196cm, 그리고 패싱하는 여성이 되기를 거부했다
남성 · 탈전환2.6천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 짧고 효과 없는 에스트로겐 미량 투여 외에는 의료적 트랜지션을 한 적이 없는 디트랜지션한 게이 남성으로, 주로 194cm의 키가 패스를 불가능하게 만들었기 때문에 디시스트했습니다. 호모포비아 환경에서 젠더 비순응적으로 자랐고, 이성애 여성으로 살며 이성애 로맨스를 경험하고 싶어 트랜지션에 가까워졌지만, 의료적 개입이 아니라 자기 인식을 통해 스스로를 멈췄습니다. 이제 디트랜스 포럼에서 많은 시간을 보내며 호르몬의 비가역성, 재여성화의 메커니즘, 그리고 제가 트랜지션 욕구의 진짜 원인이라고 보는 것 — 사회적 전염, 오토호모에로티시즘, 성적 대상 정체성 역전 장애 — 에 대해 직설적이고 때로 가혹한 조언을 합니다. 젊은이들에게 트랜지션이 홍보되는 것과 자녀의 이성 호르몬 요구를 긍정하는 부모에게 매우 비판적이면서도, 그 한계를 이해하는 좁은 범주의 사람들에게 트랜지션이 허용될 수 있다고 주장합니다. 아직 사적으로 여장하고 전신 전기분해를 받았지만, 게이 남성으로 정체화하며 리트랜지션 계획은 없습니다.
전체 이야기
I was born male and I am gay. I never went through with a medical transition, but I came very close to it, and looking back I can see how easily it could have happened.
Growing up, I was gender non-conforming. I was always more drawn to femininity than to the masculinity that was expected of me, and I struggled with that in a fairly homophobic environment. I now think a lot of that discomfort got reframed for me as gender dysphoria — as though the problem was that I was in the wrong body rather than that I was a gay boy in an environment that made being gay feel impossible. I also watched a lot of straight pornography as a kid in what I described as an attempt to "cure" myself of my gayness, but it backfired: I ended up fantasizing about being the woman in the scene, which only made me more dysphoric. Later, when I tried gay porn, I found it unappealing because it seemed hedonistic and non-romantic, so I kept returning to "female-friendly" straight porn focused on intimacy and romance — always imagining myself as the woman rather than the man.
For a long time I was motivated to go MtF by a very romanticized view of what living as a woman in a heterosexual relationship would be like. I wanted the social changes — I wanted to be in a relationship with a man, but I couldn't imagine doing that as a man myself. I think that's the core of it: I wanted to live as what I saw as a "regular" straight woman, with all the romance I associated with that.
What stopped me was, frankly, my body. I'm 6'5''. I realized I had absolutely zero chance of ever passing — I would have been, in my own words, "a crossdressing NFL linebacker." I said that had I been under 6' and more of an ectomorph, I may very well have actually transitioned through hormones and surgeries. Had I been 6 inches shorter, I probably would have "trooned out," but I was too self-aware to live as a hopelessly unpassable 6'5'' person. So I desisted before ever starting hormones or having any surgeries.
I did, however, microdose on estrogen at one point — it was too little and too infrequent to have any significant effects, but it means I technically count as detransitioned. I also mentioned at one point that I was "currently having full-body electrolysis hair removal," and I still do things like crossdress in private and remove my body hair. I've come to accept that I'm better off living as a gay man than wasting time and resources chasing what I now see as a pipe dream.
I've thought a lot about why transition appeals to people like me, and I've developed a fairly specific framework for it. I believe the main drivers are: Erotic Target Identity Inversion Disorder, which underlies autogynephilia and autoandrophilia — the tendency to try to turn yourself into what you sexually desire; GNC homosexuals who feel their life would be easier if they presented as a typical straight person of the opposite sex; and autohomoeroticism — fetishizing opposite-sex homosexual relationships, which I think is especially common among heterosexual women who want to experience romance with men as men themselves. I've also argued that a lot of FtM transitioners are influenced by MLM/Yaoi media and by attractive young FtM influencers, and that they end up expecting to become a "kawaii teenage twink" while actually ending up as something quite different.
