모든 이야기

그를 되돌린 것은 호르몬이 아니라 상담과 신체 이미지 작업이었다

남성 · 단념296
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 사회적 전환은 했지만 호르몬이나 수술은 시작한 적 없는, 디트랜지션한 남성입니다. 전문 상담을 통해 신체 이미지, 체중, 정신 건강 문제를 다루었고, 그것들이 나아지면서 성별 규범에 맞지 않는 남성(gender-nonconforming)으로 사는 것이 편안해져 전환을 중단했습니다. 제 뼈와 DNA는 언제나 남성일 것이라는 깨달음, 그리고 트랜스 친구 두 명의 결말이 제 결정을 굳혔습니다. 지금 저는 전환에 대해 비판적으로 말하고, 트랜스 공간을 사이비 종교에 비유하며, 다른 사람들에게 의학적 전환을 고려하기 전에 근본적인 불편함을 다루라고 조언합니다. 자살 생각, 자해, 시도에 대해서는 서술하지 않았습니다.

전체 이야기

I was born male and grew up in what I describe as an oppressive, homophobic household — later I would also describe it as a cult I was "born and raised in." For as long as I can remember I have had body image issues, and I had a few friends who were trans whose stories sounded very similar to what I was feeling, both in the past and in the moment. They seemed happy with their new lot in life, and it seemed to resolve their issues, which made transition look like a plausible solution for me too. One of the things that made me think I wanted to fully transition was how women — including trans "women" — and femboys were treated in porn and other sexually explicit or suggestive material. The idea of being lusted over and ogled at, or "admired," was what was exciting to me. In a later comment I summed up the core of it: after a lot of self-examination and professional counseling, what I wanted to transition "ended up boiling down to a misplaced desire to be found attractive (read lusted after and ogled at) and non-gender related body image issues." I also found trans-dominated spaces to be "nothing but a massive echo chamber and a hive mind," with only occasional dissenting voices. I went through a period I referred to as the "Male-Enby-Trans Girl pipeline," including social transition, but I deliberately decided to work on my underlying mental health and body image issues before starting medical transition. My reasoning was that if I dealt with those issues first, I would either fix what was making me think I was trans, or I would have dealt with my mental demons and could then use transition as a genuine fresh start — and either way it bought me extra time to consider whether I really wanted HRT and the irreversible parts of transitioning. That strategy worked. "The more weight I lost and the more I delt with my other mental health issues, the less and less I wanted to medically transition and I got more and more comfortable in my own skin." I never started hormones or surgery. What ultimately cemented my choice to stop socially transitioning and not proceed with medical transition was the realization that no matter how many surgeries or procedures I went through, my bones and DNA would still show I was male — "When I'm dead and gone, even my bones would still show that I was male." Two of my biggest trans friends, whom I considered my biggest influences, served as a kind of post-mortem confirmation: one had a horrible mental breakdown to the point they couldn't leave their house without a massive anxiety attack, and the other ended up detransitioning. I also figured out that clothes have no gender. I can still dress how I want, shave all my body hair (I have always hated body hair and always will), and still be male. Getting comfortable as a gender-nonconforming man — with a mostly androgynous and femboy wardrobe, occasional crossdress-cosplay, and more feminine hobbies — actually made me more comfortable with my masculine aspects. There have been several times I've done my makeup and gone out with my fraternity brothers to a cigar lounge for guys' night. I have not given a precise calendar date for when I first felt dysphoria or body discomfort — only that it has been present "for as long as I can remember." I have not stated my exact age at any point. I did not start HRT or have any surgeries, so there are no medical complications or fertility concerns to report. I have not described any diagnoses beyond referring generally to "other mental health issues" and body image issues that I worked on with professional counseling. On sexuality and attraction, I have not explicitly labeled my orientation; what I have described is a desire to be lusted after and ogled at as the erotic core of my transition wish. I have not described a partner, dating life, or children of my own, though I once encouraged a woman in the community by telling her that wanting to be a good mother "speaks VOLUMES." I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts at any point. My regret is not about physical changes, since I never medically transitioned; it is more about the time and identity confusion. I do not express intense or escalating regret — my tone in these comments is upbeat, resolved, and even humorous. I am quite vocal about my views on transition for others. I advise people questioning transition to "find comfort in being a GNC man" and to find the source of their discomfort first, because "it is going to be infinitely easier to try and find the source of your discomfort now... Then to go ahead and transition and have regrets and second thoughts down the line that you can't undo." I compare trans spaces to cults — "shun the non believer! Shun the apostate!" — and argue that detrans people are treated as apostates who must be silenced. I have made the argument publicly that "I've never run into a trans person that wasn't autistic or had some other sort of mental illness. Usually with dubious self diagnosis." I also counter trans claims with the line, "You feel like you should be a woman? OK. Then what is A woman? What defines femininity?" I have not described formal activism, organizations, or advocacy roles beyond posting these comments.