단 한 번도 전환하지 않은 채 r/detrans에서 보낸 5년
여성 · 단념700
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 타고난 성별에 일치하는 여성으로, 트랜지션도 디트랜지션도 한 적이 없지만 2019년 7월부터 r/detrans와 관련 커뮤니티에서 활발하고 목소리를 내며 조언과 댓글을 제공해 왔습니다. 미성년자에 대한 사춘기 차단제와 호르몬 대체 요법, 너무 성급히 처방한다고 제가 보는 젠더 전문 치료사, 그리고 사람들을 되돌릴 수 없는 시술로 밀어붙인다고 제가 보는 트랜스 온라인 공간에 비판적입니다. 성인 트랜스의 트랜지션 권리는 지지하지만, 호르몬과 수술이 과도하게 홍보되고 규제가 부족하다고 믿으며, 주류 트랜스 활동이 디트랜지션한 사람들을 무시한다고 제가 보는 점에서 그들을 옹호해 왔습니다. 제 관여는 제 몸과 가슴과 목소리에 대한 개인적 불편에서 부분적으로 비롯되었고, 그것을 의학적 개입 없이 다뤄 왔습니다. 호르몬도 수술도 받은 적이 없고 디트랜지션 이야기도 없습니다.
전체 이야기
I have never transitioned and I am not detransitioned — I have said so repeatedly in these communities — but I have spent a lot of time in detrans spaces since around mid-2019, reading and offering advice, and I want to lay out how I came to be here and what I think.
I first started posting in July 2019, mostly responding to people who were questioning whether to start testosterone or to detransition. My advice was consistent: don't live a lie because it seems more convenient; there are flat-chested, tomboyish women who live happy lives; living as something you're not is a mental struggle. I told people that coming out again would be hard but that the people who care about them would rather know the truth. I also pushed back on the medical side early on — after Buck Angel's health scare in July 2019 I wrote that anyone medically transitioning should know every risk, and that it was "despicable that medical professionals aren't warning patients."
I have never taken hormones myself, but I have been very deliberate about researching their effects. I told people that females on testosterone are supposedly four times more at risk of heart disease, that HRT can cause atrophied sex organs, brittle bones, and shortened life spans, and that you can't pick and choose which changes happen to you. I warned about binders — deformed ribs, fainting, damaged breast tissue — and about the risks of hysterectomy and oophorectomy, including increased Alzheimer's risk from medically induced menopause. I have said plainly that I am "not a doctor" when speculating about these things.
I am a cisgender woman. I have never identified as trans, but I do have my own complicated relationship with femininity: I wrote in May 2020 that I have hidden my chest with baggy shirts, layers, and slouching, felt "super uncomfortable, even around family," and haven't been swimming in a decade because I disliked how little swimsuits covered and feared missing a spot when shaving. My voice is on the lower side — I get called a guy or a prepubescent boy in online game voice chats, which I said isn't flattering when you're already aware of how masculine your voice sounds. I also mentioned slouching as a hard habit to kick and joked about needing a back brace.
My views on transition are conditional rather than absolute. I have said I support trans adults doing what they want, that gender dysphoria is a real feeling, and that healthy adults should be allowed HRT provided they've had extensive therapy and medical tests. But I am strongly opposed to puberty blockers and HRT for children, saying I "sure as shit wouldn't give hormone blockers to my kid, or HRT to my teenager." I am critical of gender therapists, whom I described as pushy and eager to hand out HRT, and of online trans spaces, which I called "hugboxes" that glorify transitioning and gloss over side effects. I have also written about Discord and 4chan groups that actively encourage people toward HRT and surgery, and about the pressure some trans people put on others to get SRS.
I have been vocal about what I see as the failures of the trans-activist mainstream. I have argued that removing gender dysphoria from the DSM, combined with anti-discrimination protections, makes it impossible to criticize transition medicine without being called hateful. I have defended detransitioners directly — telling one person "You exist, and they don't like that" and insisting that regretters are real and their experiences shouldn't be downplayed. In May 2020 I posted a thread asking how actual detransitioners felt about a YouTube video that dismissed them, and I spent several comments criticizing the video for using outdated, unlinked studies and for treating detransitioners as an insignificant minority whose experiences don't matter. I noted that the video's creator contradicted himself by saying "we should support them" while also framing detransitioners as TERFs with an agenda.
I have also been banned from a trans surgery subreddit for politely disagreeing with a comparison someone made about facial feminization surgery; I noted that the person who scoped out my profile branded me a TERF and got me instantly banned, while a trans person who agreed with me was left alone. I have said I am "not a single letter of that acronym."
On causes of gender dysphoria, I have written extensively about alternatives: sexual abuse leading people to hate their bodies, abuse by someone of the same sex, hating resemblance to an abusive parent, sissification porn, internalized sexism and homophobia in "signs you're trans" content, and general insecurity about being sexualized. I have said that stopping porn consumption has stopped dysphoric feelings for some people, and that being a tomboy or butch lesbian doesn't make someone a man. I have also written about the egg-adjacent content I see as grooming — asking minors about genitals, masturbation, and porn habits — and about how lonely, vulnerable people get drawn into these communities because they seem inviting.
I have never had surgery, never been on hormones, and have no personal detransition story. What I have is a long, sustained engagement with other people's stories, a lot of independent research into medical risks, and my own unresolved discomfort with my body and voice that I've worked through by other means. I continue to post in these spaces, mostly offering the same message: take your time, figure out the underlying cause of your distress, don't rush into permanent decisions, and look after the healthy body you have.