모든 이야기

r/detrans의 조력자로, 트랜스로 자기규정한 두 아이를 걱정한다

여성 · 단념801
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 여성으로 태어난 마흔아홉 살이 넘은 여성으로, 디트랜지션하지는 않았지만 트랜스 정체성을 가진 두 명의 젊은 성인 자녀를 둔 걱정하는 부모이자 오래된 페미니스트이며 동맹으로서 r/detrans에서 읽고 씁니다. 저는 1980년대 십 대 시절 폭식증을, 이후에는 건강 불안을 겪었고 치료와 SSRI로 관리했으며, 섭식장애에서의 지속적인 회복은 Kim Chernin의 책 덕분이라고 생각합니다. 저는 젠더 정체성 이데올로기와 트랜스 의료의 확인만 하는 모델에 비판적이며, 망설이는 사람들에게 먼저 OCD나 우울증을 다루고 의학적 전환 전에 기다리라고 적극 권합니다. 저는 전환을 한 적이 없고 전환 후회도 없습니다. 저의 주된 걱정은 19세와 21세인 트랜스 정체성의 두 자녀가 의학적 전환을 시작하지 않도록 막는 것입니다. 현재 저는 시스젠더 여성이자 디트랜지션한 사람들의 동맹으로 정체화합니다.

전체 이야기

I am a woman, born female, who is not detransitioned myself but who reads and posts regularly in the r/detrans community. I have described myself as an ally, an old feminist, and a worried parent rather than a detransitioner. I was a teenager in the 1980s, and I have said I am approaching 50, 49, and 50 in various 2019 comments, and 'almost 50' in early 2020. In my teens I was bulimic — I have called bulimia my 'self-harm of choice' — and I said every girl I knew was self-hating and self-harming in some way. I credited my recovery to two books: a Geneen Roth book and 'The Obsession' by Kim Chernin, and I have lived 30+ years with no food or body issues. I also struggled for years with health anxiety, which I described as having a lot in common with OCD, and said that for me SSRIs were a miracle. I have mentioned being prescribed Sertraline (Zoloft) at some point. I quit smoking about 25 years before late 2019 but still crave cigarettes weekly. I left home at 17 because my parents prohibited me from seeing my then-19-year-old boyfriend. I am a mother of two children — I have said my kids are 19 and 21 (August 2019), college-aged (August 2019), and that my eldest came out as non-binary 3 years earlier while my 19-year-old identified as FTM beginning at age 17. Both of my kids are trans-identified; they live at home, tell me things, know my concerns, and so far have not pursued medical transition even though they have said they want to. I have described my FTM kid as having a closet full of plaid pants and homemade mlm t-shirts layered over long sleeves. I have also referred to a toddler nephew. I limit and monitor my kids' internet access and block porn. I have never claimed to be detrans, but I have said things like 'I might well be on that path' if I had come of age 30 years later, and I have written about my own adolescent body distress, my eating disorder, and my relationship with womanhood. I have said I am 'a really good student, a really deep and thorough learner of my culture's lessons for girls' and that oppressive cultural expectations for women gave rise to my mental health issues. I have said I have been diagnosed with and treated for mental illnesses but am reluctant to view self-loathing, anxiety, and body discomfort as mental health issues when they are taught and learned. I have also referred to having autism and social anxiety when addressing someone else — actually, I wrote that to another poster ('As a person with autism and social anxiety you're already at a deficit'), so that is not my own diagnosis. I have a strong, critical view of gender identity ideology. I do not believe gender identity is innate and sacred, and I have suggested that perhaps no gender exists inside anyone at all. I have argued that adolescent-onset gender dysphoria is in all cases driven by misogyny — a devaluing of femaleness — and that all shame about being seen as a woman is internalized misogyny. I have been critical of trans healthcare, of the affirmation-only model, of Planned Parenthood prescribing testosterone, and of the lack of studies on outcomes for females transitioning as minors. I have said there are zero studies on outcomes for females transitioning as minors. I have defended the LGB Alliance as left-leaning and not anti-trans, and I have argued that detransitioned people should be included in LGB advocacy. I have pushed back on the use of the word 'mutilation' because it does not help detransitioned people heal, and I have repeatedly asked that the sub be kept focused on detrans stories rather than political commentary by non-transitioned people. I have said I am not detrans and I do not generally see hate and fear on the sub, only honest disagreement. I have given extensive advice to questioning and detrans people: to wait, to be 2000000% certain before medical transition, to treat OCD (T-OCD/H-OCD) before considering gender dysphoria, to consider that depression may underlie the feelings, to consider that testosterone is not benign (secondary polycythemia, blood clots, vaginal atrophy, lifelong medical dependence), and that HRT's only medical purpose is cosmetic phenotype change. I have recommended ACT, mindfulness meditation, OCD specialists, the IOCDF, Cari Stella's videos, Felix Conrad's 'How to Jedi Mindtrick Your Gender Dysphoria,' and various books. I have also advised parents on how to handle trans-identified kids: don't control presentation, do limit internet, don't prohibit binding outright but negotiate, keep trust, and use resources like Sasha Ayed, Brie Jontry/4th Wave Now, and the Pique Resilience Project. I have been open about my own experience when it seemed useful: my bulimia, my health anxiety and SSRIs, my experience of ovulation-related symptoms across 35 years of menstruation, my age and how sexual objectification fades after 30, and my own mother's expectations. I have told people that I am not detrans but that I read the sub to learn. I have also been candid about struggling with anger and panic about trans ideology but choosing not to express it in the detrans space. I have not described any transition, hormones, or surgeries of my own. I have not described detransition regret because I have not transitioned. My concerns are about my children's potential transition and about the cultural and medical landscape around gender dysphoria.