부모가 호르몬을 거부했다 — 이제는 그들에게 고마워한다
여성 · 단념626
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 여성으로 태어나 어린 시절부터 트랜스 남성으로 자신을 규정했고, 어머니가 그/그의 대명사를 쓰려 한 가운데 사회적으로 전환했지만 부모님이 거부해 호르몬이나 수술은 받지 않았습니다. 18세에 데지스트했는데, 주로 현재 파트너가 저를 여성으로 보고 존중했기 때문이며, 그것이 제가 여성인 것을 자랑스럽게 만들었습니다. 지금은 데지스트/전환을 되돌린 여성이며 이름은 니키, 저를 보호한 부모님께 공을 돌리고 이제 온라인에서 아이들에게 전환을 서두르지 말라고 적극 경고합니다. 의료적 전환을 하지 않아 수술 후회는 없지만, 얼마나 가까이 갔는지와 트랜스라고 믿으며 잃은 세월을 깊이 후회합니다. 미성년자 전환, 트랜스 라벨을 주장하는 논바이너리 사람들, 제가 분파적이라고 보는 온라인 트랜스 커뮤니티에 비판적입니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female, and even as a kid I was socially trans — I told my friends my parents were transphobic because they didn't agree I should transition, even though my mother at least tried to use he/him pronouns for me after calling me 'she' for 16 years. I never got hormones or surgeries; my parents refused to let me, and I now believe they were protecting me the way a parent should. I came out as trans and fully believed I was a transman. When I was young I took a quiz that told me I was transgender and I accepted it, partly as an escape from how much I hated myself — I felt I wasn't worth living, was taking up space, wasn't a beautiful girl, and would die alone, and I thought being something else would make me worth the air I breathe. I was extremely mentally ill and depressed, sad and angry all the time, and I look back at old fights with previous friends and see how angry at the world I was. I'm an artist, and I think that link mattered: artists are often introverts and chronically online, perfectionists who feel bad about themselves and their creations, and I fell into the camp of trying to become something I liked because I didn't like myself. Drawing myself as the opposite gender felt euphoric, a temporary relief. I dated multiple people, primarily other FtM trans people, while I identified as FtM.
The change came gradually. First I wanted to grow my hair out, justifying it with 'I might as well look like the most attractive woman I can be until I can officially transition,' though I always ended up cutting it again. Then I wanted to dress more feminine, wear dresses and skirts, justifying it as 'obviously I'm just a femboy, I'm still a man I just like some feminine things.' Meeting and then dating my current partner at 18 was the nail in the coffin. He hadn't been told I was trans — he saw me as a woman — and the way he respected me and found me beautiful as I was made me feel proud to be a woman and showed me why I had thought I was trans in the first place. I desisted when I turned 18, at which point I realized I was not trans. I was far more scared to come out as desisting than I had been coming out as trans, because I feared being told I had faked it to be trendy when I truly believed I was trans — and the trans community made sure that fear was justified, telling me I was being manipulated into thinking I wasn't trans.
It wasn't until this year, at 20, that I realized how terrible a decision I could have made if my parents hadn't stopped me. I see so many people my age detransitioning and think 'Oh my God. That could have been me.' If I could give advice to my younger self I wouldn't — instead I'd want to tell my parents at the time to take me to therapy and work on learning to love myself to prevent me from ever thinking I was trans. I did not go back to my birth name, Carlee, which I hate because it sounds ugly and always got the response 'Oh! Like iCarly!' When I believed I was trans I chose the name Leon, which I still like without animosity, though it's weird to hear. I tried Leona after desisting but it didn't stick, so I go by Nikki, a nickname for my middle name, and I'm content with it.
I have no ongoing medical needs since I never medically transitioned. Mentally, I was extremely ill and depressed while identifying as trans and even more depressed after; I was sad and angry constantly. I don't describe specific trauma beyond saying I held trauma and suffered for years because I was afraid of the consequences of telling someone, and I believe non-binary identification can come from trauma or confusion. My family supported me — they refused transition as a child and I credit them with protecting me. My current partner, whom I began dating at 18, was central to my desisting; I also had a girlfriend at one point whom I advised to leave a partner who wouldn't support her detransition journey. Sexually and romantically, while identifying as FtM I dated primarily FtM people but grew sick of it — I wanted to date someone who was actually a man, someone with a penis, because I'm not a lesbian and wasn't attracted to them romantically or sexually since they still had women's bodies.
I don't describe intense regret over medical changes since I had none, but I deeply regret how close I came and the lost years of believing I was trans; that realization has deepened over the past year rather than faded. I now think transition for children is something I'm very against — I draw the line at kids getting any hormones or surgeries, though socially being trans as a teenager is 'a bit irksome' but not permanent, and I believe adults' bodies are their own decision. I regularly try to warn kids online about how serious transition is, though they often blow me off as an uneducated bigot, which is heart-wrenching. I think the trans community is cult-like (Buck Angel explains it well), I'm skeptical of most people who claim to be trans unless they meet strict criteria (diagnosed dysphoria, surgery, therapy with a non-gender-affirming therapist, a known reason for being trans), I respect standard pronouns but refuse neopronouns, I believe non-binary should have a separate label and not be called trans, and I feel deeply disrespected when people try to 'educate' me on trans issues despite my first-hand experience — more offended than I ever was by misgendering or deadnaming.