모든 이야기

36세에 유방 절제, 후회 없음 — 하지만 테스토스테론은 끊어야 했다

여성 · 탈전환1.3천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 디트랜지션한 여성입니다—여성으로 태어나 사회적 전환은 한 적이 없고 36세에 유방 절제술을 받았으며 30대에 약 14개월간 테스토스테론을 간헐적으로 사용하고 3년 넘게 전에 중단했습니다. 저는 수술을 후회하지 않습니다. 그것은 인식되지 않았던 평생의 온몸 통증을 해결했고 저를 더 나은 엄마로 만들었습니다. 하지만 저에게 옳지 않았기에 테스토스테론을 중단했습니다. 제 불쾌감—뇌가 제 몸이 남성적이기를 기대한다고 표현합니다—은 15년 반의 결혼이 끝난 뒤 현저히 줄었습니다. 저는 자신을 여성, 보수적인 기독교인, 그리고 의사로 봅니다. 지금은 이전보다 더 여성스러워 보이지만 발작적인 불쾌감은 여전히 경험합니다. 저는 전환 전의 신중하고 개별적인 평가를 지지하며 비판 없는 확인적 사고와 강경한 젠더 비판적 디트랜스 수사 모두에 비판적입니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female and I am a doctor working in medicine and public health in Australia. I have never socially transitioned and I have never identified as a man, but I have had significant, long-standing gender dysphoria centred on my body, and I have taken medical and surgical steps to manage it. My dysphoria goes back a long way. I did not experience it as a child in the sense of saying I was a boy, but I had discomfort in my body and difficulty with being touched, and I disliked breast development. As a teenager in the 1990s, when trans issues were far less prominent, I interpreted these feelings as internalised lesbophobia - I came out as lesbian in high school - and I also convinced myself that I must have been sexually abused as a child. That was not true, as far as I know; it was all gender dysphoria. I wondered for a while if I was trans, around age 19 or 20, but I never came out to anyone and buried it. I got on with life: I became vegetarian, married, had a child, and trained as a doctor. It was not until my mid-thirties that I acknowledged to myself that these long-standing feelings were actually gender dysphoria. I had a long history of distress and very little exposure to modern trans ideology. I had been married for 15.5 years, and I have spent a lot of time trying to work out how much of my dysphoria was pre-existing and how much was worsened by a bad relationship with my husband. My ex saw me differently in ways I wasn't even different, once we recognised I had gender dysphoria. My husband left me, and the marriage broke down about a year before I wrote about it in early 2020. Since being out of that relationship, my dysphoria has been markedly less, and I think feeling safe is part of it. The way I describe my dysphoria is that my brain expects my body to be male. It is not an identity - I don't identify as male or want to be male. For years I had an overwhelming feeling of wrongness throughout my body that I could not attribute to any particular body part, and I assumed it was a body image problem. Then, when I started exploring gender and put on a proper commercial binder, that horrible whole-body feeling went away. That was a light-bulb, life-changing moment, and I could not un-know it. I had breastfed my baby for over a year, which I am very glad I was able to do, but which probably shows how deeply I had buried these feelings between about age 20 and 35. I had extensive therapy before making decisions. I was a well-informed health professional in my mid-thirties when I chose a mastectomy. I had top surgery at age 36, over five years ago now, and it was the most wonderful, life-changing thing for me. My surgeon was clear that he could not provide aesthetically pleasing results and that the benefit would be psychological. I had bound for a bit over a year beforehand. My breasts were not an erogenous zone for me and I had no nipple sensation to the grafts, so there was no sexual loss. I love my chest - it feels like mine - and I have no regrets. The distressing whole-body feeling has completely gone. I can be physically closer to my daughter, I am a better mum, and I have a higher tolerance for stress. I have some quirks - a small dog ear, uneven scars - and I am happy with them. I also took injectable testosterone, on and off, for a total of about 14 months, with a break of several months in the middle, in my thirties. I liked the physical changes, including permanent genital changes, but I did not find that T significantly relieved my dysphoria, and I did not like the emotional and mental changes. I never achieved significant masculinisation and never passed as male, except sometimes on the phone. I stopped T because it wasn't right for me; my last dose was over three years ago. Some changes reversed; some did not. My voice is deeper, though it has lightened somewhat and my inflections are feminine, and I can sing better now with practice. I get occasional comments about my voice and an occasional 'sir' on the phone, but most of the time nothing is said and people read me as female. The fat redistribution did not fully reverse - I still have forehead wrinkles, and I have a persistent depression in my right thigh from fat that did not return after the first time I stopped T. I have PMDD, which I had before T and still have. I manage it with depo provera, which works well but caused heavy bleeding, so I had an endometrial ablation, and I also have a Mirena IUD as a backup. The ablation was straightforward day surgery and I do not bleed. I have an anxiety and OCD history; my OCD is currently in remission, though I have obsessional issues with my body, including weighing myself frequently, which are worse now that I am off T. I have also had a bad experience with a doctor who prescribed estrogen patches I did not want, which had horrible side effects. I am a conservative, evangelical Christian. My faith, along with less dysphoria since leaving my marriage and social pressure to be the best mother I can be, has led me to adopt a more feminine presentation now. I have been trying to push myself in terms of presentation - some skirts, yes; dresses mostly no; bras no, because even putting one on looks and feels wrong. I have bought a lot of jewellery and makeup over the years; sometimes I wear it, but often it feels wrong, and I tell myself it's because it gets in the way rather than admitting it's the gender dysphoria. My dysphoria is mostly body-related rather than social. I am still occasionally uncomfortable being viewed as female, but I function well in female roles - mum, gentle health care professional - without frequent discomfort. I do not identify as trans, though I have at times identified with the 'transmasculine' label, and I suppose I would fall somewhere under a 'trans and gender diverse' umbrella. I have never socially transitioned and never detransitioned, so the standard labels don't quite fit me. I don't think having dysphoria means anything about whether someone is cis or trans, and I don't think the extent of dysphoria determines whether someone should transition. I have thought a lot about what caused my dysphoria. I wonder about sensory processing - I dislike excessive noise and other sensory inputs, and I struggled with being touched - and whether that was part of why I disliked breast development so much. I have also wondered whether my PMDD contributed, since my brain changed with my body each month. I don't have a neat 'reason' for my dysphoria, and sometimes I feel defective compared to others who seem to have identifiable causes. In a recent post I said that having a female sexed body actually, literally, felt like it caused me trauma - like a violent or abusive act might - simply from being touched and interacted with in the world in that body. Much of that went away after my mastectomies. I have no regrets about my surgery. I do wish it hadn't taken surgery to find peace, but I am a better mum for having had it. I am very wary of how my story could be used: I would never want it quoted in isolation to support surgery for everyone. I think psychological evaluation before any gender-related treatment is important, and I think teenagers in particular need great care, though their feelings shouldn't be dismissed. I am critical of both extreme positions - the uncritical affirmative model and the harsh gender-critical movement - and I found gender-critical comments here incredibly stressful, hurtful and unhelpful, even though I never socially transitioned. I think we need a thoughtful, balanced 'third way' of therapy. I have also been protective of this community, worrying that extreme content from throwaway accounts could get the subreddit shut down. I am now in my early forties. I have a happy daughter, a professional career, and a good life. I am happy in my body, and I have found that the most important things are therapy, self-care, gentle exercise, prayer, antidepressant medication when needed, community, and finding things that make me laugh.