모든 이야기

트랜스 남성으로 8년, 그리고 호르몬은 끝내 오지 않았다

여성 · 단념사회적 전환 14 → 데시스턴스 22135
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 13세에 레즈비언으로 정체화하고 얼마 뒤 아젠더로, 그다음 14세부터 22세까지 트랜스 남성으로 정체화하며 그 정체성으로 약 8년을 살아온 디트랜지션한 여성입니다. 여러 번 시도했지만 저는 주로 보험 장벽, 2019년 Planned Parenthood에서의 불운, 심한 사회적 불안 때문에 호르몬을 한 번도 구하지 못했습니다. 아동기 트라우마, 성적 학대, 진단되지 않은 자폐성, 소녀로서의 취약함에서 벗어나고 싶은 욕구가 제 전환을 이끌었고, 제 자살 사고는 전환을 중단하기 직전 몇 주에 정점에 달했습니다. 중단한 이후 저는 하나님을 찾았고 제 여성성과 화해했으며, 지금은 논바이너리 꼬리표와 '시스'라는 용어, 그리고 의학적 전환, 특히 아동에 대한 전환에 비판적인 견해를 가지고 있습니다. 저는 Reddit에서 전환을 고민하거나 전환에서 벗어나려는 다른 이들을 적극 격려합니다.

전체 이야기

I first identified as a lesbian at 13, a little before becoming agender. At 14 I moved to identifying as a trans man, and I held onto that identity until I was 22. In total I identified and lived as a trans man for about 8 years, maybe 8 to 9 years in that mindset. The more I tried to push myself to be a good man, the more apparent it was that I was fighting my own nature. I was pushing myself beyond my limits to be a comparable man, and it was too much for me. I was trying to be something I wasn't built to be. Being trans wasn't making me happier; it just put me in a box that limited my growth as a person. When I socially transitioned and presented as a man, I did feel safer and stronger, but that was just in my head really. Trying to be a man was like this alter ego — a new me who is stronger, safer, more confident, stoic, and so on. But I was also a shell of a human because I was more focused on playing a role as opposed to addressing the issues that made me feel weak, vulnerable, and insecure as a woman. I was denying myself, but not for something great, but for an alter ego that made life harder for me. Looking back, I think trauma and undiagnosed or ignored autism are the main culprits for me. Instead of addressing trauma that happened in my childhood, I let it manifest into trying to become a man to escape. For myself and a lot of my trans friends, most of us experience trauma, most notably sexual assault. Maybe we subconsciously felt if we became men, we would be safe from them. On the neurodivergent side, typical gender norms and expectations feel arbitrary, and we may fall into trans friend groups and start mirroring them until we internalize their struggle. I also think taking on a new identity feels like a reset button where we get to craft a new version of ourselves, and that's alluring. A lot of us were punished or had bad things happen to us simply for existing as girls and women, so we escape that by transing ourselves. I feel like a lot of us girls were pushed to grow up fast and got to watch our male counterparts get away with childish behavior because 'boys will be boys.' I also pointed to fatherlessness — a lot of us try to search for or become what we didn't have. I also realized my life would be so much easier if I wasn't trans, and I was just so tired of fighting everything that I kinda threw a white flag. The weeks leading up to me finally desisting, my suicidal ideation got really bad. I felt like dying a trans man would be more noble or realistic than to just desist. I felt like, 'I dug my grave, might as well lay in it.' I'm glad I didn't listen to that. On the medical side, thankfully I was always rejected or ignored by endocrinologists, so I never had hormones. Mostly because my insurance didn't cover it. Sometimes I'd call and reach out to different doctors, but they either weren't taking patients or just never called back. Once I went to a Planned Parenthood in 2019 and made a reservation, checked in, and some glitch happened — the doctor was never notified. I waited 2 hours and was marked as a no-show. I probably could have been more proactive, but I had really bad social anxiety, and I didn't have anyone to support me or go with me. Even so, living in that mindset for 8 to 9 years still does a number on you. I was raised as an atheist and tried to do the Norse Pagan thing while I lived as a trans man. Shortly after I desisted, I ended up finding God, and it was the most affirming thing that it was the right thing for me. I looked back at all the odd coincidences that prevented me from transitioning or self-deleting, and I came to the conclusion that He was protecting me. It took someone else asking if all this work and effort was making me feel happy and complete, and it didn't. I had to shift my thinking from what should and shouldn't be to what is and isn't, and changing that mindset has helped me a lot. Now I don't agree with the term cis; I think it's redundant and unnecessary. I don't think nonbinary is a gender — I just think it's a philosophy that inadvertently reinforces gender stereotypes. I think these new terms and labels are damaging, especially to children that parents are letting the internet raise. The more we muddy up the language, the harder it is for people to articulate these complex feelings and emotions. I believe a woman who looks like a man but enjoys feminine things is a totally valid way to be a woman. You're more than your gender — you are an amalgamation of your character, beliefs, actions, and interests. Trying to figure out a new label or box to fit in will stunt your character growth. I've spent time on Reddit encouraging others — telling a 16-year-old who desisted that they don't owe their trans-identifying friends anything, warning someone that these treatments are harmful to the body and that regret tends to kick in about 5 to 9 years in, and criticizing parents who let a young child or doctors using the 'dead daughter or trans son' tactic drive gender decisions. I also believe trying to gender emotions leads to more distress and confusion.