모든 이야기

에스트로겐, 남자 20명, 그리고 패싱을 좇는 것에 대한 경고

남성 · 탈전환113
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 전환을 되돌린/비판적으로 사고하는 트랜스 여성(생물학적 남성)으로, 에스트로겐과 테스토스테론 억제를 해 왔고 20명 이상과 성관계를 가졌으며(대부분 남성, 감정적 사랑 없이), 성을 경험하는 방식에 포르노의 영향을 강하게 받았습니다. 저는 패싱에 대해 매우 자각적이며 대부분의 MtF가 자신의 패싱 능력을 과대평가한다고 믿고, 100% 패싱을 추구하는 것이 불행으로 이어진다고 경고합니다. 저는 온라인 트랜스 커뮤니티를 '분파적'이라 비판하고 선천적 생물학적 성차에 대해 강한 견해를 가집니다. 트랜스 정체성에서 벗어나 아이 없이 고립되어 끝날까 걱정하며, 치료는 정체성 문제를 해결하는 데 제한적이라고 봅니다.

전체 이야기

I was born male and have lived as a trans woman (MtF) for some time. I have been on estrogen and testosterone suppression, and I have discussed with others the physical effects of HRT, including that while it is possible to prevent the penis from shrinking much, the testicles will shrink and fertility is not guaranteed, though it is likely fertility could return after discontinuing HRT. I have thought a lot about passing. I told someone that most MtFs think they pass when they don't, and that it is a very common trend in the trans community for MtFs to overestimate their ability to pass. I said I have seen people claim to be 'stealth' when they are obvious, and that I have met many MtFs in person who think they are stealth when they are very obvious. I explained this through psychology: when you want something to be true, your mind hides from reality. I warned someone whose goal is '100%' passing that they will never be happy unless they are 'dumb' and delude themselves, because some people are too self-aware to live like that. I also noted that being referred to as she/her by strangers is not definitive because passing is contextual — a lot of people can pass to random strangers for a few seconds, but in more intimate experiences like meeting a partner's family or having sex, it comes crashing down, and men will clock a trans woman, still have sex, and not admit it to themselves. I have a critical view of online trans communities. I said the reason something is 'culty' is because online communities operate in culty terms in terms of what they allow to be discussed to prevent 'trolling' (which I described as preventing truth-telling), while also saying this doesn't mean being transgender is not a real thing. I hold strong views about biological sex differences. I argued that males and females evolved differently and that this leads to consequences, and that it is a biological reality that females will never enjoy manual labor as much as males or be as good at it, that males will never deal with children as well as females, and that males will always kill and commit violence more than females. I said you will never convince the average male and average female that they are wrong for conforming to the behavior of the average male and average female, because they prefer it. I also argued that infants display gender preferences, that the idea that all differences between male and female brains is socialization is ridiculous, and that 'nurture follows nature.' I criticized what I see as a general trend in leftist philosophy to presume all humans are blank slates despite evidence to the contrary. I also said that 95% of males and females enjoy their gender roles and actively impose them on others, so the existence of exceptions will never remove gender roles. I have been heavily affected by pornography. I said porn affected me so strongly that I have never had a truly sensual sexual experience. Before having sex, porn led me to only associate sex with kinky animalistic acts, never love. All the sex I have had has been a means to an end (orgasm). Even though I have been with 20+ individuals, I still feel sexually inexperienced and insecure because of the damage porn did. Kissing or cuddling does not turn me on, but watching a girl twerk does. I am mostly attracted to males but don't feel emotional love for men, just the physical. The most intense orgasms I have had were to certain porn, generally after abstaining for a long time. I concluded porn is very bad for most people. I have also reflected on aging and life trajectory. I predicted that lots of trans people who dived in during their early twenties will have wake-up calls when they turn 30 and it is not cool anymore to be an edgy loner/stoner/rebel, while people around them start families. I expressed concern about lonely, bitter millennials and childless people in their 50s and 60s looking for a purpose, suggesting they might turn into political radicals to fill the void of having no family, while acknowledging that not everyone is fertile and it is something you have to live with. On therapy, I advised someone that most therapists are not very helpful for questions of identity — that therapists can help illuminate patterns of behavior or thoughts creating distress, but they are not there to tell you if you are a girl or a boy. I said therapy is not a solution, it is a simple dialogue. I also advised someone who seemed to want to be pretty and express femininity not to get too wrapped up in themselves, and that if they find themselves browsing trans forums every day, they have turned it into a hobby and are probably neglecting other aspects of their life.