모든 이야기

남성으로서의 4년, 호르몬 없이, 그리고 그것에 만족

여성 · 단념620
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 데지스트한 게이 여성으로, 사회적으로 전환해 4년간 남성으로 살았지만 호르몬이나 수술은 하지 않았습니다. 제가 트랜스가 아니라는 것을 깨달았기 때문에 전환을 되돌렸습니다—저는 내면화된 여성혐오, 자기혐오, 아동기 성폭력, 이른 포르노 노출, 그리고 여성이라는 이유로 저를 얕본 어머니와 씨름하던 남성적인 여성이었습니다. 트랜스 정체성을 버리고 남성적인 여성으로 사는 것이 기쁩니다. 다만 아직도 가슴 위화감, 공공장소에서 남성으로 읽히는 것, PTSD, 우울, 치료에서의 내면화된 여성혐오와 씨름하고 있습니다. 약 1년간 자살 충동이 있었고 한 번 시도했지만 여전히 노력하고 있으며 의료적 전환을 하지 않은 것이 감사합니다. 진짜 트랜스 사람은 존재한다고 믿지만 전환은 과도하게 사용되며, 자기혐오의 공백을 채우기 위해 전환하지 말라고 다른 이들에게 경고합니다.

전체 이야기

I was a tomboy kid — I hated dresses, dolls and pink things, and I always hung out with boys, playing football and loving dinosaurs, dragons and cars. When puberty started I began hating myself even more; the boys stopped hanging out with me and bullied me for being a tomboy, and I realized I was never going to be allowed into their group. Watching my body change in a way I hated, and having female parts, was very difficult. On top of that I liked girls only, and I hated when boys wanted to be with me and sexualised me — I felt humiliated and like a weak little girly girl. As a kid I also hated my parents dressing me in girls' clothes; when I reached 16 I started wearing my father's t-shirts and loved it, but I noticed people around me disrespecting me because I no longer looked attractive, and I felt betrayed, realizing people had only liked me for my appearance. I started identifying as trans online, where I was exploring my identity. I changed my name to a male one and found a group of people who accepted me and saw me as male — something I really wanted. We played online games together, I did masculine things and flirted with girls. But it was only good at the start. I became very narcissistic and egoistical, focused on my appearance and how masculine and attractive I looked, and I became very toxic-masculine because I felt that was what men were. I was happy on the outside but inside I became more and more miserable; I was spending hours online, it became my second life and eventually my first because I stopped doing things in real life. I became severely depressed when I felt I wasn't really a man, and during that time it was impossible to admit — I preferred to be miserable than be a girl again. I identified as a man for 4 years and came out to people during the last two of them. Eventually I reached a point of feeling dysphoric about my male identity itself, because I wanted to stop being a man but couldn't bring myself to change back to female. The months after that realization were a disaster: deep self-hate, depression, anxiety so severe I felt pain in my body, always feeling disgusted and nauseous, tired, with fevers from bad mental and physical care. I stopped taking care of myself completely. When I finally wanted to change my situation it took months of work to start dismantling the trans ideology I had built over years. During those months I started feeling very suicidal; no one in my real life knew why I was so low — I told no one, neither family nor friends. I was living in a hell I had created online and in my mind. I later described myself as having been suicidal for one year, having attempted and failed, after which I realized my mom would be very sad and would want me alive despite everything. It's now been over a year since I stopped identifying as male, and I'm happy with that. I don't follow gender stereotypes anymore; I just do and believe my own things. I don't regret it that much because the experience led me to accept my true gender. I don't blame anyone, I don't blame the trans community, and I know actual trans people exist. I describe myself as desisted — I never medically transitioned, only socially — and I'm a masculine female, a gay woman. I wish I had known back then that I could live as a gay woman and be happy; sometimes I think I lost my teenage years for nothing, even though I know that's an unhealthy mindset. I still struggle. I still feel dysphoria, though focusing on work and hobbies helps. People often mistake me for a guy, which stresses me when I'm outside my home, and I avoid public bathrooms because of the stares from women — I just want to be a masculine woman. I still hate my breasts and have chest dysphoria I can't seem to resolve despite trying everything. My main reasons for transitioning were that I liked girls and didn't want to be a girl liking another girl, jealousy of men, and wanting women to see me as one of them. I now understand I was suffering from internalised misogyny and was trying to be a man to mask that pain, plus self-hatred, sexual trauma, and a dissociative disorder. During and especially at the end of my FTM period I was in a full depersonalisation/derealisation state, and that unbearable pain was the major reason I wanted to detransition; wearing male clothes made me dissociate in the long run because I wasn't connecting with the male gender anymore. I've come to see that my mother contributed to all of this — she holds misogynistic ideologies, always wanted a son because she believed sons love their mothers more, and compares me negatively with male family members, once calling me a loser for having anxiety when male relatives wouldn't. I've also disclosed that I experienced sexual assault as a kid and exposure to pornography from a very young age, leaving me with shame, anger, and feelings of being disgusted and dirty. I'm in therapy and working on internalised misogyny, which I didn't know I had until someone pointed it out; I still deal with psychological PTSD, hatred, blocked emotions, disappointment and hopelessness, and I worry it's not getting easier, though I keep trying. I developed mental illness and major depression from trying to be a man for so many years. I'm glad I never took testosterone. I've posted about a breakdown on a suicide-related forum where people insisted I was trans FTM even though I said I was a female who just hates her body. I now believe trans individuals exist but that it's rarer than the number of people identifying these days, and I advise others not to use transition to fill a void of self-hatred.