모든 이야기

11살에 커밍아웃, 19살에 테스토스테론 — 그리고 20살에 중단

여성 · 탈전환전환 11 → 디트랜지션 20340
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 11세에 커밍아웃하고 19세에 테스토스테론을 시작해 2024년 5월에 약 1.5년 후 중단한 디트랜지션한 여성(ftmtf)입니다. 짧은 후회 시기를 겪었지만 이제 여성으로 — 특히 마스큘린하고 중성적인 레즈비언으로 — 스스로를 받아들이고, 외모에서 사회적으로 디트랜지션하지 않은 채 트랜스 라벨을 버렸습니다. T로 인한 신체 변화(깊은 목소리, 체모와 얼굴 털)를 후회하지 않으며 사회에서 계속 남성으로 인식되고, 그것에 평화를 느낍니다. 일반적으로 일부 사람들의 트랜지션은 여전히 지지하지만 FTM 커뮤니티가 얼마나 외모 중심이 되었는지에는 비판적입니다. 디트랜지션 이후 보고된 자살 사고나 자해는 없습니다.

전체 이야기

I came out as trans in 7th grade, at 11 years old, and presented masculine from that point on — I cut my hair short and never let it grow out again. My family was mostly supportive at the time, though as I got older it became clear they'd expected me to grow out of what they saw as a phase. I voice-trained from around age 11 as well, which means my deep voice and masculine speaking patterns are now just my natural way of talking. I started testosterone at 19, just out of high school, in early 2023. I was on it for about a year and a half before stopping in mid-May 2024 to observe how I felt. During that time I passed as male socially and was never questioned by peers, though I suspect I'm probably clockable to a trained eye. I'm a licensed skin therapist by profession, so skincare has always mattered to me — I never went cold turkey on it even while dealing with cystic acne on T. Around May 2024, at almost 20 years old, I started seriously questioning whether transition was right for me. A few things converged: testosterone widened my face, gave me cystic acne, enlarged my pores, sped up visible aging, and receded my hairline somewhat. Seeing other trans men online — greasy, unkempt, overweight, wearing crop tops and dresses — unsettled me and made me confront how T was changing my own appearance. I realized I'd been using the fact that I identified as trans pre-TikTok as a crutch to prove I wasn't just following a trend, but that assurance no longer felt solid. My immediate family still calls me 'she' and my birth name in public, which I told them was fine because it's my transition, not theirs — but strangers and acquaintances get confused by my female name when I almost completely pass as male, and that causes me embarrassment. My parents have told me they miss their little girl and their tomboy, which crushes me because I'm very family-oriented. I avoid my extended family's phone calls because I know my voice will make them uncomfortable even though they know about my transition. I stopped hormones two weeks before my late-May 2024 posts and three months before my July 2024 post. I went through a short phase of regret after stopping, and I do wish I had waited to start hormones. I also wish I had allowed myself to experiment with femininity before T, because now I feel it's too late to dip my toes into it the way I could have pre-T. Detransitioning socially would take 'leaps and bounds' because of how deep my voice is and how masculinized my natural speaking patterns are. I was scared of shaving off my facial hair because it felt like a security blanket. By late May 2024 I was leaning toward detransition, reframing my experience as possibly being 'a lesbian and mistaking my insecurities growing up for gender dysphoria.' I said I could see myself as a woman, just a very androgynous/masculine one, and that I don't think I'll ever be a feminine woman nor necessarily want to be. I said I'd just be butch if I detransitioned and wasn't too worried about being conventionally attractive as a woman. I was considering laser hair removal if I detransitioned. By early July 2024, three months off T, I had dropped the trans label entirely and no longer talk about being trans. I accept myself as a woman (ftmtf) and can look in the mirror and tell myself I am a woman without feeling disgusted or phony. I don't regret the changes HRT gave me — I enjoy my deeper voice, body hair, and a little facial hair. I don't plan on correcting people who call me Marshall or refer to me in masculine terms, and I still use the men's restroom out of respect for women who'd be uncomfortable with me in theirs. I live in a southern, conservative state, not surrounded by queer bubbles, and I mesh well with people there — I have a healthy, sober lifestyle, my own career, and a thriving social life. I described myself as happy in 'No Man's Land.' I generally still believe in the benefits of transitioning for certain people, but I think a large portion of the FTM community is heavily dependent on the aesthetic changes of hormones. I acknowledged I may have fallen into the same trap when I started HRT, and that my second thoughts about trans men's appearances may have come from my own second thoughts about my transition. I asked openly whether my current peace could be a cope, though I don't think it is.