8세에 소녀가 되고 싶었던 건 소년을 사랑할 수 있기 위해서였다
남성 · 단념1.8천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 남성으로 태어났고 사회적·의학적 트랜지션을 한 번도 거치지 않은 채 멈췄으며, 지금은 게이 남성으로 정체화합니다. 여덟 살쯤 되던 어린 시절에는 다른 남자아이들을 사랑할 수 있으려고만 여자아이가 되고 싶었지만, 동성애를 이해하게 된 중·고등학교 무렵 그 생각을 넘겼습니다. 저는 아동에 대한 의학적 트랜지션에 강하게 반대하며, 그것을 겪었다면 깊이 후회했을 것이라고 믿고, 디스포리아는 동반된 정신 질환과 함께 먼저 다루어야 한다고 r/detrans에서 활발히 주장합니다. 호르몬도 수술도 한 적이 없고, 종교적 우파와 정치적 좌파 양쪽의 괴롭힘 때문에 미술 경력은 이 계정과 완전히 분리해 둡니다.
전체 이야기
I was born male and grew up in a fairly religious, homophobic environment where I absorbed the message that gay people were horrible before I even understood what the word meant. Around first grade — I've pegged it at about 8 years old — I developed what I described as a "strange fascination with bowflex commercials for the shirtless dudes" and started imagining dating other guys. Because I had no concept of homosexuality, my child-logic was that in order to love or be with a man I had to be a girl, so I silently wanted to be a girl for years. I was explicit that this wanting had "nothing to do with FEELING like a girl" — it was purely so I could love males. I never acted on it: "I never ACTED like a girl because like, I'd have gotten killed." It wasn't until middle school or high school that I actually understood what homosexuality was, and I grew out of wanting to be a girl and settled into "ah, I'm just gay." I never socially transitioned, never took hormones, never had any medical intervention. I've stated plainly: "I never took chemicals and I still have my hair so I have nothing to say here," and "I only desisted, didn't take any medication." So I describe myself as a desister rather than a medical detransitioner, though I corrected someone else once by saying "you're not a desisted female, you're detrans" for someone who had medically transitioned. I now identify as a gay man and have said I've "just grown comfortable with being a gay guy." My position, shaped by my own experience, is strongly against surgical and hormonal transitioning at young ages: "when you're having these thoughts as young as 8 you don't really know what you're going to feel when you're older and that's why I'm strongly against the surgical and hormonal transitioning at so young. I would have deeply regretted it." I also said that even if I had put on a dress and had people call me a girl, "that still wouldn't make me a bio woman so I'd still be navigating as a male." I went through a questioning period and said that "when I was questioning, a lot of the groups turned me off because they would say such stupid things I wanted no association with it. I wanted to be a woman, not a trans woman was the big thing." I specifically cited Sophie Labelle's "girl penis" comments, drawn on 8-year-olds, as a reason I didn't want to be part of that community. The only groups I wanted to join were art-related ones with gender-bending and gay themes, but I found that community became "an extremely toxic place." I'm an artist myself — I mentioned I "used to actually be years ago hovering top 100 FA artists and was for a time the #1 Y!gallery artist" — and I keep this account entirely separate from my art because of harassment I've received from the left: I had a comic about a former bully redeeming himself and falling for his former victim that was "accused of drawing a rape comic because 'bullies can't be redeemed'," and I was attacked for drawing a Norse-themed tribal character despite being mixed race. I also mentioned a friend group falling apart when someone accused me of being a "jan 6 truther trump supporter" and claimed Gamergate was responsible for January 6th, and that people in a chat log called me a "transphobic cissie" — which I suspect happened because of my "lack of transitioning medically." I attended a college that was "constantly featured for segments on 'sjw cringe comps'." I've been politically on the left and expressed dismay that it's "turning into the evil fascists I used to be against," and I've said I'm not a Trump fan or defender. I've been active in r/detrans, arguing extensively that trans suicide statistics don't account for detransitioners who regret transition and are lumped in as "trans suicides," that gender dysphoria is often comorbid with BPD, bipolar, schizophrenia, DID, depression, and autism and should be treated first, and that gender-affirming therapists skip full psychiatric evaluation. I've said things like "you don't hate trans people, you hate TRAs" and argued that AGP is real and under-discussed. I've also discussed being a furry, and I've engaged in debates about men's rights, saying "I do involve myself in discussions about men's rights that are applicable. I'm not an activist I just discuss it." I've been repeatedly accused of transphobia by others on Reddit, including a mod I believed was trying to get me permanently banned. Sexuality-wise I identify as gay and have discussed at length tensions between gay men, lesbians, and bisexual people, including an ex-roommate who claimed to be a lesbian while only dating men to gain "lgbt credit." I have no stated mental health diagnoses, no surgeries, no hormones, and no fertility concerns in the transcript. I don't describe myself as experiencing dysphoria in a clinical sense — my childhood wish to be a girl was framed as a workaround for wanting to love men, not as feeling like a girl.