트랜스 남성이 아니라 시스 남성이 되고 싶었다
여성 · 단념684
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 여성으로 태어나 13세부터 ftm/논바이너리로 강하게 정체화했지만 의료적 트랜지션은 하지 않았고, 트랜스 남성으로 살기보다 시스 남성이 되고 싶었다는 것을 깨닫고 디시스트했습니다. 이제 여성으로 불리는 것이 편안한 젠더리스 급진적 페미니스트로 정체화하며, 남성 신체에 대한 바람은 아주 잠깐 스칠 뿐입니다. 기여 요인으로는 아들을 원했던 미소지니스트 아버지, 자폐/ADHD와 따돌림, 여성의 성적 대상화에 대한 두려움, 전부 트랜스 남성인 온라인 친구 집단, 심한 포르노 사용이 있었습니다. 포르노와 소셜 미디어를 끊어 자아 감각이 안정되었고, 이제 젠더를 의문시하는 청소년의 트랜지션에 대해 비판적으로 옹호합니다. 저는 현재 여성 신체와 삶에 평화를 느끼는 디트랜지션/디시스트한 여성입니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and grew up in a household where my father repeatedly told me he would have preferred a son; he was bitter that my mother gave birth to two daughters and constantly reminded me how much he wanted a boy. He pushed me hard to excel in school and sports, and when I didn't — because of depression — he told me it wouldn't be a problem if I were a boy. I distinctly remember the day I was caught looking at porn and he said, 'If you were a boy this would have been okay, but you're not, so...' I also recall him handing me a Carl Jung book when my depression surfaced in high school and telling me reading it would solve all my silly mental problems and that I didn't need therapy.
Pre-puberty, all my friends were boys and we played Star Wars at recess and talked about video games. I played with Hotwheels and Legos. After puberty, I was suddenly expected to be quiet, wear a bra, and follow double standards that boys did not, and I had to friendzone some boy crushes, which made me hate my new body. Friendships with boys stopped as soon as we all hit puberty, which felt very alienating, like my 'disgusting inherently sexual female body had betrayed me.' I was bullied a lot in school for being awkward and androgynous/hairy. I have Asperger's (high-functioning autism) and ADHD, which was once misdiagnosed as OCD. Due to sensory issues I can't handle uncomfortable feminine clothing or the sensation of makeup on my face, and I frequently miss subtle female social cues. This made me feel like a 'failed' woman.
I came out to my parents at 13. Even though it felt irreversibly catastrophic at the time, I kinda just cowered in the corner and didn't bring it up ever again and they silently accepted it as a phase. I strongly identified as ftm/nonbinary for a while. I was too scared to socially transition but I did experiment with wearing a binder in public, styling my hair, and switching pronouns among friends. I never had medical transition — no hormones, no surgery. I did experience a frightening incident while presenting male: a group of teenage boys started following me around a ferry boat calling me a faggot; I hid in the women's bathroom to cry and take off my binder.
Two things made me stop identifying as trans: realizing I'm allowed to be an unfeminine woman, and accepting that hormonal transition was not for me. There were things I liked about the idea of masculinization (more masculine body shape, deeper voice, escaping the male gaze) and things I absolutely did not want (male pattern baldness, acne, uterus atrophy, social/romantic rejection). I didn't want to live as a trans man, I wanted to live as a cis man, and I knew I wouldn't ever be happy spending my whole life aspiring towards a biologically impossible transformation. Online, all of my friends were/are trans men, which was a big factor in wanting to transition — I literally did not know anyone who felt comfortable being female. I also felt like I had a 'better chance' at love if I transitioned because I was bad at femininity. Friends were supportive even when I asked them to name me because I couldn't think of a good boy name; they are still my close friends after I desisted.
I describe myself as having desisted rather than detransitioned, since there was no medical transition. I currently identify as genderless (NOT agender — I do not recognize the existence of gender) and it's hard to explain to anyone who isn't a radfem. I say 'she/her is fine but I'm not cis.' It took me multiple years after desisting to regain an appreciation for my body and womanhood; I finally allowed myself to embrace other women, and that female solidarity led to embracing myself. I now say I love being born a woman; if a genie appeared I wouldn't even be wishing for a penis. Being socialized as a woman is part of my identity as a feminist killjoy. It doesn't feel like settling, it feels like I've returned home. Any desires to be a cis man are usually fleeting thoughts rooted in issues with my sexuality and being assertive in real life. Ten years after coming out, I explained becoming a radfem to my mom and she was like 'wow honey you're so mature'; my friends just went back to using female pronouns.
I was definitely pornsick during those trans/nonbinary years. I strongly preferred written homoerotica and hentai doujinshi because irl porn is depressing and gross. I started with light BDSM (especially femdom imagining myself as the submissive male) and quickly graduated to far more extreme material. All my kinks back then were related to transformation and loss of bodily autonomy — I imagined myself gang raped, tentacle raped, kidnapped, drugged, abducted by aliens, limbs amputated, brutally murdered, buried alive, hypnotized, bimbofied, transformed into an animal, secretly fed testosterone by my mistress, impregnated, and more. Nothing was too weird as long as I wasn't in control. I experimented with hypnosis in real life and discovered I'm highly suggestible. Looking back I think I was struggling to take responsibility for my life; I still struggle with making decisions and taking care of myself, but I recognize that's my job. Nowadays my fantasies are like chaste kisses and hand holding — thank god for quitting porn. I am a bisexual tomboy and feel insecure about my attraction to men; I always feel shocked when a man is into me because I feel like I'm bad at being woman.
I made the choice this year (2019) to permanently quit social media; I had a Twitter addiction so bad my brain started thinking in tweet format. Since quitting, my sense of self stabilized very quickly and I'm much more present experiencing daily beauty. I also quit porn. I've struggled with depression since high school. I practice mindfulness by walking outside, staring at clouds and sunsets and birds, drawing and writing stories about a woman who is my feminist power fantasy, and reading biographies. I worked at a preschool where every adult in the building was female and I felt totally safe and respected — my favorite job in the whole world, though I had to leave for reasons.
I consider 19-22 the most hellish and confusing years; after that it gets easier to exist. I was sincerely convinced at age 17 that I would commit suicide before age 20, but I am still alive 5 years later. I now believe gender dysphoria is a symptom of a sick society that needs to be taken seriously and addressed, but transitioning isn't right for everyone and it's important to look inwards and reconcile with your identity before any form of medical transition. I don't believe in brain sex; I fixed my gender distress by accepting I can't change my sex and choosing not to spend my life moping about wanting to be a boy. I occasionally fantasize about having a male body and sometimes do 'wish' I was trans, coping by presenting as androgynous as possible, but I'm not sure looking like a little boy in public is worth crushing my ribcage for a binder. I've become an active voice in the detrans/desisted community, offering advice to questioning teenagers, critiquing medical transition as an escape from unaddressed trauma, and pushing back against the idea that detransitioners are simply 'cis mistakes.' I consider coming out as detrans braver than it ever was to be trans. I currently feel comfortable as a woman and reasonably content with my life.