4살부터의 성별 불쾌감 — 그리고 전환이 없는 나라
여성 · 단념2.7천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 중단한(desisted) 여성입니다 — 4~5세부터 성별 불쾌감이 있었지만 보수적인 동유럽 출신국에서 전환이 불가능했기에 의학적 전환을 한 적 없는, 남성적이고 이성애자인 25세입니다. 젠더는 개념으로서 존재하지 않고 나는 실제 남성이 될 수 없다는 추론을 통해 중단에 이르렀고, 따라서 지금은 전적으로 제 여성 신체에 근거해 여성으로 정체성을 인식합니다. 여전히 성별 불쾌감을 관리 가능한 배경 소음으로 경험하며, CBT 치료, 우울증 약(양극성 2형 가능성), 그리고 일과 우정과 자원봉사로 주의를 돌리는 것으로 다룹니다. 자기남성애, 하체 성별 불쾌감, 그리고 종종 제가 남성으로 통과하게 해 주는 남성적 외모가 있고, 신체적 편안함을 위해 유방 축소를 고려하고 있습니다. 젠더 이론과 긍정 치료에 비판적이지만 성인의 신체 개조 권리는 지지합니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and I live in Eastern Europe — I've said I'm Russian, in a country with active anti-LGBT laws and real homophobia. I'm 25 now (as of my posts in 2025-2026).
My earliest memory of wanting to be a boy is from around age 4-5, when I got confused for a boy on a playground and it left me perplexed. I've said those thoughts are 'one of my earliest memories.' I was a massive tomboy growing up, and by 16 it got really severe. I never medically transitioned — partly because transition is essentially unavailable in my country, and partly because I didn't know about transgenderism as a concept until halfway through my teens. I was diagnosed with depression as a teen and got into a non-affirming therapist who worked with me on the depression side of things rather than affirming any trans identity. I've said that being cut off from affirming care ironically 'saved me' — that if I'd been born in the West I would have been 'the perfect case' and 'perfect prey' for gender-affirming care, since I check essentially every supposed box for being 'trans for real.'
My dysphoria began to fade around 20-21, and I've described 16-20 as the worst period of my mental health, with things improving markedly by 23. I now identify as a desisted woman — a masculine, straight woman. I never came out publicly; I lived 'as if' I was trans in some sense but couldn't come out in my country. I've said I 'self-identified myself out of being trans' by coming to believe that gender as a concept doesn't exist.
Causes and contributors: I've reflected a lot on where my dysphoria came from. I grew up in a very unstable, abusive household — the abuse wasn't targeted directly at me but I was 'collateral damage.' I was raised pretty gender-neutral, 'almost like I was the son,' so outside the family my being different was more apparent. I associate my masculine identification as a self-protection mechanism — femininity felt unsafe and like weakness because it wouldn't have protected me back then. I have internalized misogyny and sexist beliefs about what women can be. I live in a sexist country where being seen as a woman was rough and unappealing, and the image of 'a woman' seemed shallow compared to what I felt. I have a masculine face (people said I look like my dad) and a curvy body, and I pass as a man fairly often even without hormones. I also have autoandrophilia (AAP) — I discovered this about a year ago — and bottom dysphoria, which I say is less common in females. At puberty I realized my attraction to men was more masculine and dominant than other girls', and I felt like I 'gazed on them like a man would on a woman,' so identifying as a 'gay man' felt easier because it had representation, whereas extremely masculine heterosexual women are invisible. I was heavily in fandom and consumed mlm/gay porn as a teen, which I believe exacerbated my dysphoria — I've said porn 'did a pretty heavy damage on me as a teen.' I also have other mental illnesses: officially diagnosed with depression, in therapy for about 11 years, on medication, and currently discussing with a new therapist the possibility of bipolar 2 (I say I'm 'like 90% sure'), with a past suspicion of cyclothymia. I note my most dysphoric times fell during depressive episodes.
Process toward desisting: I never set out to transition, but I was planning to migrate and possibly identify as a man somewhere that would believe me. What stopped me was coming to believe that gender doesn't exist as a concept — I reasoned that I can't 'feel like a man' because I've never been male, and that any such feeling is my female body making an interpretation. I've described this as a rational, logical conclusion. I also realized transition wouldn't give me an actual male body with working male genitals, which is what I actually want, so it would only accentuate the problem. I found CBT therapy very helpful — it works with underlying beliefs rather than just feelings. I also credit time, aging, medication for depression, and redirecting my attention outward to hobbies, work, volunteering, and friendships. I've said I 'disenchanted' myself from gender by pure reason.
Medical: I never took hormones. I never had any surgeries. I am currently considering a breast reduction — I have a very large chest (H cup) and want to go down to about a C cup — primarily for physical comfort reasons (can't sleep comfortably, can't run, back pain) rather than dysphoria, and I've set a one-year waiting period before pursuing it. I've said this would be the only 'medical' thing I inflict on my body. I've discussed vaginal atrophy as something that put testosterone off the table for me.
Mental health: I have depression (officially diagnosed), possible bipolar 2, and lifelong dysphoria. I've said dysphoria is 'a habit in my brain' that has lessened but probably won't fully disappear — I aim for neutrality rather than happiness about my sex. I've had suicidal thoughts in the past but said that my reasoning about gender and reality actually stopped them — I reasoned I can't know death is what I want since I've never experienced it, so 'my ill brain is lying to me.' I'm currently on medication and in therapy.
Adversity: Unstable, abusive household as a child; sexism and objectification growing up; depression from a young age; living in a homophobic/transphobic country.
Social: I have a small circle of friends who know my views and accept me as a masculine woman. My mother knows about my thoughts. My father was emotionally unavailable, dismissive, and treated me like a 'project' rather than a daughter — I've limited contact with him and made sure I have documents to go no-contact if needed. I'm pretty isolated in terms of community — there's no detrans community in my country. I'm a virgin at 25 with almost no dating experience; I've kissed about three times, once with a woman to test attraction (I'm straight). Men generally don't find me attractive because of my masculine presentation, which makes romantic life hard and lonely.
Sexuality: I'm straight — attracted to men, with a masculine/dominant attraction. I like masculine men. I've said a lot of my 'gender envy' was actually heterosexuality — the 'do I want to be him or be with him' confusion. I relate to mlm media because there's no representation of masculine straight women. I have AAP tendencies.
Regret: I don't regret transition since I never medically transitioned. I do express frustration at lost time and the confusion of my teen years, but I've said I'm in a far better place now than at 16. I don't describe intense regret — more relief that I didn't go further.
Outcomes: I'm now a desisted, masculine, straight woman. I live openly as a woman while maintaining masculine presentation and often passing as a man. I work in art and craft, volunteer, work out, and have a few close friends. I describe my current quality of life as much improved — 'healthy, pretty stable' — though I still experience dysphoria as background noise and have loneliness around dating.
Attitudes: I'm very critical of gender theory and the concept of gender itself, which I call 'garbage' and 'one of the top 5 worst things that happened to humankind.' I believe adults should have the right to body modifications but that transition shouldn't be presented as changing sex. I'm critical of medicalization of non-conforming youth, of affirming care, of the financial incentives of pharma, and of the lack of open discussion. I identify as politically libertarian and 'politically homeless.' I don't do formal activism but say that existing openly as a masculine woman is my way of 'tipping the scales a little.'