모든 이야기

30년의 치료와 마침내 와닿은 한 가지 질문

여성 · 단념1.1천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 캐나다에 사는 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 이전의 트랜스 정체성을 점차 허위 정체성으로 보게 되었고 지금은 디트랜지션을 고민하거나 겪는 사람들을 지원합니다. 저는 심한 우울증과 지속적인 가족 트라우마로 약 30년간 치료를 받았고 그동안 대부분의 SSRI를 시도했으며 SNRI가 더 도움이 된다고 느꼈습니다. 저는 제 불쾌감이 타고난 성별 정체성이 아니라 더 깊은 정서적 갈등에서 비롯되었다고 믿으며, 그것을 이해하도록 도운 것은 탐색적 치료였습니다. 저는 자료를 적극적으로 공유하고 디트랜스 이야기와 클리닉에 대한 불만을 지지하며, 미성년자의 의학적 전환에 반대하면서 성인 트랜스 사람들의 권리를 지지합니다. 저는 이 글에서 자살 생각이나 자해를 서술하지 않았습니다.

전체 이야기

I have been active on r/detrans since March 2023, mostly offering support, resources, and my own perspective to others who are questioning, desisting, or detransitioning. I am a detransitioned woman — I use the flair 'desisted female' on Reddit — and I live in Canada, where I have been treated for depression for decades under provincial health insurance. My own history: I experienced gender dysphoria when I was younger and went through a period of identifying as trans. I don't give exact ages for any of these milestones in my posts, so I'll leave the timeline vague rather than guess. What I can say is that I eventually came to see being trans as, in my own words, 'a false identity' for me, and I detransitioned. I have described myself as having 'experimented with what today would be called social transition when younger.' I have not described hormones or surgeries for myself in this transcript, so I won't claim those. What led me there, and what I now think about it: I have come to believe that gender dysphoria is usually a physical embodiment of other, deeper conflicts — trauma, anxiety, loneliness, social anxiety, feelings of never being 'enough.' I recommend the book *Gender Dysphoria* by Susan and Marcus Evans repeatedly because it articulates what I understand about my own experience: that people project unbearable emotional pain onto a body part and come to believe removing or changing it will cure the dysphoria, and for many it does not. I also believe the affirm-only model of care failed people like me. I was, in my view, caught in an era where only affirmation and medicalization were offered. I have been in therapy for a long time — I say '30 years in therapy (major ongoing family traumas and major depression here)' and elsewhere 'Did a lot of therapy and never regretted any of it at all; helped me rid myself of self-hatred and realize why this developed and how to give myself a break and learn to self-care.' I have been on various SSRIs for about 30 years, most of them, and found SNRIs best for my depression. I mention having been depressed but not medicated until my 30s. I have described myself as short, older, and new to Reddit. Adversity: I refer to 'major ongoing family traumas' and 'major depression' spanning roughly three decades. I don't elaborate further in this transcript. Sexuality: I have not described my own sexual orientation directly. Regret: I don't describe my own regret in detail here — most of my posts are advice to others — but I have spoken about transition regret as a real and widespread phenomenon, and I have framed my own trans identification as something I've had to work through and put behind me. I have suggested scripts for telling family that 'I am traumatized by my trans identifying years' and want to forget being part of that identity, which suggests residual pain for me too. What I do now: I post resources constantly — Genspect, the Gender Dysphoria Alliance, the Gender Exploratory Therapy Association (G.E.T.A.), Helena Kirscher, the Pique Resilience project, Ken Zucker, Ray Blanchard, Sasha Ayed, and the Canadian detransition booklet. I shared the Susan and Marcus Evans book, a post about a US detransition rate of 30%, and a Canadian detrans booklet. I have advocated for detransitioners to tell their stories publicly, for class-action lawsuits against clinics, for sex-discrimination challenges so detransitioned women can access restorative care (breast reconstruction, voice feminization, laser hair removal), and for exploratory therapy rather than affirmation for young people. I have also tried to connect a parent I know with a detransitioned young woman to talk to her trans-identified 15-year-old. Attitudes toward transition for others: I support trans adults' right to live as they choose and access medical care, and I explicitly say I don't oppose trans people — only what I call the 'ideology.' I am strongly opposed to medical transition for minors, cite the 80–96% desistance figure, and believe most youth dysphoria resolves with brain maturation into the mid-20s. I am critical of what I see as stereotypes enforced by trans ideology, of the erasure of sex-based women's spaces, and of the medical and pharmaceutical establishment profiting from lifelong medicalization. I do allow that a small minority — I estimate 0.2% — may be 'truly trans' and may benefit from adult transition. Current status: I am a detransitioned woman, living as female, in Canada, managing long-term depression with medication and therapy, and actively supporting others in the detransition community.