I'm very critical of how transition is promoted. I've said repeatedly that you cannot actually change your sex — you can only pass through superficial body modifications — and that this is the fundamental problem with transition. I've argued that the 40-fold increase in FtM transitioners since 2010 indicates a social contagion, and I've compared it to historical witch-hunts where people came to believe things that weren't true because of collective suggestion. I've also said that gender dysphoria and its consequences only exist because transition is available; had it not been, virtually all transitioners would simply have lived as gender non-conforming but otherwise normal people.
I'm also critical of parents who affirm a child's transition demands. I've said that parents who cave in to an 11- or 13-year-old's demands to transition have failed in their role, and that a parent's job is to do what's best for the child, not to be their friend. I've blamed parents who approved cross-sex hormones for their young teenagers, and I've asked detransitioners whether they blame their relatives or healthcare professionals for affirming rather than helping with underlying mental health issues.
I've given a lot of practical advice to people considering or going through detransition: stop testosterone until you've made up your mind, since most effects are irreversible anyway and you can continue passing in the meantime; the irreversible changes are voice, body and facial hair, hairline recession, and clitoral enlargement, while fat redistribution, muscle growth rate, and fertility/menstruation will reverse; fat redistribution takes up to two years; you can speed re-feminization by losing and then regaining weight so that new fat is distributed in a female pattern; waxing is better than shaving for facial hair; minoxidil can help with hair regrowth but finasteride won't work once you're off testosterone; and you should get your hormone levels checked after quitting. I've also recommended being open with people about your detrans status to preempt gossip.
On mental health, I've said that testosterone isn't the most potent anti-anxiety substance available and that numbing yourself with it isn't a solution — the world doesn't become less hostile just because you quit. I've recommended cognitive behavioral therapy and exposure therapy for anxiety, and I've suggested social media detoxes and getting a daily routine in order while detransitioning. I've also advised people to get professional help rather than relying on hormones to manage depression.
I've been blunt, sometimes harshly so, in my comments — I've called people's transition reasoning stupid, told someone they looked like a "pooner caricature," and described someone as looking like "the bearded lady from the circus freakshow" (though I later edited that statement and apologized, saying I was genuinely bemused rather than intending to be cruel). I've also been supportive in moments: I've told people they're normal now, that they should admit they made a mistake but not let others humiliate them, and that since there's no going back it's a matter of learning from it and making the best of the situation.
I've talked people out of suicide, telling them that suicidal tendencies come in waves and that they should keep calm for a week and it will pass, and I've told someone not to drown themselves at Christmas because their relatives would suffer. I've also advised someone whose problems were loneliness and a NEET lifestyle rather than transgenderism to go outside and touch grass.
On the question of whether transition is ever acceptable, I've taken a somewhat nuanced position: I've said that if someone has analyzed it carefully, understands they cannot actually become the opposite sex, treats it as a feminizing body modification to pass socially, and concludes it would lead to a net quality of life increase, then it's acceptable — but they should think long and hard and take all risks into account first. I've said the best candidates for transition are GNC homosexuals who have a realistic chance of passing, understand what transition can and cannot do for them, and want to live a fairly traditional life as a typical heterosexual member of the opposite sex.
I've also discussed my own sexuality in detail. I'm gay, I'm not sexually attracted to women, and I've said I'm better off living as a gay man. I've described myself as a gay incel at one point. I've noted that among male homosexuals there seems to be a greater willingness to reject queer culture and assimilate into mainstream society, which I contrast with AGP/AAP transgenders who seem to embrace separatism.
As for my current status: I desisted, I never had any surgeries, I never took testosterone, I only microdosed estrogen briefly with no significant effects, and I identify as a gay man. I still crossdress privately and remove my body hair, and I've had full-body electrolysis. I'm critical of transition for most people but not absolutely opposed to it in principle for the right candidates.