모든 이야기

팬데믹 시기의 이별 — 그리고 전환에 대한 마음의 변화

여성 · 단념275
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

나는 브라질에 사는 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 트랜스 파트너와 사귀면서 전환할지 말지를 두고 갈등했고, 이후 팬데믹 동안 그 관계와 트랜스 운동 모두로부터 분리되어 전환하고 싶은 마음 없이 내 몸에 편안함을 느끼게 되었다. 지금은 단지 건강한 여성이 되고 싶고, 후회 없이 트랜스 친구들을 유지하고 싶으며, 생각을 바꾼 것을 감사히 여긴다. 나는 의료 시스템에 회의적이다 — 트랜스 수술과 의사들의 여성 건강에 대한 잘못된 처우가 내 견해의 주요 요인이었다. 나는 내면화된 여성혐오, 사회적 전염, 그리고 여전히 트랜스로 사는 사람들 사이의 후회에 대해 이야기한다. 나는 이 자료에서 어떤 수술, 호르몬, 자살 사고, 자해도 서술하지 않았다.

전체 이야기

I have been active on the detrans subreddit for quite some time, and over that time I have read many different stories of detransitioners — some of whom were happy and confident for many years before they started to regret it. That breadth of experience shaped my view: I came to believe it is impossible to know if one is TRULY trans. I live in Brasil. Before I made my own decision, I was struggling with whether or not to transition while I was dating a trans person, and I felt a lot of jealousy and resentment toward them. On top of that, my partner did not support any of my decisions. My ex and I were constantly being asked if we were trans — one person kept insisting that my ex was in the closet. What actually moved me was putting distance between myself and the trans movement for a while, including every trans person and trans-allies around me. The pandemic helped with that separation. I broke up with my trans ex-partner. After some time, and after looking at gender with a whole new perspective — this subreddit helped a lot — my feelings changed drastically. Now I feel comfortable with my body, I have no wish to transition at all, and the only modification I want is just to be a fit woman. I also have trans friends with whom I can be, feeling no remorse or regrets. Actually the opposite: I see my trans friends having gender issues and trying to prove themselves so hard and suffering because of it, and all of that makes me feel that I absolutely made the right decision — it makes me thankful that I quit and changed my mind. I do not think that would have been possible if I had stayed in that relationship. I have also reflected on how detransition and regret are more common than they admit. I suspect many people feel defeated when no one shows support, and are told by professionals that they need testosterone for health issues and can't go back anymore. Maybe they live in constant "I chose this myself and I have no options now, I need to live like this and hope no one knows I regret." I have asked myself how many people who still live as trans are only doing so because of social shame — having spent your whole life fighting society, family and friends, letting go of dear relationships, and facing so much hardship, admitting it was not worth it is such a hard path that many choose to live in denial instead. On bodily and medical matters, I told another person that I could immediately tell they were female, that they should do what is best for their mental and physical health, and that their body would have the fat return naturally to female places after a while. On the question of whether sex is a spectrum, I said I see it as the same as saying the number of human arms is a spectrum because some people have less or more than two. I agreed that social contagion is real. Two major factors shaped my skepticism. One was how trans surgeries "blackpilled" me on the "science" and doctors in general — but the major one, I said, is how hellish female health is treated by doctors. I also noted the irony that males are invading women's spaces while spaces that were always gay male culture are being invaded by females. On culture and sexuality, I discussed yaoi and yuri at length: I said yaoi was created by women to women to fetishize gay men, but that it is comprehensible that gay men are into and wish they could reclaim yaoi and BL, because so much gay-oriented media is either mindless porn with no romance, pop shows where they fanboy woman divas, or drag shows. I argued yuri, unlike yaoi, was started by female for female audience and in Japan is still like this in the non-sexual form, and that yuri does not mean sexual comics — for many years it was mostly romance between women, though nowadays, especially with westernization, most yuri found online is porn made by men for men, which I called a corruption of the culture. I also noted the history of female-only theatre in Japan as a huge success for both lesbian and straight women for decades. Regarding Brasil specifically, I explained that "she-gays" were always a thing, but for most of history they still identified as men — the feminine ones, even those who crossdressed a lot, were still gay men, and very masculine gay men open about being gay would use she pronouns, which somehow correlated more with feminine culture. Recently, after the trans boom, most gay men who are not extremely masculine started coming out as non-binary; I said trans culture changed everything. About lesbians, there were some who used masculine pronouns, especially the very butch-like ones — I remember it was common for them to be called "husband" by their partner, which I attributed to internalized shame of being in a homosexual relationship. Now, I said, every young woman, even the heterosexual ones, don't want to be women anymore, because of internalized misogyny. I have offered practical advice to others in difficult spots: to someone worried about being read as trans at college, I suggested remaining socially trans while at that college (bad for mental health but good for finances) and, when people start noticing, saying you needed to stop because of health issues — a very good reason, since some people who are still trans really do go through that — and, if anyone questions further, making a crying face and saying you don't want to talk about it. I have also complimented others' appearance to reassure them (telling one person they were graceful and stylish, another that they don't look like a caveman at all and are pretty), and I told someone struggling that transition gives way more troubles than benefits.