전환 없는 성별 불쾌감 — 그리고 감사하게 여기는 게이트키핑
여성 · 단념73
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 성별 불쾌감을 겪었지만 전환하지 않기로 결정했고 더 이상 그럴 의도도 없는, 디트랜지션한/전환을 중단한 여성입니다. 불쾌감에도 불구하고 저는 시스로 간주되어 신속히 전환으로 이끌리기보다 게이트키핑에 직면했습니다. 저는 일부 LGBT+ 공간에서의 괴롭힘과 "너보다 트랜스" 태도를 비판하고 디트랜지션을 고민하는 사람들을 지지합니다. 저는 호르몬을 사용하거나 수술을 받았다고 서술하지 않았고 구체적인 심리적 위기나 자살 생각도 보고하지 않았습니다.
전체 이야기
I have lived with gender dysphoria for a long time, but I ultimately decided not to transition, and I no longer intend to. I used to want to transition desperately, but one of the reasons I chose not to is that I never wanted to spend the rest of my life trying to get other people to believe I was a guy — I just wanted to be me and be left alone to live my life regardless of gender or other people's opinions.
I sought help for my gender identity issues and ran into what I described as the opposite problem from people who get rushed into transition: gatekeeping. I found good therapists to be a real gamble, and gender identity issues make it even tougher. I have said that finding good therapists is a gamble and that I had the opposite problem from someone whose psychiatrist diagnosed them hastily from a single letter. I believe a letter should never be considered enough for a diagnosis, and I have been struck by how many people are hurried, and sometimes bullied, into transitioning when it is no magical solution.
I have experienced dysphoria while being assumed cis by others, and I know how frustrating that in-between place can be. I no longer intend to transition. I have described myself as having a shaved head and dressing in a pretty masculine way — nothing form fitting, no blingy stuff — and I use women's restrooms without having made anyone uncomfortable so far. I have suggested that someone in a similar position could wear accessories or colors coded as more feminine, like simple earrings, if it made them more comfortable.
I have thought a lot about confidence and self-esteem as the way to stop questioning myself. I have said that feelings of wanting to transition come back because, until you work on your confidence, the grass seems greener on the other side, and that you can be introverted and masculine just as you can be introverted and confident. I recommended body language work, learning not to be too hard on oneself, and even charisma, debate, or public speaking classes. I told someone else that if they were sure they were not trans, working on their confidence was what they needed, because the best way to stop questioning yourself is working on yourself — you become the one in control.
I have also reflected on how other layers of insecurity would exist if I had been a girl, and further layers still if I transitioned, such as being preoccupied with passing. I have told others that there is nothing wrong with them and that it's great being a man, that plenty of people would kill to be one.
I have been critical of certain corners of the LGBT+ community. I have written about an insane amount of gatekeeping and bullying in circles whose mere existence pushes boundaries, saying I found that out the hard way. I have described people who, despite being oppressed themselves, oppress others and try to make you feel your experience is not valid or is less valid than theirs; people who think you're fine and privileged if you haven't transitioned while enforcing on others the same antiquated standards they accuse others of holding. I have noted a 'transer-than-thou' attitude among some in the community, assuming it stems from their own insecurities, and I have said bigoted words can come from within the LGBT+ community. I have agreed strongly with the idea that some trans people find detransitioners terrifying because it means they could be wrong about their own transition.
I have told people considering detransition that it would be better to stop taking hormones and give themselves time and space to evaluate where they stand, because it's their body and they get the last word on it. I have also said that too many people are told they can't have experienced dysphoria if they haven't transitioned, that transition is not for everyone, and that some people go decades or entire lifetimes with dysphoria without transitioning — and I am glad when people open up about dysphoria but find ways to be content with their lives, wishing this were more accepted.
I have advised someone being pressured by friends about detransitioning that their own identity and detransition don't revolve around those friends, that they are not at fault and haven't betrayed anyone's trust, and that they were just trying to live their life and found that way wasn't for them. I told them to put themselves first because detransitioning is about them, and that if they explain where they were coming from, real friends will accept them and fake friends will take care of themselves.
I have also discussed with someone who only believes in male and female that if that belief is genuine, it should be sufficient to keep them from identifying as non-binary, and I encouraged them to take time to find out what they themselves believe and to explore themselves in general. I suggested they think about why calling themselves a woman causes physical pain, and whether that might be dysphoria worth exploring with a therapist specializing in gender identity issues, or whether it's a matter of semantics — liking being female because they are biologically female while 'woman' evokes an idea of womanhood they don't feel they belong to.
I have expressed sympathy for people who received death threats over their identity, while noting that people will judge you no matter what and that we can't control that but can control ourselves. I have also predicted, pessimistically, that a lot of people would flip tables and drive a YouTuber offline if they came out a certain way, blaming the nasty minority that creates trouble.
I have not described undergoing hormones, surgery, or any medical transition myself. I have not described a specific detransition process, since I never transitioned. I have not described a specific mental health diagnosis, suicidal ideation, self-harm, or a suicide attempt. I have not described family dynamics, romantic relationships, career, or education in detail.