모든 이야기

11세부터 성별 불쾌감, 전환 없음 — 대신 심리치료

여성 · 단념1.1천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 의학적 트랜지션을 한 적은 없지만 어린 시절부터 10대까지 심한 성별 불쾌감을 겪은 디트랜지션/디시스트 이성애 여성입니다. 제 불쾌감은 내면화된 여성혐오와 성차별적 고정관념, 다른 여자아이들과 어울리지 못함, 11세부터의 심한 월경통, 10대 초반의 성적 학대, 여성 생리의 평가절하에서 비롯되었습니다. 수년간의 대화 치료가 자기혐오와 분노를 극복하는 데 도움이 되었고, 지금은 아주 평범한 시스 여성으로 정체화하지만 가끔 재발하기도 합니다. 생리를 멈추기 위해 데소게스트렐을 복용하고, ADHD는 설트랄린과 메틸페니데이트로 치료받고 있습니다. 지금은 젠더 의학에 비판적이며 확언보다 탐구적 치료를 옹호합니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female and grew up identifying as a girl, but from as early as I can remember I 'saw' myself as a boy in my thoughts — as a young schoolkid I would ponder that 'me as a girl' just felt strange, not at home, not 'like me.' Growing up, gender roles and stereotypes about my sex — internalised misogyny — were a huge part of my distress. When I was young, sexist tropes were the backbone of pop culture; magazines and public media regurgitated gender stereotypes all day long, shaming women who failed to match up: how to diet because you're fat, how to always smile and be pretty because no one wants an ugly hag, how to read your guy's mind and care for him or he'll run for another, how to make a quick healthy meal after work or you're a bad mom. It didn't feel optional, and people around me didn't understand why I hated it so much. I ended up feeling 'not like the other girls' — not in the misogynistic sense, since I was a feminist and hated how feminine things were derided, but thinking 'maybe I am a weirdo and meant to be something else, because clearly a woman isn't what I feel like.' I never really felt like being 'one of the girls' and was missing a sense of belonging. Most of my friends were male, but in all-male groups you end up being 'the girl' sometimes, which I found hurtful and alienating. The more I progressed into puberty, the more 'becoming a woman' felt like a curse. I suffered severe dysmenorrhea since I was 11 — on a very awful level, with cramps, stabbing pain and suicidal thoughts — and was frustrated at being weaker than men, at the possibility of being raped and pregnant, at not wanting to be seen as vulnerable. I hated being 'designed as a baby machine.' My mother and other women kept bringing up 'me having a baby someday,' as if the womanly desire to be a mother must be in me. My anatomy and female parts disgusted me, which I connect to having been sexually abused as a young teen. Deep down I still felt that being female made me physiologically 'deficient,' even though I consciously believed otherwise. I also grew up with a somewhat bulky, muscular figure and a square face that in my perception was 'neither one or the other,' and thought if at least I were a man it would match both my character and frame. I also had an annoyingly high sex drive, complete with porn sessions, that was often 'nearly unmanageable.' I had OCD-like features when I was depressive. I also have ADHD, which includes fogginess, plus anxiety and depression, and benefited hugely from low-dosed sertraline and methylphenidate. I have been on ADHD meds for years. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgery. I did, however, go to a registry office about changing my name: hearing my birth name made me physically hurt and nauseous back then, and the euphoria with my new one didn't last long either; I didn't go back, which saved me some money. What moved me toward desistance was talk therapy, where I worked through all my self-hate and anger over years. I had projected my whole negative self-image onto my name — it stood for 'the dumb ugly clumsy cringy nerd asspie failure of a girl that I thought I was.' I learned to forgive myself and sympathise with that hurt girl, though it took years. Meeting another girl with the same name, who loved it, also made me wonder why it didn't seem bad on her. I also dug up, during therapy, that my dysphoria partly stemmed from an underlying devaluation of female anatomy — I felt being physiologically weaker was somehow inferior, though I would have staunchly denied it; facing that truth was cringe-inducing but ultimately made me come out stronger and mostly at peace with my biological reality. I have had relapses from time to time; for example, training once triggered my last bigger dysphoria relapse because it reminded me how different my female body is from men's, and therapy was priceless in helping me digest that anger. I still have 'the same dumb angsty ghosts' rising from their graves periodically over 20+ years of ruminating gender crap. I took desogestrel, a progesterone-like micropill, for years to get rid of my periods (pain-related), and I'm still on it — I'll never go back. I also found Celexa (citalopram) killed my sex urge efficiently, though the libido-killing effect was ultimately too much for me. I currently identify as a straight cis woman — 'not even a lesbian' — and describe myself as a desister. I work in the trades and have a boyfriend, also in trades, and we work as a team. I am German and my language is heavily gendered, which makes pronoun politics a practical pain. I am a scientist by background, with a solid general background in biology/biomedicine and human physiology. I am a leftist and most of my friends fully support the gender narrative or go silent when I raise concerns, including about my own experience; I've accepted they're not useful in that regard. I have no children and don't want any. I still struggle at times with my female physiology — my womb doesn't offer much for me and a bunch of muscles would be more convenient — and I still resent the physical strength difference a bit, but I take a pragmatic view: we're only mammals dealt a random card before birth. I also have lordosis (swayback) that came with puberty and get into fitness routines to manage it, plus frequent UTIs. I am critical of transition for others: I don't believe 'true trans' in the wrong-body sense exists, I think gender medicine is experimental and often irreversible, that there is no objective way to tell 'true trans' from underlying issues, and that therapy exploring underlying causes (CBT, talk therapy, gender exploratory therapy) is the only responsible route. I have advocated for detrans visibility, criticised the USTS 2015 statistics for excluding detransitioners, argued against the 'always ask pronouns' practice, and defended the sub's moderation against political fuel. I have no regret of not transitioning — I concluded a new identity or body would be a futile path for me.