에스트로겐 수년, 작은 가슴, 그리고 단 한 번도 여성이 아니었던 삶
남성 · 탈전환26
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 남성으로 태어나 사회적·의료적 전환을 거쳤고 수년간 에스트로겐을 복용했지만 이를 중단했으며, 지금은 사회적으로 남성이거나 논바이너리로 자신을 규정하며 여성으로 정체화한 적은 없습니다. 저는 주로 신체적 효과를 위해 호르몬을 선택했지만 작은 가슴과 창백한 피부 외에 별로 얻은 것이 없었고, 그것으로 인해 불행하고 건강하지 않다고 말해 왔습니다. 저의 전환 이력은 메스암페타민 사용과 얽혀 있는데, 사람들이 저에게 반대 성별의 옷을 입히고 제가 트랜스가 될 수 있다고 말했으며, 대학 시절의 크로스드레싱에 깊은 수치심을 느낍니다. 저는 도움을 청했지만 자폐, 우울증, 사회적 불안이라는 변하는 진단을 받았고 더 깊은 문제를 찾는 방법을 물었습니다. 저는 전환과 디트랜지션 모두에 대해 여전히 유보적이며, 질문하는 사람들에 대한 적대감이라고 제가 여기는 것 때문에 디트랜스 포럼에서 다른 사람들과 여러 번 충돌했습니다.
전체 이야기
I was born male. I don't remember exactly when I first started feeling unhappy with my body, but I know that puberty is what really did it for me — I've said plainly that I "just don't like what puberty did to my beautiful face and I feel ugly now and wish I were a cute androgynous tomboyish woman instead of a man sometimes." I've told people that I don't consider that a real problem, that "it's all in my head," and that when I've tried to get help, professionals "diagnose me with autism or depression or social anxiety. Something different every time."
I transitioned medically — I've been on estrogen for years. I described choosing it deliberately: "I literally read the effects of estrogen and the effects of testosterone and made my choice despite the risks and challenges." The physical side seems to have mattered most to me: "Maybe it's the physical aspect that pushed me over the line." What I wanted, I said, was unusual — "I don't want to be socially a woman. I almost want to be socially a man and biologically MTF." I've described myself as socially male or non-binary, and said I never identified as a woman: "I am socially male or non-binary, not a woman and never identified as such." I also used the label MTX rather than MTF at times.
The estrogen itself has been a disappointment. I said it's "basically done nothing for me," giving me only "small breasts and weirdly pale skin," and I haven't experienced shrinkage, anorgasmia, or erectile dysfunction. I also said I wanted to kill my sex drive because I'm ashamed of my sexual feelings, and wished the estrogen worked better at reducing my libido. I've defended the medical safety of what I took, saying "I've done estrogen for years and I'm not a zombie with cancer and heart disease," and arguing that bioidentical estrogen is different from synthetic or animal-derived estrogens. I've told others that stopping injections is fine and that most estradiol effects are reversible, citing someone I know whose breasts atrophied after stopping.
I desisted, and it's been hard. I changed my name to a masculine one and liked the name, yet felt "gutged" every time I heard or said it — a complete contrast to when I'd changed it to a feminine one. I've been unhappy and unhealthy on estrogen, and said it's had a negative indirect effect because it constantly reminds me of trans issues, which I called an unhealthy fixation for me.
There's a darker history I've alluded to. The only people who ever called me a trans woman, I said, were "the people I used to smoke meth with and usually they'd crossdress me once I was spun and tell me I was pretty and basically lie to me that I can or should be trans when really I can't and shouldn't." I've also said I'm ashamed of my college days, "basically being a public crossdresser," that it's embarrassing looking back, and that I try to pretend it never happened.
I've been in therapy or sought help, but felt it hasn't landed: I've asked "How do I identify the deeper issues?" and suggested seeing a medical professional about possible depression. I've recommended laser hair removal to others in detail (a dozen-plus sessions, turning up settings, sunscreen), dutasteride over finasteride, and DIY or switching doctors when blocked.
On the forums I've been combative and defensive. I feel the detrans sub is hostile to what I thought were moderate views, that it punishes any suggestion that trans people might exist, and that it's a bad environment for questioners — "you're not questioning if the conclusion is foregone." I got into extended arguments accusing others of willful misinterpretation, hostility, and calling me a liar for having transitioned. I argued trans women aren't claiming biological femaleness, that social/gender categories are constructs, and that simply transitioning isn't "living a lie." I've been downvoted heavily for these positions and told people are being assholes to me.
I've also given advice to others: it's okay to be a man without a beard, binders and layering can hide breasts, don't chase impossible beauty standards, ask whether you're doing something to conform to others' expectations or for yourself, and that detransitioning now doesn't preclude retransitioning later. I told someone I hoped someday to be "confident in transition and in detransition" like them, but that right now I feel apprehensive of both.