모든 이야기

테스토스테론 6개월, 그리고 18세에 중단

여성 · 탈전환전환 11 → 디트랜지션 18566
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 16세에 사회적으로 트랜지션하고 17세부터 6개월간 테스토스테론을 복용하고 대학에서 심한 우울, 고립, 자살 사고 후 18세에 중단한 디트랜지션 여성입니다. 지금은 목소리 여성화에 힘쓰며, 수년간의 안전하지 않은 가슴 압박으로 인한 가슴 변화를 포함해 테스토스테론의 영구적 영향을 안고 살고 있습니다. 저는 남자가 되고 싶은 욕구가 트랜스이기 때문이 아니라 이른 사춘기, 괴롭힘, 내면화된 여성혐오, 젠더 역할에 대한 불편함에서 비롯되었다고 믿습니다. 저는 치료로서의 트랜지션에, 특히 아동에 대해 비판적이면서도 전면 금지에는 반대하고 탈의료화와 트랜지션을 미용 수술처럼 대하는 것을 옹호합니다. 저는 불쾌감이 있는 이들에게 자신이 트랜스라고 단정하기보다 여성인 것이 잘못 느껴지는 근본 이유를 찾으라고 권합니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female and started my period unusually early, at age 9, which made me feel alienated from my female peers who were not developing at the same rate. I had struggled with gender roles my whole life and never felt like I fit in with other girls, though I didn't fit in with boys either. As an anxious young person with few friends, I spent a lot of time online and stumbled upon the trans community, identifying as a trans boy at age 11 — cutting my hair and using a different name online, but never telling anyone in real life out of shame. Two years later, after being bullied in middle school for looking 'like a lesbian,' I tried hard to fit in as a cis girl: growing out my hair, wearing revealing clothes. That worked for a few years, but I still felt fundamentally wrong. I suspect I am neurodivergent, though I have issues with that label. At 16, mid-pandemic, I got really into stan Twitter, where being trans was normalized, and I began to think my earlier phase had meaning. After deliberation I socially transitioned, and by 17 I was on testosterone. I had broken up with my girlfriend and lost my whole friend group right before starting hormones, leaving me with no support system. I'm not close with my family, and my identity caused a bigger rift. The six months on testosterone, starting at university, were among the worst of my life: constantly misgendered because I didn't look or sound like a man, I stopped leaving my room, skipped classes for two months, and was severely depressed to the point of genuinely wanting to kill myself. I finished the semester with straight Bs but was deeply isolated. In the second semester I felt somewhat better and made a few friends, but shame and self-consciousness persisted — I still skipped class and spent days or weeks in my room, feeling like a zoo exhibit on campus. My friends used my chosen name and he/him pronouns, but it felt like they were humouring me, like a kid playing dress-up. Testosterone deepened my voice and redistributed body fat, but I knew it would never give me the results I wanted: I would always be 5'2 with wide hips and a feminine face, never a 'normal' man. I became 99% sure I wanted to detransition, planning to stop testosterone, recognizing that my desire to be a man was rooted in bad childhood experiences and internalized misogyny. What gave me pause was that I still hate gender roles and the way people treat women — at least while not passing, I wasn't expected to act like a woman. I noted the irony that I'm generally opposed to cosmetic surgery and think people should accept themselves despite beauty standards, yet I wanted to change my body drastically. After stopping testosterone, I began voice training to feminize my voice, drawing on past singing lessons, though I lamented not having my singing voice back. I also worried about my breasts after about two years of unsafe binding plus six months on T: they looked and felt saggier and more malleable than before, and one had become a noticeably different shape from the other — something I feared would obsess me since I'm prone to fixation on symmetry. I asked whether breast shape and perkiness would recover as hormones returned to normal female levels, and whether chest muscle or continued binding positioned differently might help. I also dealt with the permanent effects of testosterone after detransitioning. I reflected that I spent about two and a half years — two socially, six months medically — miserable and wallowing in dysphoria, and that transitioning made my insecurities about my female body far worse, leaving me afraid to be in public for fear of being clocked. I believe I would have spared myself a lot of pain had I accepted myself in the body I had two and a half years earlier and worked through the discomfort instead. I've become critical of the trans community's intolerance of other perspectives, describing my earlier beliefs as willful ignorance and 'wild mental gymnastics,' and arguing that kids probably shouldn't be subjecting themselves to drastic treatments of dubious safety and efficacy. I believe transition has saved lives and that an outright ban could be disastrous because some kids are convinced it is their only hope, but I am not actually in support of transition as a treatment for gender dysphoria — in my ideal world no one would have to change their body to be happy. I think the focus should be on why people feel they need to transition, demedicalizing being trans rather than banning it, and I've said transition should be treated the same as cosmetic surgery under law. I respect trans people, nearly all my friends are trans, and I'll use whatever names and pronouns they want, but I believe trans identity doesn't make logical sense. I've argued that having gender dysphoria does not necessarily mean someone is trans, that most detransitioners had dysphoria and are cisgender anyway, and that dysphoria reflects discomfort with one's sex and gender roles with underlying causes worth finding. I define detransitioning as accepting the different and sometimes inaccurate versions of yourself that people see and becoming secure enough in your internal sense of self that others' opinions don't matter. Currently I am a detransitioned woman, working on feminizing my voice and reconciling with the permanent effects of testosterone.