소아 전환에 의문을 제기했다는 이유로 인터섹스 서브레딧에서 차단당했다
남성 · 단념398
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 XXY(클라인펠터) 증후군의 인터섹스 남성이며 트랜지션도 디트랜지션도 한 적이 없습니다. 저는 남성으로, 그리고 이성애자로 정체화하면서도 제가 '정확히 시스도 아니고 완전히 이성애자도 아니다'라는 점을 인정합니다. 저는 인터섹스 커뮤니티가 이념적으로 포섭되었다고 느껴 r/detrans와 젠더비판적 공간에 참여하며, 소아 젠더 긍정 치료에 의문을 제기한 이유로 주요 인터섹스 서브레딧에서 차단되었습니다. 저는 분열성 인격장애와 자폐 진단을 모두 받았습니다. 저는 젠더 비순응적 중년(2023년 말 기준 47세) 남성으로 제 몸을 받아들이며, 오늘날 성별 불쾌감으로 읽힐 어린 시절 경험에 공감하지만 트랜스인 것에는 공감하지 않습니다. 저는 소아 트랜지션, 트랜스 활동의 자살 수사, PCOS와 인터섹스 상태의 혼동에 비판적 견해를 가지고 있습니다.
전체 이야기
I was born male with XXY (Klinefelter) syndrome, an intersex/DSD condition, and I have identified as a man and as heterosexual, while acknowledging I'm 'not exactly cis and not entirely hetero' but that those labels are closest to true for me. I've never questioned my identity or detransitioned — I'm not detrans — but I participate in detrans and gender-critical spaces because I feel my own intersex community has 'been captured by ideologues and impostors.'
Growing up, I was gender non-conforming partly by preference and partly due to biological realities: I have natural A-cup breasts (which I minimize with button-up shirts), long hair I keep flowing and will never lose to baldness, and I've been teased since childhood for running, throwing, swinging, kicking, hitting, sitting, and thinking 'like a girl' — I joke that XXY guys are 'the original femboi demigirls.' I had at least one tomboy best friend as a kid and relate to traditionally feminine childhood play (play house, séances) as well as traditionally masculine play (spaceships, guns, swords). I have firsthand experience with misgendering and bullying, and with something 'as close to GD as body dysmorphia gets.' I describe my relationship to my body as 'radical acceptance' — of my 'unhairy permamoobs' and everything else — and I guarantee people would have called me 'a trans kid, an egg' had I been born in this generation. I relate to feeling 'male between the legs, female between the ears,' but I do not relate to being a trans woman at all.
I'm now middle-aged — I noted being 47 in one comment — and I've never fathered children, never set foot in a gym, and I'm now comfortable enough to take my shirt off and swim in public because 'nobody gives a fuck anymore.' I describe myself as INFJ, demisexual, a 'people-pleasing nerd,' and gender non-conforming. I've never been on hormones or had surgeries related to gender; I have no detransition story of my own.
Mental health: I've disclosed 'having had both diagnoses' in the context of schizoid personality disorder and autism, indicating I've received both of those diagnoses at some point. I don't describe treatment or severity beyond that.
My involvement in these communities is largely ideological/advocacy: I critique pediatric gender-affirming care, question the conflation of PCOS with intersex conditions, argue about sex-segregated spaces, and defend a strictly biological understanding of sex. I was banned from the main intersex subreddit for questioning pediatric GAC, and I frequent r/detrans using the 'questioning' flair out of respect for the moderators, though I joke I might switch to 'desister.' I've linked the Ayala v. AAP lawsuit complaint multiple times and called gender-affirming care 'the biggest medical scandal of all time.' I'm critical of trans activism's framing of suicide risk as coercive ('blackmail, ransom, coercion'), and skeptical of the commonly cited low regret statistic. I hold Blanchardian views, referencing AGP, and I'm critical of what I see as ideological capture of intersex and medical communities. I don't express personal regret about transition because I never transitioned; my concerns are about others, especially minors, undergoing medical interventions.