낯선 사람이 그가 트랜스일지도 모른다고 말했다 — 2주간 공황발작이 이어졌다
남성 · 단념1천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 정신적으로는 디트랜지션했지만 실제로는 전환한 적이 없는 남성입니다. 호르몬이나 수술을 한 적이 없고 남성으로 정체화하며, 구체적으로는 폭력적인 아버지와 과잉 밀착한 어머니로 형성된 여성적 성격을 지닌 양성애자 남성입니다. 2024년 5월 한 낯선 사람이 제가 트랜스일 수 있다고 제안한 것이 2주 넘게 멈추지 않는 공황 발작, 심박 항진, 실존적 반추를 유발했고 크자낙스, 술, 운동, 신뢰하는 성학자가 이를 진정시켰습니다. 신체 불쾌감은 없고 얼굴과 몸이 마음에 듭니다. 제 고통은 아동기 성별 비순응 기억, 억압된 동성애 감정, 의료적 전환으로 밀려날지도 모른다는 두려움에 집중되었습니다. 이제 아동기 성별 비순응과 성적 지향을 가족 외상, 가능한 경계성 인격장애/복합 외상후 스트레스 장애의 렌즈로 보며, 트랜스 이데올로기와 성별 긍정 치료에 강하게 비판적이고 디트랜스 공간에서 비공식적 옹호 활동을 합니다. 여전히 외롭고 예민하지만 남성으로서의 정체성은 안정적이며 호르몬을 사용한 적이 없습니다.
전체 이야기
I am a man in my late thirties (40 as of May 2024) who has never transitioned and does not identify as trans, but I went through an intense, frightening episode of gender-related fear and rumination in late May 2024 after a stranger on Reddit suggested I might be trans because I had written about difficult-to-reconcile bisexual attractions.
Growing up, I had some feminine behaviour as a child: I knitted, I have pictures of myself wearing my mother's clothes, I had at least one or two gender-swapping fantasies in early adolescence, and I remember asking my mother if I was a girl. I never actually believed I was a girl, though — I described it as trying to interact with the world using girl behaviour, thinking that looking "pretty" and being charming and mild was the way to get along. Around age 11 I snapped out of it mostly; I was long-haired and feminine-looking (I may have a mild intersex condition), and when a man on vacation called me a girl I got angry, especially that my father laughed. I remember being aware of being a boy from early puberty forward, albeit one who felt his personality was very feminine.
My childhood was marked by serious family dysfunction. My father was violent and abusive toward me and my mother — I remember him kicking me, spitting on me and calling me a sissy while I lay on the floor, around age 9, after I tried to protect my mother from him; I shouted "nooooo." He also once beat me and called me a slur for girl. My mother was overwhelming and enmeshed with me; I became a surrogate husband to her, she was "a goddess" to me, and she constantly told me "never become like your father." I now believe she may have encouraged my feminine behaviour in kindergarten partly to mock my father. I also believe my father was a closeted gay or bisexual man, a sensitive man hidden under narcissism. I was lucky that the enmeshment ended by grade school, when I began identifying with my father instead. My grandfather was a crucial masculine ideal — kind, calm, strong, never raising his voice. I lost my best friend Jonathan when he transferred schools around grade 2 or 3, turned inward, imitated my mother, and was lonely and bullied for most of my schooling until a new friend in grade 9 showed me that masculinity could be kind and safe. I also recall childhood sexual predation: older men leering at me in the men's changing room at the pool as a "pretty" young boy, and public exposure by men, which I was a victim of as a child.
