이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 필리핀 출신의 디트랜지션 게이 남성으로, 에스트로겐 주사(대략 2018~2023년)로 약 6년간 트랜스 여성으로 살았고 2년 전 디트랜지션해 다시 남성으로 제시하고 있습니다. 저는 주로 내면화된 동성애혐오, 거부하는 아버지, 여성적이라는 이유의 괴롭힘, 그리고 여성이 되면 남성에 대한 끌림이 받아들여지고 남성 파트너를 찾을 수 있으리라는 믿음 때문에 트랜지션했습니다——그것은 일어나지 않았습니다. 디트랜지션은 심한 패스 불안을 해소했지만, 저는 여전히 불쾌감, 신체 이형, 우울, 여성에 대한 질투, 그리고 매력 없는 아직 동정인 게이 남성으로서의 격렬한 외로움에 시달리며, 2025년 말에도 재트랜지션 충동이 강했습니다. 가장 힘들 때 저는 삶을 끝내려는 충동과 싸우고 욕망에서 벗어나려 화학적 거세를 고려했다고 말했으며 치료사를 찾고 있었습니다. 저는 호르몬 자체는 후회하지 않지만 잃은 시간, 우정, 경력을 후회하며, 지금은 트랜지션에, 특히 여성적인 게이 남성에 대해 비판적이면서 엄격한 게이트키핑과 성별은 바꿀 수 없다는 수용을 촉구합니다.
전체 이야기
I am a gay man from the Philippines who lived as a trans woman for about six years and detransitioned two years ago. I first realized I was gay around age 7 and was very feminine as a child — my gait, speech, behavior and personality — and I was bullied for it throughout high school by my father and male classmates whenever I showed soft emotions or excitement. My father was a poor role model with vices who had an affair with a prostitute and fathered four more children with her, and he hated me for being gay; that, plus growing up in a homophobic, religious society, gave me internalized homophobia and the belief that I needed to be a woman for my attraction to men to be valid. I also fell in love with multiple straight men who rejected and ignored me, while gay men did not want me because I was feminine, and I envied women for their easier dating prospects.
I started estrogen injections in 2018 at age 23 (I have also said 24) and lived as a trans woman for about five to six years, until I stopped hormones around August 2023 at age 29. I never presented fully as a woman — just long hair and plucked eyebrows — and I only passed about 50/50, which gave me severe social anxiety: I would cover up with hoodie, mask, hat and tied-back long hair when going out, avoided interviews and social contact, and felt like a fake. Despite that, I did reach a level of passability where people called me a beautiful tall Asian woman, and I liked many effects of estrogen — softer skin, no acne, no balding, youthful look, better complexion, calmer mood, low libido — but I developed cup A breasts, which I could hide with a sports bra. I never had surgery; I had considered SRS early on but there is no insurance coverage for it in my country, and I decided against it because of cost, risk of losing sensation, complications and years of dilation. I also worried about my height (5'9, taller than 95% of men and far above the 4'11 female average in the Philippines), which hurt my passing and fed body dysmorphia.
I stopped hormones in August 2023 because transition was expensive, unhealthy, socially isolating, and because I realized I would never actually be a woman; my social anxiety largely disappeared after detransitioning and I could go outside and talk to strangers without fear. However, my dysphoria and internalized homophobia persisted: I described feeling empty as a man, no longer caring about my appearance, and being jealous of women. My testicles grew back to about 1.4x their HRT size within three weeks of stopping, and testosterone returned to near-normal within four to six weeks. I noted that estrogen improved my mood and eliminated my depression, while being back on testosterone made me feel emotionless, angry, and hypersexual with very high libido.
Mental health-wise, I have dealt with depression, social anxiety, body dysmorphia, and what I call dysphoria that never went away despite passing. Around April 2024, newly turned 30 and in a new city, I described being depressed, watching straight porn 1-2 hours a day trying to make myself straight, considering chemical castration to kill my desires, having no friends, still being a virgin, and fighting urges to end myself by thinking about traveling and experiencing life first; I was looking for a therapist. I have said I might die a virgin but that many people die sexless. After the first few months of feeling amazing, by around a year into detransition (mid-2024) my anxiety worsened again, fearing testosterone was ruining my face and body, and I still had zero romantic attention as a gay man. By late 2025 at age 31, I reported a strong urge to retransition because of loneliness, having never had an actual relationship, though I had flings and a long-term online relationship while trans.
I now identify as a gay man, though I still struggle with wishing I had been born female and sometimes contemplate retransitioning or manmoding on estrogen. I do not regret hormones because they taught me about myself, but I regret the lost time, lost friends, stalled career, and the delusion that transition would bring me love. I am critical of transition for others, especially for feminine gay men like myself, whom I believe are often pushed into it by internalized homophobia; I have called trans identification a mental disorder in my own case, argued that sex cannot be changed, urged strict gatekeeping, warned against surgery while unsure, and described the rise of transition among youth as a "social pandemic." I have not described any formal advocacy or activism beyond posting and commenting in detransition communities.