모든 이야기

7세의 성별 불쾌감, 운동이 오기 전에 디시스트하다

여성 · 단념1.4천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 여성으로 태어났고 2000년대 초중반 7세경부터 아동기 성별 디스포리아가 있었으며 의료적 트랜지션을 전혀 하지 않고 디시스트했습니다 — 호르몬도 수술도 받은 적이 없습니다. 제 디스포리아는 주로 내면화된 여성 혐오, 따돌림, 우울, 불안에서 비롯된다고 생각하며 현재의 트랜스 운동이 존재하기 전에 자란 것을 기쁘게 여깁니다. 이제 "정의상 논바이너리"이며 "약간 남자아이 같은 면"이 있는 디시스트한 여성으로 자신을 규정하고 she/her 대명사를 사용하며 트랜스로는 규정하지 않지만, 경미한 사회적/이름 디스포리아와 임신 및 큰 가슴에 대한 디스포리아가 있습니다. 사회복지 석사 과정 학생이며 대부분의 문제에서 정치적으로 좌파이지만 아동기 의료적 트랜지션, 사춘기 차단제, 여성 스포츠의 트랜스 여성에 강하게 비판적이어서 직업적·사회적 관계에서 소외감과 죄책감을 느낍니다. 성적 학대 관계로 인한 PTSD, 중단한 자해 이력, 간질이 있으며 치료를 받고 있습니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female and grew up in the early and mid 2000s, a childhood I consider lucky because, as I put it, "the agenda wasn't a thing back in the mid 2000s, so I was spared being told I was, in fact, a boy, and that I should be given hormone blockers." I qualified for gender dysphoria as a child — I remember having a feeling that something was "off" since around age 7 — but crucially I never had a problem with my body itself. I wanted to be seen as a boy, not to become one physically. I thought it was physically impossible to be the opposite sex but I wanted to be a boy. I hated everything feminine, apart from two "girly phases" which were the exception to the rule, and even during those phases I was embarrassed to present feminine, so I outgrew them and went back to qualifying for gender dysphoria. I felt femininity was the embodiment of weakness, and I still partly feel that. I was being bullied somewhat and had significant depression and anxiety during that period. I am grateful that the trans movement was nonexistent then. I desisted. Even after I conformed and became "normal" to society, I went back to wearing male-typical clothing at 20. I don't wear bras anymore and don't shave my legs either — both of which embarrass me a little, but I remind myself how sexist those roles are and that it's up to me to resist sexism and my own internalized misogyny. I'm SOOOO much more comfortable not wearing bras. I have long hair because I like it. By the time I was writing about this in 2020, I was 23. I no longer qualified for gender dysphoria or as trans. I don't particularly want to be a guy, and I'm okay with my body, other than hating the fact that I'll never be as physically strong as males. I still present gender nonconforming and feel it empowers me more than dressing in a manner typical for women. My behavior is a mixture of gender-neutral and occasional feminine stuff — jumping up and down, squealing, clapping when excited — but I really hate it when I cry, and I cry very easily. I never took hormones, never had surgery, and never changed my pronouns. I still use she/her/hers and call myself a girl "out of linguistic convenience," even though that's not completely how I feel inside. I go by the gender-neutral nickname Jess rather than my full legal name Jessica, and I have mild dysphoria — "name dysphoria" — when the full name is used or when I'm encouraged to be more feminine. I also dislike being compared to other women. I described myself as "desisted female" and, at various points, as non-binary: "I feel that I'm enby with a side salad of guy." I said I was "by definition non-binary" but also that I sometimes said "Who am I kidding. I'm not non-binary." I acknowledged myself as physically female and would join the women's sports team, but on the inside felt like neither man nor woman, but "soooorta both." I explained this partly through spirituality: I believe in reincarnation, that we've all been male and female throughout many lives, so souls do not have a gender, and I've felt that way my whole life. I worried that identifying as partially a guy only worsened gender roles, and I was frustrated because I'm a very logical person and something that doesn't make sense makes me lose my cool mentally. I confused myself and it bothered me daily. The thoughts persisted: as an early teenager I had "I'm a guy" thoughts pop into my head daily, even though I had started conforming more by then. I've had the thought that I'm a guy pop in my head every day for a very long time. I never wanted male secondary sex characteristics; I was fine with and still am fine with my female body. I'm heterosexual — "strangely enough, I've always been straight" — and I'm not attracted to tall or muscular men, which I think is partly because I feel my own masculinity is threatened and I'm being emasculated. I was not sexually active. What I have come to see as the cause is internalized misogyny: "I feel more