모든 이야기

2019년부터 r/detrans의 외부인

남성 · 단념3.4천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 성별 불쾌감을 겪은 적이 없고 트랜지션도 하지 않은 이성애 남성이지만 2019년부터 r/detrans 커뮤니티에서 활동적인 지지 구성원이자 조용한 참여자입니다. 사회 불안, 범불안, 우울과 씨름하며 약, 심리치료, 운동, 감사 실천, 자원봉사로 대처해 왔습니다. 의학적 트랜지션, 특히 미성년자에 대한 것에 비판적이며, 트랜지션 후 후회와 자살률에 관한 주장에는 회의적이지만 성인이 선택할 권리는 지지합니다. 저 자신은 트랜지션도 디트랜지션도 하지 않았기에 공유할 트랜지션 시기가 없습니다.

전체 이야기

I have been active in the r/detrans community since mid-2019, mostly offering support and advice to others rather than telling my own transition story in detail. I have never transitioned myself — I have repeatedly said I have never experienced gender dysphoria and have never taken hormones — but I have been a long-time participant in these discussions, and I have described myself as an older man who is 'on the old side' and who has been 'one to support struggling minorities' but grew troubled by the direction of the trans movement the more I learned about it. I have never experienced gender dysphoria, thank god, but when I read the stories of people here so much of what they go through sounds like normal young people's struggles. I have said that is probably why most people interested in transitioning are younger, and I have likened it to teenage black-and-white thinking: 'I'm not 100% the stereotype of a woman, so I suppose I should become a man.' I have been critical of medical transition, particularly for minors, arguing that puberty is a necessary biological process and blocking it is a very bad idea, and that hormone use for gender purposes has not been studied and carries unknown long-term side effects. I have also argued that most surgical transitions leave recipients sterile, and that no one should throw away their ability to have children on a whim. On mental health, I have been open about my own struggles. I have social anxiety disorder (social phobia), which I have said I used to suffer from severely and which a simple prescription from my doctor really cut down to size. I have also battled general anxiety and depression, and I have described having struggled with gloomy ideas about myself in general — feelings that I will never be happy, that I am so different from everyone else, and self-hate. I have said I still fight depression and probably always will, and that it warps your thoughts. I have found some things helpful: volunteer work at a charity, light exercise, making a list of things I am thankful for, and cutting back on unhealthy habits such as alcohol and overeating. I have also described a technique of setting aside about 15 minutes each day to deliberately focus on unwanted thoughts until the mind tires of them. I have mentioned losing over a hundred pounds a few years ago simply by counting calories, without exercise or medical intervention. I have been critical of what I see as the excesses of the trans movement, including what I view as activists running roughshod over rules, the medical establishment rushing decisions that in other areas of medicine would be approached cautiously, and the financial incentives of a lifetime of hormones and surgeries compared to a few years of therapy. I have questioned studies claiming very low rates of transition regret, arguing that self-selected samples and small numbers make such claims unreliable, and I have said it is fundamentally inaccurate to call transition regret a myth. I have also expressed skepticism about claims of high suicide rates among dysphoric people, suggesting the risk may come from co-occurring conditions such as depression rather than dysphoria itself, and that transition would do little to reduce it. I have been supportive of adults making their own choices about transition, while opposing medical transition for children, whom I believe are neither mentally capable nor physically appropriate for such treatments. I have repeatedly encouraged people considering transition to seek therapy first, to address depression, anxiety, trauma, or other issues before making life-altering decisions, and to try less drastic measures first. I have also cautioned against quitting any medication cold turkey, including hormones. I have been critical of gender ideology more broadly, arguing that the concept of gender has little worth since 99.9% of people say their gender matches their sex, and that there are no 'male minds' or 'female minds.' I have been skeptical of transgender activism's claims about historical oppression, and I have been critical of what I see as unfairness in allowing people born male to compete with women and girls in sports. I have described myself as having been a Democrat or someone who used to hold more liberal views on these issues, but said the more I learned, the more troubling I found the movement. I have also expressed views minimizing the current significance of misogyny, and I have been skeptical of claims about male privilege, though I have noted that MGTOW and anti-feminist people are not necessarily conservative. I have been a moderator of at least one subreddit — one where people would post pictures of themselves and ask for critique of their hair, clothes, etc. — which I have said was my introduction to body dysmorphia, having been surprised how often a good-looking person thought they were ugly. I have recommended r/raisedbynarcissists to numerous people, and I have mentioned 4thwavenow as a resource. I have also shared a YouTube channel of a new detransitioner named Ryan. I have been generally encouraging and warm in my interactions, frequently wishing people good luck, telling them they are brave or courageous for sharing their stories, and reassuring them that there is no failure in deciding you don't like a decision you've made and turning back from it. I have been critical of people who drop friends over ideology, saying they weren't really friends. I have also been supportive of lesbians and gay men, saying some of my favorite people are gay men and that there's nothing to feel bad about. I have identified myself as a heterosexual man at various points in these discussions. I have not described undergoing any transition-related medical procedures myself, and I have not described detransitioning, since I have said I never transitioned. My participation has been as a supportive community member offering perspective from outside the trans experience.