모든 이야기

그녀는 전환하지 않았다 — 전처의 MtF 이야기가 대신 말했다

여성 · 단념111
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 디트랜지션 경험에 가까운 논평자이며 스스로 트랜지션한 사람은 아닙니다. 타고난 성별에 일치하는 양성애 여성이고 젠더 비판적이며 의학적 트랜지션을 한 번도 받지 않았습니다. 행복하지 않았던 전 아내의 트랜지션(MtF), 월경전 불쾌장애(PMDD)와 부신 문제, 4기 암, 그리고 BDSM/킨크 커뮤니티에서의 경험을 바탕으로 다른 이들에게 트랜지션을 서두르지 말라고 조언합니다. 젠더는 문화적으로 부여된 고정관념이며 그 고정관념을 해체하면 대부분의 성별 불쾌감이 해결될 것이라고 믿고, 수술이 도움이 될 수 있는 신체적 몸의 불쾌감과는 구분합니다. 성별 규범에 맞지 않는 사람들을 의료화하려는 압력이라고 제가 보는 것에 비판적이며, 스스로 여성이라고 밝히는 것 때문에 TERF 낙인이 찍힐까 걱정합니다. 트랜지션한 적이 없어 개인적 후회는 없지만 타인에 대한 조기 의학적 개입이라고 제가 보는 것에는 공개적으로 반대합니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female and grew up raised by my mother, a biology teacher, and I attended a math and science magnet school where about half the teachers and students were female. I describe myself as a woman, born woman, happy to be a woman, and I've never transitioned — my involvement in this community has been as someone offering advice and perspective to people considering transition or detransition. Growing up I was a punk rock biker chick in the mid-90s, with tattoos, piercings, leather. I went to a math/science focused high school, worked in an ISP tech support office where about half the staff were women, and I've held jobs I describe as 'girly' — motorcycle safety teacher in a Harley shop, tattoo shop manager, and machine operator at a factory. My hobbies are writing cyberpunk sci-fi and gaming, mostly FPS and PvP RP servers. I still present clearly female: long curly hair, skirts most of the time because they're comfortable. I identify as bi. I have a history of BDSM/kink community involvement — I mention regional BDSM/Kink community experiences and reference my 'time in BDSM culture' as part of why I understand the difference between sex/gender identity and kink or paraphilia. I use that experience to explain autogynephilia to people asking about arousal-linked gender feelings. I was married to an MtF trans person (I refer to them as my ex-wife). I describe their transition in detail: they were in therapy for two years before getting their SRS letter, and after starting estrogen they gained 45+ pounds concentrated around their stomach and hips in a pattern more typical of male fat distribution, giving them what I called a 'beer gut.' They were deeply unhappy with the result and told me they'd rather have been a skinny androgynous boy than spend their life looking like 'a fat or pregnant girl.' We 'kinda lived at the gym for a while' but the weight wouldn't come off. I told them 'welcome to life as a woman, sometimes no diet and exercise will force our bodies to lose the darn fat.' I didn't care how they looked as long as they were happier — but they weren't happier. This experience strongly shapes my view that doctors should warn patients that getting a female body doesn't guarantee the female body type you want. I also had an ex-girlfriend who yelled at me for shaving, and I currently have a boyfriend (who 'is super cute in a dress'). On my own health: I have PMDD and an adrenal disorder. I state I have to live on 800 calories a day and be at the gym every day to lose weight, and despite obsessively following every sane diet (Atkins, Paleo, etc.) I plateau at around 170 lbs, size 12-14. I also reveal I have stage IV cancer — my oncology team is puzzled that chemo isn't wrecking my immune system. I joke that chemo was what made me lose 20 lbs, though it was '20 lbs of fluid and tumor mass.' I also mention having sensory issues and being an 'aspie girl' (autistic), and I wear sports bras most of the time for comfort because my breasts annoy me sensory-wise. I have strong political and ideological views. I'm gender-critical: I believe gender is 'basically a set of stereotypes assigned to a physical/biological body shapes by a culture' and I point to cross-cultural examples (ancient Egypt, Greece, Scotland, Hopi, Chinese 'Walking Marriage') to argue there's no 'biological lady brain urge' to wear dresses. I'm critical of what I call the 'TRA movement' for pressuring AGP people and transvestites into transition, and I'm worried about being labeled a TERF for calling myself a cis-het-bio-female woman. I mention being 1/4 Choctaw and 1/4 Cherokee, appearing white. I've been sexually harassed and catcalled. I describe developing a 'murder walk' — head up, shoulders back, death glare, inspired by Charlize Theron's advice and the Winter Soldier — to get men to back off. I tell a story about stomping into a laundry room in a rage over a spilled soda on my leather jacket and frightening the catcallers who were in there. I also describe an 'insane evil grin' I use when men tell me to smile. I've walked a small (5'2", 125 lb) friend through a sketchy Chicago neighborhood at a gaming con while she brandished a Gatorade-filled prop syringe and recited the Jabberwocky at anyone who looked at her. I've given extensive advice to others in this community: encouraging a questioning person to explore whether they're AGP rather than trans before doing anything irreversible; advising a 14-year-old on how to talk to their parents about pausing transition; supporting someone who detransitioned after telling their parents ('Telling the truth is never betrayal'); and offering a young woman strategies for dealing with street harassment and family members making inappropriate comments about her body. I've speculated that VR therapy might help body-dysphoric people test out a different presentation before committing to hormones and surgery. I've also argued that much 'gender dysphoria' would resolve if societies fixed the stereotypes that create it, while distinguishing that from 'physical body dysphoria' where surgery may be the best option. I don't describe any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, or detransition — my role has been as an outside commentator drawing on my own life experiences (my ex-wife's transition, my health conditions, my career history, my kink community involvement) to advise others.