comfortable in masculine roles especially due to the fact that I felt femininity is the embodiment of weakness." I still kind of feel that. I also think I'd have been labeled trans today. I've said that given my past behaviors I would be assumed to be trans by today's standards and pushed to transition. I believe the internet and the trans movement planted seeds in my head that I should want to change my body and have more dysphoria than the little I have. When I obsessively look up trans stuff, it makes me have a slight desire for it. I noted that it was only when I learned about trans stuff that I started thinking "Hey, what if I were to take HRT/get top surgery?" — but I know I would regret it in reality. I feel like I'm supposed to want it and supposed to have more dysphoria than I do, which I recognize as incredibly toxic thinking. I have some body dysphoria around the idea of pregnancy and bigger breasts: both the thought of having bigger boobs and being pregnant (and even having the ability to get pregnant) give me some dysphoria. My hypothesis is that the idea of pregnancy is the pinnacle of womanhood and bigger breasts represent further femininity. At the same time, it wouldn't feel right to have a totally flat chest or a man's body. I'm lucky my breasts are small. I eventually want a tubal ligation — not for gender reasons primarily but for reproductive autonomy: I don't want kids, it's not medically a good idea for me or the kids, and pregnancy would make me dysphoric. I'm epileptic, on medication that can result in birth defects, and stress has caused breakthrough seizures, so being exposed to the stresses of parenthood is dangerous for me. I can't see myself as a parent other than maybe adopting an older child one day. I wanted to wait at least another year to solidify the tubal decision, by which point I'd be 25. I also said it's basically impossible to find a doctor willing to sterilize me at my young age of 23, while it's easy to find doctors fine with giving pre-pubescent children hormone blockers — "Why am I less competent to make life changing decisions than 12 year olds?" I have epilepsy, which I've used as an analogy: taking medication doesn't cure my epilepsy, it just puts a bandaid on it. I also have PTSD from a sexually abusive relationship involving sexual coercion — it happened 60+ times over the course of the relationship, I describe it as the most humiliating experience possible, and I was working with a therapist. I had a two-week streak at one point where I was so angry I think I was capable of killing him, though I'm usually a very diplomatic and caring person. I also had a history of cutting, which I stopped. I was seeing a therapist who knew I considered myself non-binary but not how much frustration I'd been experiencing. I was a Master's of Social Work student planning to go into macro (public policy), which put me in an environment obsessed with labels — my grad school and potentially my future job. I described myself as a leftist on about 90% of other issues, with views I summarized as "Blaire White's views on trans stuff mixed with 90% of Bernie Sanders' views." I've gone to many protests and was proud of doing so. I emailed 60 Minutes thanking them for not apologizing for a segment. I posted on r/venting about issues I have with the trans community and was immediately labeled TERFy. On another account I was told to shut up and that I was being harmful for taking a scientific perspective. This created internal conflict, alienation, guilt, and what I called "internalized non-binaryphobia." I threw out a non-binary flag-painted letter above my bed and felt liberated, and I wanted to design my own flag representing the order of masculinity, femininity, and gender-neutral phases throughout my life — joking I should call myself "Jessgender." My dad made a dad joke about it. I found a sense of community on r/detrans. I never medically transitioned, so there are no medical complications or irreversible changes from transition. I have no regret about hormones or surgery because I never had them — I say repeatedly that I know I would regret HRT/surgeries. My regrets are more about lost time, internal conflict, and the influence of the movement. I remain critical of childhood medical transition, puberty blockers, trans women in women's sports, and what I see as censorship of research on detransition and regret. I'm desisted from childhood dysphoria, currently identify partly as non-binary but don't identify as trans, use she/her pronouns, and am comfortable in my female body.