모든 이야기

논바이너리로 4년, 호르몬은 필요하지 않았다

여성 · 단념사회적 전환 14 → 데시스턴스 18278
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 14세에서 18세까지 사회적으로 트랜스/논바이너리로 정체화했지만 호르몬도 수술도 한 번도 하지 않은, 전환을 중단하고 디트랜지션한(ftmtf) 여성입니다. 지금은 여성스러움을 즐기기에 그것을 재발견하는 남자아이 같은 소녀라고 자신을 생각하며, 꼬리표를 원하지 않고 제 성적 지향(아마 양성애자, 혹은 이성애자)을 여전히 정리하고 있습니다. 저는 인터넷과 또래 사이의 퀴어 문화가 제 자신감 없음, 어색함, 늦은 사춘기, 다른 소녀들과 어울리지 못함을 설명하는 방식으로 저를 트랜스 정체성으로 밀어넣었다고 믿습니다. 자신을 트랜스로 보는 것을 멈추고 일과 야외 활동, 사람들과 어울리는 데 집중하자 우울증이 나아졌습니다. 지금 저는 청소년의 의학적 전환에 비판적이며 어린 소녀들에게 아무것도 바꿀 필요가 없다고 말하고 싶습니다.

전체 이야기

I've always been an adventurous, independent tomboy kind of girl — I like to hike, explore new places, write and draw, and build entire worlds in my head. I identified as trans (FtM, and sometimes non-binary) on and off for about four years, roughly from age 14 to 18, but I never actually took testosterone — my transition was social only, and I have since desisted. Looking back, I know I never actually wanted to be a man or wished I'd been born a boy. What I felt was envy toward FtM timelines — especially the pre-T ones, or the pictures of them as tomboy girls before they knew they were trans. I also looked up to fictional women who dressed like boys or defied traditional femininity, like Mulan and Arya Stark. I never fit in with other girls my age. Not since I was about five years old did I feel like I was one of them, and after puberty they might as well have been a different species. I would have been miserable trying to be as feminine or trendy as everyone around me. People constantly told me they thought I was a lesbian, especially in middle and high school, because I was such a tomboy who loved sports, climbing trees, riding rollercoasters, superheroes, and just being active. I was called gay a lot as a preteen and teenager for not being hyperfeminine. I was also a total nerd — no driving, no dating, no drugs, no sneaking out — basically a square in everyone else's eyes. On top of that, I had a delayed puberty: I was prepubescent until 14 and then looked like an awkward middle schooler throughout high school, which made me feel ugly and immature. I began identifying as queer in some way — mostly lesbian — at age 13, and I stayed in the LGBT community in some form for five years, until 18. Growing up in that community, being a masculine woman was portrayed as the only way to be strong and cool, while femininity was seen as weak or shallow, so I didn't allow myself to like girly things until I was 18. I rationalized being weird and different by calling myself gay or trans rather than just accepting that I was weird and different. I also didn't think I was pretty enough to be a girl, never mind a straight girl, and I never could relate to the stereotypes of a straight girl or want the classic stereotypical female role in a relationship. The internet and peer environment played a huge role. Entire friend groups at my middle school, high school, and even my job (with people in their twenties) were trans or LGBTQ+. I watched a single 3–5 minute FtM transition video once and it made me question whether I was trans for weeks. I've come to believe the ideology is like a drug to insecure teenagers, especially girls. It gives easy explanations for the confusion of adolescence — and it stretches beyond trans identity to mental illness labels, neurodivergence labels, and sexuality labels. I also think a lot of young people are trying to escape misogyny and stereotypes: 'Yes I'm wearing makeup and dresses and have a boyfriend but I'm not a DUMB GIRL, I'm a cool BOY,' which is sexist overall. Before the internet, I knew who I was; I hate to say it, but I think the internet can make someone think they're trans who isn't. What moved me out was largely just stepping away. I completely removed myself from the trans discourse and dismantled the ideas of feminine and masculine — clothes are clothes, and wearing a suit as a woman doesn't make you trans or gay. I started buying and wearing things I liked, without attaching labels like 'girl/boy' or 'masc/fem.' I also got less depressed simply by getting up, going out, working, and talking to people — doing things and focusing on other people worked miracles for my depression. When I stopped identifying as trans and attributing all my problems to that, I had to face the fact that I really hated myself and felt ugly and immature. I never took hormones or had any surgeries, so I have no medical complications or irreversible changes to deal with. I don't have trauma. I did go through a phase of 'well if I can't transition, nobody can' and would have been considered internally transphobic; now I don't really know how to feel about trans people. I don't want anybody to hurt themselves with experimental drugs or puberty blockers, and I think transitioning pushes the narrative that 'if I'm not a traditional girl/boy, I NEED to become the opposite sex to do/be the things I want.' I've been critical of the 'lesbian masterdoc' — I noted the author ended up realizing she was bi and in denial of it at the time of writing — though I said I'd give it another read for self-reflection. Sexuality is still something I'm figuring out. I've had huge crushes on male characters, celebrities, and some guys I know in real life, though my only boyfriend was a disaster that lasted a week. I used to like girls too. Depending on whether I identified as straight or gay, I'd only look at the desired gender. I may be bi, but labels feel complicated to me; I'm not even sure I'm LGBT at this point. I don't think I experience comphet. Right now it's more about figuring out things about myself than slapping a label on anything. Coming out of all this felt like going through the coming-of-age most 13-year-old girls experience, but at 18 — makeup, bras, building the confidence to wear a swimsuit after eight years. I didn't accept that I liked girly things until 18, and now I'm trying to be more feminine just because I enjoy it. I'm back to being a 'girl tomboy' as an adult. I frequently think that if I'd grown up in the 80s like my mom, I'd have been just one tomboy in a crowd of tomboys, it would have been totally normal, I wouldn't have been called gay at 11 or 12, and I'd never have thought I was anything other than a girl — a straight girl at that. Now everything is so black and white: you're either sexualized at 15 or you're trans. I don't regret any specific medical procedure because I never had one, but I do regret the years lost to the identity rabbit hole and the confusion. I'd do anything to tell young girls they're perfect as they are and don't need to change a thing. I was just barely old enough to have the sense to get out of what I now see as a cult.