테스토스테론 5년, 27세에 치료 시작
여성 · 탈전환전환 17 → 디트랜지션 22268
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 2018년 열일곱 살에 아무런 상담 없이 테스토스테론을 시작했고 2023년 1월 스물두 살에 호르몬 요법을 급작스럽게 중단했습니다. 트랜지션을 한 것은 주로 사회가 여성을 바라보는 방식, 저의 동성애, 가족의 섭식장애 문제, 온라인 트랜스 유튜버의 영향 때문이었고, 지금은 제 이전 트랜스포비아적 견해를 바꾸는 데 도움을 준 MTF 파트너가 있습니다. 디트랜지션은 처음에는 오르내렸고, 제 여성성을 받아들이는 것이 가장 큰 난관이었지만 지금은 여성인 것이 행복합니다. 남은 주요 신체적 문제는 잘못 읽히게 만드는 남자처럼 들리는 목소리와 2023년 11월부터 시작된 늦고 가벼운 생리입니다. 마침내 트라우마와 디트랜지션을 위한 상담을 시작하고 있습니다. 의학적 트랜지션 전에 상담을 의무화하는 것에 찬성하며 더 나은 동맹이 되고 싶지만, 여전히 어떤 사람들은 트랜지션으로 진정한 도움을 받는다고 믿습니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and detransitioned female. I transitioned in 2018 at age 17 — I started testosterone the very same day as my first doctor's appointment, with no therapy required. All they asked were a few questions like 'Are you a boy' and 'Do you think you're a boy,' and then it took a few signatures and I walked out of the doctor's office on testosterone. Before that I had been seeing a counselor, not for transition but for other mental health issues, and she told me she wanted me to learn to love my trans self and to love my female self — I was so convinced I was right that I thought she was being transphobic, so I stopped seeing her. That is one of my biggest regrets.
I had watched YouTubers and done Google searches on the effects of hormone replacement therapy before starting, so I had a basic idea of what to expect. I was told about the side effects and health risks of testosterone at my appointment. I transitioned around the time Kalvin Garrah was popular, and in that online space if you didn't take cross-sex hormones or look a certain way you were called a 'transtender,' so there was definitely pressure to transition. I also believe I was influenced by trans YouTubers into believing I was transgender.
The real reasons I transitioned were tied up with my views on femininity and how society expects women to be. Growing up I absorbed a male view from movies where men were millionaires, heroes, and someone big and important, while women were degraded as the gold digger, the damsel in distress, the mean girl, or the woman whose life changes only because a man enters it. I loved women but hated the idea of being one. I was drawn to women-coded hobbies, clothing and music. I also had dysphoria connected to society's views on women, my homosexuality, and issues with eating disorders — mine and my mother's. Physically I have a big nose, a butt chin, and broader shoulders than most women, so I don't fit into American beauty standards for women. I asked myself whether I was really uncomfortable with myself or just uncomfortable with how the world perceives me. I also wanted validation from others and to be part of a community and group — that desire to belong was one of the reasons I transitioned. I don't think I ever really had gender euphoria; I was 'happy' with the results because that's what a medically transitioning trans person was supposed to look like.
I detransitioned starting January 2023, at age 22, and I stopped HRT cold turkey that month. I didn't go back to the doctors who had prescribed me hormones because I felt ashamed that I was wrong about my own identity and felt as though I had betrayed a community. I was very on and off with detransitioning at first — I still had those 'what if' questions. At one point I went super feminine, which I wasn't comfortable with, and that discomfort scared me back toward transitioning for a while. But not being comfortable in super feminine clothing, makeup and wigs doesn't make me any less of a woman.
When I first started detransitioning I fell right into the hands of right-wing politics on trans ideology, watching Blaire White, Arielle Scarcella, Buck Angel and many more. It was almost like I was obsessed, a fixation on trans people because a system failed me. I now try to look at both left and right sides — I've recently started watching Samantha Lux and I love her. I feel a little guilty about that period of my life, especially because I now have a partner who is MTF (21 years old), and she has enlightened me and changed my transphobia. I believe trans YouTubers influenced me into thinking I was transgender, but at the end of the day trans people aren't the ones who failed me — it was my doctors and my parents (even though I love them) who signed me off on hormones at that age without therapy.
On stopping HRT, I don't think anything bad happened to me, though stopping cold turkey is definitely unknown territory in terms of side effects. The one medical problem that has come up recently is very late and light periods starting in November 2023 — I never had this problem before my transition, but I'm working through it. Doctors have been very nice to me recently, and I'm finally going to get therapy to talk about trauma and detransition, which I'm excited about.
Emotionally, accepting my femininity was my hugest hurdle in detransitioning. I thought you had to be a certain way, live a certain life, and that women in general were weak. Now I see how strong modern women and mothers are, and I'm just really happy to be female. I still struggle with insecurity — I mostly took photos with makeup because of it, and I want to grow my hair long. My voice is a persistent problem: it's maleish, and sometimes I joke by deepening it very low and saying things like 'What's up baby girl' around people I trust, but other times it gives me dysphoria or makes me uncomfortable that people might think I'm a trans woman instead of a regular cis woman. It's mainly my voice that gets me misgendered.
That has led to some painful public experiences. While working at McDonald's, a homeless trans woman came up to me with no money and, since we were 'the same,' asked me to help her out; I explained I wasn't trans and couldn't get her anything without getting in trouble at my job. She didn't make a scene but it lowered my self-esteem for the rest of the day. More recently, while out shopping with my girlfriend, someone ran up to me out of a store and said 'hello, I've never met another in public.' I explained I was detrans. They were very socially awkward and shy, and I don't think they meant any harm, but I had such bad anxiety afterward that I had to leave because I felt like everyone was seeing me as a man.
On dating, I'm in a monogamous relationship now and I'm bisexual, which I think makes things easier than for a straight detransitioned woman or man. When I was on dating apps I put in my bio that I was detrans and that my voice was a little off — not the best advice, I realize, since I could have matched with someone dangerous. I believe people are not required to date someone if they don't like what's in their pants. I also think before any medical transition there should be therapy first; my partner had to go through therapy to receive HRT, whereas I had none at 17.
I don't think all gender dysphoria is simply autism or another mental illness — there are trans individuals whose only issue is gender dysphoria, and people who are happy with their transition 10+ years on. I do agree that hormones carry real risks: higher risk of blood clots, strokes, other health complications and surgery complications, which is very scary. I also think it's easier for FTM people to pass since T lowers the voice, binding can hide the chest, and facial hair grows, whereas estrogen doesn't change the voice. I respect trans people as beings and live my life. I don't believe everything from either the right or the left, but I want to be a better ally. I'm still looking for more self-love, but I love the fact that I am a woman, and finding self-love and acceptance of having made a mistake isn't easy — but I am happy.