Sexually, I had early crushes on girls, but from around 14-15 I felt strong warm emotions around boys — clearly homosexual feelings — which I repressed hard in a homophobic high school environment. I forced myself to have sex with women and did enjoy it, though I needed to be in a dominant, slightly sadistic mood to perform. For the last 5-10 years, since discovering femdom porn, I have struggled to stay attracted to regular sex with women; I fantasize a lot about being pegged. I have never been into "sissy" content. I have had more crushes on straight guys than gay ones, though in recent years I acknowledged crushes on a gay man from media and on a gay/bi man on Twitter. I have lived in Thailand for several years and had run-ins with ladyboys, and I relate strongly to attraction to "women with something extra" (gyneandromorphilia). I identify my sexuality as bisexual — attraction to "female and male characteristics" — while noting I am romantically drawn to men but sexually default to women, which I call being "split bisexual." I have never had a girlfriend or boyfriend, but have had quite a few sexual partners, mostly women. I want a relationship and family ideally.
The crisis itself began suddenly in late May 2024: non-stop panic attacks, a racing heart every day for over two weeks, waking with a "drumming heartbeat," inability to feel pleasure, obsessive reading and ruminating, and the only relief coming from large quantities of alcohol and sport. I was terrified of contacting the psych ward because I feared being given a trans diagnosis; a month earlier they had given me a "tentative diagnosis schizotypal," and an emergency worker had noted PTSD and "gender identity worries," which I insisted was really body dysmorphia. I took Xanax, which broke the panic enough for me to say "I am a boy, a weird one, but a boy" and feel that it was stable rather than fake. I had an appointment with an older female sexologist in 10 days and considered her trustworthy. I have a history of severe health anxiety — years spent convinced I had a brain tumor, ALS, MS or Lyme, spending thousands, even making plans for how to kill myself if it got too bad — and I recognize that my mind can play tricks while making me feel I'm the sane one. I also have a history of following subcultures and online movements uncritically, being suggestible, and going along with ideas as long as I feel loved and included, only to later realize the people I followed had serious personality disorders and manipulated others.
I have never been on hormones and have no body dysphoria: I like my face and my body. The only physical thing I strongly dislike is losing my hair — I want a "luscious mane" and wear a cap, and I find it hard because long hair was a rebellious personal expression and losing it feels like losing pretty-boy privilege. I have also said I'd like to look like Jared Leto or Kurt Cobain.
I now think of my childhood GNC as a product of family dynamics — too-close mother, dangerous/absent father — plus trauma, and I have come to see my sexuality as "homosexuality gone wrong" because of childhood abuse: I believe I probably should have been gay but was too sensitive and hurt too easily to survive it as a child. I have wondered about BPD (my brother called me out as BPD years ago; I recognize the unstable sense of self and chronic emptiness descriptions as things I could have written word for word), and I note CPTSD/BPD, autism and narcissism as possible frameworks. I also had a PTSD crisis of childhood-abuse flashbacks in 2024 that triggered the gender questioning.
On transition and gender ideology, I am strongly critical. I fear that acknowledging gender dysphoria would put me on "an expressway to castration." I describe trans blogs as manipulative, cult-like, pseudo-scientific gaslighting aimed at vulnerable people; I argue that trans strengthens rather than destroys gender roles, that support for trans is often a cover for homophobia, and that patriarchal, unequal societies produce trans identities as an outlet for surplus men. I believe gender is only social roles, and I hold a yin-yang view of masculine/feminine balance in everyone. I have posted and commented extensively in detrans and related communities, telling people Rule 4 (never encourage cross-sex hormones or surgery), recommending people stop porn, and arguing that GNC boys mostly grow out of it and that Reddit has no non-trans space for gender-nonconforming people. I said I "desisted" long ago as a boy who grew out of GNC behaviour like most do, and that I don't fully belong here if "detrans" is the only criterion, but that this sub calmed me down during my vulnerable state.
Currently I feel stable in my identity as a man, though I still struggle with loneliness, sensitivity, low confidence around women, an unstable sense of self, and the sense that I am an amalgamation of traits stolen from others. I joined a sports club and rediscovered competitiveness, though I felt shame about wanting to win. I have a personal relationship with God and pray for strength rather than favors.