모든 이야기

20년 전 트랜스 모임에서 입을 막혔고 — 여전히 그 대가를 치른다

여성 · 단념603
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

나는 40대의, 디트랜스에 가깝지만 전환한 적 없는 부치 양성애자 여성이다 — 트랜스였던 적도 호르몬을 복용한 적도 없지만, 트랜스 감정을 가졌고 약 20년 전 한 트랜스 모임에 참석했다가 침묵당했다. 나는 DID/CPTSD, 자해(손목 긋기)와 해리 이력, DXM 중독이 있는 토목기사이며, 살아남기 위해 트라우마 치료가 필수적임을 알았다. 나는 성별 불쾌감이 가부장제에 대한 트라우마 반응이며 전환이 그것을 치료하지 않는다고 믿고, 젠더 비판적 공간과 디트랜스 공간에서 목소리를 내게 되었다. 나는 내 견해 때문에 온라인에서 살해와 강간 위협을 받았다. 현재 나는 여성으로 정체화하며 자기 수용, 글쓰기, 그리고 어쩌면 책을 쓰는 일에 매진하고 있다.

전체 이야기

I was born female and have always known I was a woman — I was never trans and never took hormones. I grew up in a feminist household, which meant I was introduced early to the concept of the male gaze, and I understood that my discomfort with my body and my new curves as a teen was rooted in the oppression women face rather than in my sex itself. I was a tomboy and a butch kid: I had body hair, walked like an athlete, spoke directly about science and math, rarely wore makeup, and rode my bike alone at night to escape being the only girl in my neighborhood crew. Around age 9 I came up with the line 'my bike is a girl's bike cuz it's mine.' I was forced into 'womanly things' by the world around me from age 3 onward, and magazines like Vogue, Cosmo, Seventeen and Sassy 'made sales by pedaling poison.' I am a civil engineer with a bachelor's degree and I am a Fellow of my professional organization. I have worked in heavily male-dominated fields and describe myself as highly spatially, mechanically and mathematically inclined. Around 20 years before mid-2022 — so roughly the early 2000s — I went to my first trans meeting and had an awakening: I found the room was all men defining women through a misogynistic lens, with no other woman present, and when I tried to speak about my own trans feelings I was silenced, both by them and by men talking over me. That experience, plus growing up before the internet and being a feminist at a young age, is why I never transitioned; I have said that if transition had been offered to me as a teenager, or if I had not been such a young feminist, I might have. I have been a drag king performer and would 'pass without even trying.' Since I started dressing how I wanted and cut my hair, I get 'sir'd' regularly and I love the thrill of it. I describe myself as a butch, bisexual, masculine woman. I have been highly attracted to butch women, and I say that butch women are what turns me on most. I have a brother I was close to growing up ('Jem Joad'), and I describe us as far from being understood by anybody. I have been diagnosed with DID (I describe myself as a 'proud D.I.D.er' who is now 'a person with organized, associated identities') and CPTSD stemming from childhood trauma. I have body dysphoria that is explicitly not gender-related, dissociation, and a history of cutting and self-harm. I have been addicted to DXM (dextromethorphan cough gels/liquid, up to 900mg, $7 a bottle) and have struggled to get off it; I have said I was 'so fucked up on drugs and anger and isolation' at one point that my perspective was completely twisted, and I once came back to apologize to someone I had been mean to. I have done trauma therapy, including dissociative-focused therapy, and I say that working on root causes in therapy 'is the only way I could stay alive.' I have used journaling, meditation, and talking out thoughts as coping tools, and I currently use cannabis ('my ether stick,' 'dabbing lite'). I bought a small house with 'every single fucking dime I had' and am glad I did, though I cannot yet afford to fix it; I describe sitting in my house and backyard 'screaming at sparrows.' I am in my 40s (I say 'I am 43' in one 2020 comment and 'perhaps because I am older, in my 40s' later). I have been through many attacks online, including death threats and 'verbal and pictorial rapings' from trans ideologues after I was called a TERF within my first day on Reddit — an accusation I found odd at the time. I say I have been through a lot of attacks, though not because of looking like a boy when I was a girl. I wrote a poem, 'Mine to Decide' (first draft April 12, 2020), in which I write 'gender is a prison,' 'I am xx, my sex is female,' and 'I was never a boy.' I have said I think I am on the way to writing a book but am trying to get over the confidence hump. I have recommended trauma therapy, body-centered therapy, and treatments overlapping with those for eating disorders, self-harm and OCD to others with dysphoria, and I have urged people not to pursue body modifications until they have done thorough psychological work with trauma-trained therapists. I have been critical of transition for others: I have said 'dysphoria is a traumatic response to our patriarchal, misogynistic culture,' that 'the solution is to treat the trauma, not validate delusions,' that 'dysphoria is not treatable with surgery,' and that 'trans is a misogynistic cult ideology' and 'trans cannot exist in science, in nature.' I have also said 'Trans is basically conversion therapy for being GNC and probably gay.' I have been an active commenter in gender-critical and detrans spaces, encouraging people to tell their stories publicly, and I have advocated for women's inclusion and against what I see as woman-erasure in language. I have expressed sadness over post-surgery loss of nipple sensation, asking detailed questions about nerve function after top surgery. I have been combative in online arguments and have acknowledged that fighting online is something I do and am trying to learn to stop.