detail in these posts, so I don't have a precise account of hormones or surgeries to give here. What I do know is how strongly I now feel about the process that led me toward transition and about young people today. I tell kids who are 13-16 not to transition and not to rush into anything irreversible, including hormone blockers, which I believe are not at all good for your health. I think a child, especially one with mental health issues, cannot think critically about this stuff, and the trans community affirms you no matter what — the answer is always 'Transition! It'll make your life better,' without knowing anything about the other person. I believe gender doctors should not give HRT out so easily, especially to people under 18 — in my view, not until someone is 21. Those extra few years of waiting won't change much in an actual trans person's life, but they make all the difference in the life of someone who just believes they are trans.
I've also become critical of how detransitioners are treated. I find it horrible how they erase our existence and what we went through just to justify their views and push their agenda. Detransitioning is a very real thing, and all of us were negatively affected by how much they push for everyone who's even remotely different from gender stereotypes to be trans — and then they criticize us for not being trans. I've completely left and blocked everything in the trans community, so I'm not up to date on the lingo anymore. I'm skeptical of people who come into detrans communities with hostile angles, and I've told people that no one here is trying to attack them — people are trying to help to the best of their abilities based on personal experiences. I also think therapy is not a magic answer; a therapist can't give you the answer either, and from my experience no one can, not just in terms of detransitioning but everything in life.
On broader questions, I think that if transgenderism is a real disorder then it should be an insignificant minority in the world, and I'm frustrated that in the USA it's such a big deal where no one believes you can be gender non-conforming without being trans, while in the majority of the world no one cares that much. I've also reacted strongly to statistics about youth medical care, noting with horror that out of 315 kids, 2 died and the researchers just glance over that. I've offered to talk with young people who message me, telling them to give it time, look within themselves, see what inherently 'unmanly' things they do and like, and build up their womanhood from what they still have of it.