모든 이야기

2011년 이전의 호르몬, 그리고 맞서러 돌아간 한 클리닉

여성 · 탈전환3.1천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 매우 어린 미성년자(2011년 이전)였을 때 뉴욕주 시러큐스의 조슬린 센터에서 이성 호르몬을 받고 '상당히 멀리' 간 후 2015년경 디트랜지션한 디트랜지션 여성입니다. 저는 임상적으로 CPTSD가 있고, 포르노에 노출시킨 어른들에게 그루밍당했으며, 제 트랜지션은 너무 많은 것을 파괴해서 기능할 수 있는 것이 기적이라고 말합니다. 다시 자란 얼굴 털과 목소리 변화를 포함한 신체적 영향이 남아 있고, 저는 적극적으로 의학 연구를 찾고 제 진료에 대해 옛 클리닉에 맞섰습니다. 저는 좌파 성향의 공개적 레즈비언 디트랜지션 여성으로 트랜스 커뮤니티의 전술과 디트랜지션의 우익 포섭 모두에 비판적이며, detrans 공간과의 관여로 인한 번아웃과 고통을 겪습니다.

전체 이야기

I received cross-sex hormone therapy as a very young minor in Syracuse, New York, at the Joslin Center, from an older woman doctor — I believe her name was Dr. Irene Sillis — sometime before 2011. I have described that care as more cautious than what a lot of kids deal with now, but still 'pretty reckless.' The Joslin Center's current public Google presence obscures that any transgender clinic operated there, which I find disconcerting. I also went to a counseling center run by a woman who made gender work her life's mission, and that clinic is the one that referred me for hormones. I detransitioned roughly eight years before April 2023, so around 2015, and I have said I have been off testosterone for 8+ years. I transitioned as a very young minor, and I have said that the feelings I had then were 'extremely typical of that life phase' and should not be compared to adults feeling the same way. I am female. I accepted that I am unchangeably female and that I could make the social steps to living this truth in a more publicly understood way. I am a detransitioned woman, not a desister — I do not have dysphoria that makes me want to be the opposite sex; I only have dysphoria that makes me want to completely undo the effects of testosterone. I have said I am 'highly skeptical of transition in any situation.' I have described my transition experience as having taken and destroyed so much that 'it is a miracle I can even function on a daily basis.' I have said cross-sex hormones are not good for your physical health and that the health risks I undertook 'should never have been clinically approved.' I have faced discrimination for being detrans as well as for other reasons. I have said I have immense psychological pain from having done cross-sex HRT because lack of knowledge of side effects is scary, and that it has left me visibly socially marginal unless I invest extra time in cosmetics, and led to various social traumas that haunt me years later. I have clinically known CPTSD. I have noticed that vitamin B1 has a major impact on my twitching, more so than B12. I have said I have been in different new age cults. I have said I feel like I escaped cultic abuse. I have discussed having facial hair that returned after incomplete laser hair removal and later electrolysis, and I have asked about shaving products because the regrown hair is coarse and I nick myself. I have said I did incomplete laser two years before electrolysis, and about four years later it started coming back patchy but noticeable. I have had voice work — I did not tell the instructor I was living as trans at the time, and she wondered why my range seemed different from a typical male range; I found it worth it and it helped me feel better about my voice. The Joslin Center commented only that my voice sounded female enough when I detransitioned and then washed their hands of the case. I have tried to be studied as a medically detransitioned woman because there seem to be no studies on the physical impacts of cross-sex HRT after detransitioning. Some of my personal tests have come back negative for any signs of diseases in some areas, and I have said I would like to report healthy results and test for unknowns because I believe people need proper data rather than scaremongering or hugboxing. I have said I actually think anyone pro-transition should want me to be studied because my results have come back so positively. I reached out to the old therapy clinic that referred me for hormones and got a message back the same day asking me to send an email explaining why I felt it was neglectful and which clinician I saw. The person on the phone apologized. I later said the conversation went better than expected; I kept it diplomatic and focused on helping those who detransition and helping science advance. I was afraid I might lowball myself out of much-needed compensation, and I was cynical about what they could do without being threatened with a lawsuit. I was groomed by individual adults who exposed me to porn in real life in order to cultivate it as a sense of identity, and by being screamed at for expressing myself in ways counter to the narrative they wanted for me. It was not merely exposure to the existence of gender nonconforming or gay people. My parents never divorced. My parents were not the ones described in a thread I commented on — I noted that in that poster's case, the parents only did what they could while treating the child as a family scapegoat. I went to an extremely fringe college similar to Oberlin. I have said I am disabled and live in the USA, in a country where the social safety net for the abysmal. I am tired of being tokenized by politicians promoting policies I believe will lead to more abuse of the disabled. I have been pulled over at TSA for not having a penis many times. I have said I am a rocker, not a mod. I have said I am burnt out on gender ideology and that scrolling the detrans subreddit is an overall detriment to me, and that I would have a drastic increase in life quality the less I engage with the topic. I proposed a newsletter or blog that would relay research and medical information without requiring social engagement with the community, because I think the current structure acts as a filter and causes retraumatization. I said I was leaving the community and that it would probably be my last thread for a while, though I continued posting. I have said I am ideologically a leftist/Marxist detransitioned person and that right wingers do not primarily agree with me. I think gender nonconformity is fine and that homosexuality is in some ways morally superior to heterosexuality. I am concerned about the strong polarization of detrans platforms to the right and want detransition to be a nonpartisan issue. I am very concerned about Project 2025. I have said I am a lesbian and that much of the lesbian community has been wrecked by the current situation. I have said I cannot convincingly lie about being genderqueer. I have said I am female but also feel like I escaped cultic abuse. I have expressed strong views that the trans community engages in abuser and cult tactics, that a certain other detrans-adjacent subreddit exists primarily for coercive control, and that a librarian's comic series depicting a murder fantasy about a detransitioned woman was genuinely frightening. I have said I am highly skeptical of transition but that part of medicine and peer-reviewed science is working with people you do not 100 percent agree with, and I welcomed Dr. Will Powers's efforts into detransition healthcare. I have said I regret not doing Job Corps when I was younger. I have said I assumed I would re-transition when I went to another country where it is legal, but I did not, because I already knew completely logically and soberly what I needed to do. I have said that being gender nonconforming or having trauma should not result in being given experimental hormones. I have said that no one ever deserved to be lied to, even people who say they like that they were on blockers.