테스토스테론을 강제로 끊겼지만, 여전히 자유의지를 택하다
여성 · 탈전환82
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 디트랜지션한, 자폐적이며 키가 크고 남성적으로 보이는 사람으로 여성으로 태어나 사회적·의학적으로 트랜지션했고, 유전성 혈액 응고 장애로 의사들에게 테스토스테론 중단을 강제당했으며, 20대에 호르몬과 그 장애로 양측 폐색전증을 겪었습니다. 저는 비자발적 디시스트입니다 — 선택이 있었다면 아마 여전히 T를 사용했을 것입니다 — 그리고 여전히 남성으로 태어났기를 바라지만, 수술은 절대 받지 않기로 선택했고 성별 중립적인 이름을 유지했습니다. 팔로플라스티와 음낭성형술의 파멸적이고 수백만 달러 규모의 합병증을 겪은 친구들과 가까이 지내며, 그것이 하부 수술에 반대하는 제 결정을 형성했습니다. 호르몬이 거의 저를 죽일 뻔했더라도 사람들의 선택을 제한하는 것은 잘못이라고 주장하며 트랜지션 의료에 대한 어떤 법적 제한이나 금지에도 강하게 반대하고, 온정주의보다 자유의지를 지지합니다. 트랜스 이데올로기에는 비판적이지만 개인의 접근은 지지하며, 다른 디트랜지션하는 사람들과 고통받는 청소년이 계속 살도록 독려하는 데 시간을 씁니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and have always come across as masculine — I describe myself as a naturally tall female. I have had dreams about being fully male since I was a kid, and I still legitimately wish I had been born male. I transitioned socially and medically, but I deliberately picked a gender-neutral name when I transitioned because I always knew I would ultimately avoid surgery (surgery scares me generally) and that I would always be somewhere in between. As a result I kept my birth name, though my female birth name definitely wouldn't fit and never really has.
I was on testosterone for a period, but I was forced to stop taking T by doctor's orders because I have a genetic blood clotting disorder which makes hormones extremely risky. Because of that genetic disorder combined with hormones, I had a bilateral pulmonary embolism in my 20s. I describe myself as a sort of unwilling desistor — if I had a choice I might still be taking T. Hormonal treatment for transitioning almost killed me, but I still say I would not advocate for limiting or banning it for others.
I desisted and still appear very masculine. I mostly date female partners, and my girlfriend is German. I also say I am on the autism spectrum. During the pandemic I traveled a lot, which helped me shift my identity a bit, including stopping binding, which I used to do every day and found painful.
I got surgical consultations before deciding against bottom surgery. Twice when I was getting surgical consultations I would hear a trans guy in the lobby or nearby office describing in distress how they can't pee, and I decided not to go for it after hearing that. I wish people were up front on statistics — I never heard about these complications from doctors, just FTMs I knew who were suffering. I have a friend who had a scrotoplasty that went so badly he can't even sit down and basically can't work now because of it; he also had a phalloplasty that looked great at first but has since had many revisions mostly due to urethral complications, making it look worse and everything more painful over time. That friend has said all of his procedures have cost more than $1 million, mostly covered by the state of California. Watching friends allow themselves to become guinea pigs saddened me deeply.
Even after desisting I still think about having a phalloplasty sometimes because I still appear masculine and mostly date female partners. If I did it I would go for the lowest-risk sort (pedicle flap) and try to keep my vagina and structures there intact. I note that more surgeons are willing to do phalloplasties where you keep your vagina and original urethra, and I criticize all-or-nothing thinking and insurance policies that require complete surgery for coverage, saying policies like that doom FTMs to suffer.
I am critical of trans ideology but strongly believe people have a right to access the healthcare they want and believe they need, and that this right shouldn't be limited. I take a strongly anti-paternalist, pro-free-will position: I say that if you try to limit and regulate transition healthcare you are being transphobic, and I compare restricting transition to overreach like conversion-therapy bans that force therapists to cheerlead transitioning. I explicitly say that even though testosterone almost killed me, I still have a choice to take it if I want, and that is awesome. I also argue against seatbelt-law analogies for restricting choice, saying I am a hater of paternalism and the limitation of free will, period. I have been downvoted heavily in the detrans community for these views and have urged the subreddit not to become extreme.
I have given support to other detransitioners and distressed young people: I encourage masculinized women to travel to accepting places like Portland, Oregon; I suggest becoming a workaholic as what saved my life; I recommend travel and new social contexts for reinventing yourself after detransition; and I have repeatedly urged people not to hurt themselves. I relate to others on the spectrum and thank them for being brave.
On regret: I do not express regret about hormones per se (I might still take T if I could), but I regret the near-fatal blood clots and I avoid surgery out of fear of complications. I remain saddened by lost time and by friends' surgical suffering. I still wish I were born male, which is a persistent sadness rather than something that has resolved.