2020년 호르몬을 끊고 — 그러고는 아들이 같은 문을 지나는 것을 지켜보았다
남성 · 탈전환651
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 디트랜지션한 남성으로, 여성으로 살았고 약 2020년에 중단할 때까지 이성 호르몬을 사용했습니다. 스스로에게 강요한 여성혐오, 성적 페티시, 성장의 어려움이 저를 트랜지션으로 끌어당겼다고 믿으며, 이제는 어떤 의학적 개입보다 인지 치료가 먼저여야 한다고 생각합니다. 제 아들은 나중에 트랜스로 정체화하고 최소한의 임상 평가 후 호르몬과 수술을 받았으며 약 6년째 우리 가족과 연락을 끊고 있는데, 저는 그것을 이어지는 애도라고 표현합니다. 저는 r/detrans에서 활동하며 디트랜지션한 사람들을 격려하고, 청소년에게서 이익을 얻는 비윤리적 의료 체계라고 제가 보는 것을 비판합니다. 저는 남성으로 살고 제 남성성을 받아들이며, 누구도 성별을 바꿀 수 없다고 믿습니다.
전체 이야기
I want to tell my story, because I think it matters and because I've spent a lot of time on r/detrans trying to encourage others who are where I once was.
I was born male. I came to identify as trans and lived as a woman for a period, and I took synthetic cross-sex hormones during that time. I don't have exact dates for when all of it started in my own case, but I do know that by early 2020 I had already come out the other side of it — I was detransitioning and encouraging other people who were doing the same. In February 2020 I wrote to someone who had just detransitioned: "Time to reclaim yourself. You've learned from your experience, put it behind you and begin afresh. If this is difficult, you may have to identify why you chose trans in the first place, self imposed misogyny is my guess." That question — why did I choose this in the first place — is one I've had to sit with myself.
Looking back, I think self-imposed misogyny was a real part of it for me, along with the general difficulty of growing up. I've written that "Growing up is difficult for everyone, it's something we must soldier through, hopefully with the support of loved ones," and I wish someone had said that to me instead of affirming me. I also think some of what pulled me in was sexual — I told one person, "If you enjoy seeing yourself sexually as a girl, then that's a fetish. It's up to you whether you want to feed that or not," which is advice I would have needed to hear myself. I've also argued that a lot of what people think of as wanting to be a girl is really just wanting to enjoy things society has labelled feminine, and that those are matters of personality, not biology: "Sadly society has labelled certain things feminine and/or masculine. Whereas enjoyment of these things is more about personality than biological sex."
On the medical side, I was on hormones and I came off them. Coming off spironolactone was something I discussed with others — I noted that "Going off Spiro can cause fluid retention. Happily the side effects of spiro will be reversed once off of it," and I suggested tapering: "Perhaps just halving it for a bit would be wise." I've told people that "3 weeks is such a short time. Toss the meds, they are at war with your DNA," and I've described synthetic hormones as toxic and shortening of lifespan. I don't have a record of surgeries in my own case, so I won't claim any.
What moved me toward detransition was mostly thinking and reading for myself. I came to believe that transition doesn't do what it promises. I've written, "No one can change sex, it's simply a performance," and "Cross sex hormones war with a persons DNA. Every cell in our body contains our chromosomes." I also think cognitive behavioral therapy should come before any medical intervention — I relayed that "Our family physician once told us that taking synthetic hormones cements the delusions. Cognitive behavioral therapy is her first choice in treating a patient with body issues, not drugs," and I've argued that "it requires a great deal more work to detransition when they realize they've made a mistake. Cognitive therapy doesn't damage the body or mind."
A large part of my life since 2020 has been spent as the parent of a son who identifies as trans. I've described it as grief: "I am approaching 6 years of grief. We lost our son to the transcult. All we can do now is wait for his return." He received hormones after one visit to a trans clinic — no clinical history, no psyche referral — and was fast-tracked for surgery. He has since cut off communication with the entire family and only associates with trans-identified people. I've written, "The drugs put him into a depression. He is now stuck with a surgery he can't reverse... He no longer associates with family or friends," and "His bones are now weak, he has a greater risk of cancer." I've said I will never give up on him and that we wait for his return daily.
I also have a post-operative trans woman in my family circle, whom I describe as living "in solace and regret," someone I believe was "poisoned and butchered" and "sold a lie."
As for where I stand now: I am a detransitioned man. I live as a man, I've urged others to "Embrace your manhood, love the skin you're in," and I believe that being an effeminate man is fine but that one can never become a woman. I've been active on r/detrans and elsewhere, encouraging people who are detransitioning, warning others away from hormones and surgery, and speaking critically of what I see as an unethical medical and social system profiting from young people. I've written, "Clinics are profiting off of this contagion. Our young people are being poisoned and mutilated," and I've said that being told you cannot change sex "would be a courtesy" rather than an insult. My advocacy comes from a place of grief for my son and regret about my own past, but also from hope — when I see someone detransition, I've written, "It gives me hope for young people who are being damaged by this unhealthy social contagion."
I don't describe myself as suicidal and I haven't self-harmed. The pain I carry is mostly grief for my son and for lost years, and it's ongoing rather than improving.