모든 이야기

에스트로겐 9개월, 그리고 양쪽 모두에게서 배척당했다

여성 · 탈전환1.2천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 약 9개월간 에스트로겐을 복용한 뒤 의학적으로 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 그 에스트로겐은 제가 청소년기 전환이라고 부르는 시기에 OHSU에서 받았습니다. 외로움과, 제가 온전히 이해하지 못했다고 서술하는 성인 압력 아래 부분적으로 전환했고, 호르몬 상태에서 여성성을 수행하려 하며 스스로를 '광대'처럼 느꼈습니다. 디트랜지션은 사회적 반발을 불러왔습니다 — LGBT와 트랜스 지원 모임에서 배제되었고, 이후 제 경험을 공유했다는 이유로 친LGBT 서브레딧의 봇에게 '트랜스포빅'이라는 낙인이 찍혔습니다. 저는 초기의 '모든 전환은 엿 먹어라' 단계에서, 의학적 전환에 직접 반대하기보다 사전 동의와 완전한 정보를 옹호하는 보다 온건한 입장으로 옮겨갔습니다. 현재는 젠더 비판적 커뮤니티와 트랜스 활동가 커뮤니티 양쪽에서 소외감을 느끼고 스스로를 두 세계 사이에 끼인 존재로 묘사하지만, 이데올로기로서 급진적 페미니즘에는 여전히 동일시합니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female, and I detransitioned after a medical transition that I now describe as an adolescent transition. Looking back at the timeline I can piece together from my own posts, I was on estrogen for about nine months, and I had my hormones at OHSU (Oregon Health & Science University). By September 2020 I said I could "barely remember what it was like, even though I was on estrogen for 9 months," and added that "there was so much bad stuff happening to me then that I guess I try to block it out." I have referred to "my adolescent transition," which tells me the transition began when I was young, and in a June 2020 post I referenced "a lot of the things that happened to me over the past 6 years" having traumatized me in the way trans communities deal with dysphoria — implying the difficult period ran roughly from 2014 to 2020. I never had surgery as far as my posts go; the medical intervention I describe is hormones. In a September 2020 comment I told someone asking about signs of detransition that "there's no way to really tell. Nobody can tell the difference between 'normal doubt', and something that will lead to detransition. That's why so many of us go on for so long, even though it's a mistake." I also noted that being on estrogen made me feel "basically like a clown for the time I was on estrogen," and that feminine presentation is "super hard to pull off for MtFs, but masculinity is so easy to look 'good' as for FtMs." On causes, I've been fairly open that loneliness played a role: "I partly transitioned cause I was so lonely, so it's like chicken or the egg." I also described intense pressure around gender presentation during transition: "I constantly felt this during my adolescent transition, and nobody really validated or helped me process those feelings because they didn't really have an answer themselves. At best, my feelings were called 'internalized transphobia.' I just remember thinking the word 'clown' every time I tried to do something 'gender confirming.'" I said that arriving at gender-nonconforming expression from "a more healthy angle" after detransition let me use things like lipstick without "the constant crushing pressure that I felt when transitioning," and that "performative expression is so much easier when you're not carrying the burden of an entire gender." I've also described a broader context of distress during my transition years: "Overall there was so much bad stuff happening to me then that I guess I try to block it out." In a June 2020 post I wrote that "a lot of the things that happened to me over the past 6 years have traumatized me to the way they deal with dysphoria," and that I was "extremely scared and angry about what adults were doing to me while I barely knew what was going on" — suggesting I was a minor or young person during at least part of my transition and felt adults were acting around me without my full understanding. On what moved me toward detransition, I don't describe a single dramatic event. Instead I've described a gradual disillusionment with both trans and gender-critical communities. I wrote in June 2020 that I was "stuck between worlds," that I didn't want to "fall back into gender critical circles" because that would mean "regressing into a state where I was extremely scared and angry," but that I was also "afraid of fully jumping the gap and associating with trans activists, because the bulk of them ignore us at best, and outright harass us at worst." I said I didn't want to "be taken advantage of and tricked into adopting identities that I don't truly want for myself." I also described the social dynamics of transition and detransition as a major factor in how hard it is to stop: "It's all casual to start taking hormones, and then when you realize how it's hurting you, the lovebombing stops, your trans support network disappears, everyone shuts you down and gaslights you. It's hard to stop, even if you know it's not what you want just because of the social consequences alone. I'm tired of hearing how the LGBT community never shuts people out when I've been on the wrong side of so many judgmental cliques who freeze me out of any socialization because of faux-pas like detransitioning." I've said elsewhere that I was "always scared of coming across as hateful and making people leave." I've described myself as having gone through an "edgy 'fuck all transition' phase" and later moving past it: "Even if it does work, it doesn't affect me or my detransition, so I guess I'm done with my edgy 'fuck all transition' phase... The best thing for people is just to lay all options out on the table and educate them as much as possible so they don't regret anything." I've also said, "Whether or not medical transition works shouldn't be the hill we as detransers die on... I don't even care anymore either way, this all seems to be getting so childish and politicized." On mental health, I've referenced being mentally unwell at points — I called parts of the community I was in one "using reddit to endlessly bully the mentally ill and downtrodden," and I've referenced self-hatred in the context of other detrans people's posts. In September 2020 I said "my health just sucks" and that I was "really worried about getting the virus before I go back to school," which tells me I was a student at that time. I don't describe specific diagnoses. On adversity, I've referenced being cyberbullied, being brigaded and harassed online repeatedly, being banned from gender-critical subreddits despite "towing the party line," and being labeled "transphobic" by a bot on a pro-LGBT subreddit after detransitioning — which prompted one of my posts: "Love being witchhunted on a pro-LGBT sub and automatically labeled by a bot as 'transphobic' because I had the audacity to detransition and share my experience. FML." I've also described feeling alienated from both leftists and gender-critical feminists, saying I wished "I could associate with my fellow leftists without feeling like I need to keep a secret." On sexuality and gender, I've said "I wouldn't call myself a former girl but yea" when someone framed my past that way, and I've expressed skepticism about the truscum/tucute debate: "they're all arguing as if there's some official card-carrying trans membership pass that you get if you qualify, but this stuff is all made up anyway." I've also criticized the quasi-religious language around transition: "I don't really like the whole quasi-religious narrative of 'second puberty' or 'trans birthdays'... Even the term 'deadname' has some really dark fucked up implications... Especially when you introduce detransition to the conversation, the whole 'death and rebirth' metaphor starts to look very sinister." On my current views about transition for others, I've settled into a moderate, informed-consent position: "The best thing for people is just to lay all options out on the table and educate them as much as possible so they don't regret anything." I've also defended the concept of AGP while criticizing a particular writer as a "quack," and I've pushed back on both aggressive anti-trans posting in detrans spaces and on trans activists who dismiss detransitioners. I told another user, "this isn't a GC sounding board... this is a space for detrans people to live their lives, not a space to debate trans athletes." I've also said, "People want to silence us so they can go back to pretending we don't exist. Arguments get hard when you actually have to think about people who have been harmed by transition." I don't describe suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts in this transcript. I don't describe a current relationship status, career, or family situation beyond being a student as of September 2020.