CBT는 신체에 주목하는 것이 통증을 키우고 있음을 가르쳤죠 주었다
여성 · 단념293
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 트랜지션을 멈춘 디트랜지션 여성으로, 어떤 의학적 개입도 받은 적이 없고 지금은 양성애자 젠더 논컨포밍 여성으로 정체화합니다. 십 대부터 제 젠더에 의문을 품었는데, 일부는 자라면서 남성들이 저를 대하는 방식이 싫었기 때문이고, 또 일부는 몸과 남성성/여성성 기준에 저를 묶어 두는 강렬한 반추가 동반된 불안 때문이었습니다. 불안에 대한 인지행동치료는 신체적 불편에 집중하면 그것이 커진다는 것을 보게 해 주었고, 트랜지션 대신 철저한 자기수용을 실천했습니다. 지금은 디트랜지션한 사람들의 가시성, '시스' 같은 낙인을 거부할 권리, 청소년이 어떤 수술보다도 먼저 기다려야 한다는 점을 지지합니다. 트랜스인 것이 의학적 문제가 아니라는 주장과 젠더를 의심하는 아이들 주변에서 쓰이는 자살 '전염' 논변에도 비판적입니다.
전체 이야기
I am a female who questioned her gender for years and eventually desisted without ever having any medical intervention. I first started hating what was happening to my body as I got older, around the time I was maturing, and I didn't fit in with the other girls; for a while I concluded that meant I was a boy and needed to change my body. What I eventually realized was that I mostly hated how men treated me as I was maturing, and that what I really am is gender non-conforming — though I say I don't even really know what that means anymore.
I have anxiety with intense rumination, and I saw a therapist for anxiety disorders where I did cognitive behavioral therapy to retrain how I think and how I talk to myself. My therapist explained that what we focus on gets magnified — if I fixated on a worry, that worry would grow. She never applied that to gender, but I started to think that much of my discomfort with my body came from obsessing over it and comparing it to people around me and to standards of what was masculine and feminine. Part of coming to terms with my body also had to do with generally loathing medical stuff and not wanting to go there, accepting that I will always look how I look, so focusing on it is fruitless. I had to practice radical self-acceptance and love, which is really hard. I do not have OCD, but I do have anxiety with intense rumination.
In college I thought I could fix a lot of my fears by not being feminine or straight — that as an androgynous pansexual I could escape the exhausting balance women are expected to strike between being attractive to men but not too feminine. No one could expect anything from me if I labeled myself that way. Now I understand I am a woman who sometimes wants to look feminine and sometimes does not; I sometimes have long hair and sometimes short, I wear dresses sometimes and hiking boots and overalls other times, makeup sometimes and not other times. I identify as a bi woman. At one time I didn't want to be called a woman because I didn't belong with them, but now I know I'm just a different kind of woman who fits in better with other types of people. I don't need anything about me to be stable or labeled.
I have a twin brother, and seeing that he wasn't having to deal with what I was dealing with made my struggles with femininity and body image worse. I went through the exhausting process of trying to strike a balance of being attractive to men but not too feminine so people would know I was strong and independent but also feminine and sexy.
Things I know about my body now: I prefer being a small-chested woman, and when I gain weight the reason I want to lose it is that my breasts get too big. I am very risk-averse and have high anxiety about medical procedures, so I cannot see myself having any surgery despite not liking when my breasts get bigger than a tiny A (like with weight gain) and needing to diet to keep them smaller. It isn't having breasts that bothers me — it's hating them when they become more apparent or full. That fact is one of the ways I figured out I'm not really trans. I also don't cringe at being called a woman or she/her, even if I bristle at the stereotypes. I prefer to be androgynous, and I used to love confusing people about my gender, which also made me think I was trans — but I think I just liked messing with the binary because I'm that kind of person. I also dream of being able to just take my shirt off and it pains me that society won't let me.
I have thought a lot about whether being trans is medical or purely identity. I stand with the trans community and don't want to take anyone's rights away, but I can't fathom how something that requires invasive surgery and lifelong hormone therapy isn't medical. I compared it to ADHD, a neurological difference treated with drugs, and questioned whether anything originating in the brain is by definition not medical. I also questioned the claim that cis people don't think about their gender — as I opened up to people, I found many cis people feel weird about how they are gendered, how they perform gender, and how their bodies aren't 'ideal' for their gender; I believe it's actually rare not to think about it.
I have also thought about how the queer community could spend more time advocating for the erasure of gender roles and stereotypes rather than upholding them, and I noted that tying being trans more to discomfort with body parts has a clearer meaning than tying it to gender expression. I hope for a world where nobody cares about your clothes, haircut, or jawline. I'm skeptical of the claim that suicidal contagion doesn't apply to kids with gender discomfort — I think adults screaming in congressional testimony that kids will kill themselves inevitably makes more kids think they'll want to kill themselves and demand medicine they otherwise wouldn't.
After desisting, I didn't want to be called trans or cis — I just wanted to exist without thinking about labels and categories. I argued that people should be able to decline the label 'cisgender' without being accused of transphobia, since a trans person can choose to be identified as trans, or just as a man or a woman, whereas a non-trans person must be cis or be labeled transphobic. I also distinguished between an insult and a slur, saying a slur requires more venom and a history of violent use.
I have advised younger people considering transition to wait as long as possible before any surgery, because complications are real and attitudes change a lot from 18 onward — when I was 18 I had many feelings about my body and the world that I have totally abandoned now, and I hated hearing that from others at the time, but they turned out to be right. I told them to do heavy research into consequences like lifelong hormone needs after a hysterectomy, and to consider therapy to figure out why they feel bad about having those parts. I also encouraged someone who was detransitioning, saying it takes bravery to transition and bravery to go back, and that more detrans visibility is a good thing. I have been active in online detrans and gender-questioning communities, partly because I was looking for conversation so I wouldn't feel isolated.