이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 여성으로 태어나 10세까지 홈스쿨링을 하며 정서적으로 방치되었고, 여성스러운 것을 좋아한다는 이유로 두 명의 손위 형제자매(둘 다 나중에 남성으로 트랜지션)에게 괴롭힘을 당했습니다. 12세부터 18세까지(대략 5~7년) 트랜스 남성/논바이너리로 정체화했지만 어떤 의학적 트랜지션에도 접근하지 못했고 18세에 디시스트했습니다. 지금은 디시스트/디트랜지션한 소녀로 다시 여성으로 정체화하지만, 잠재된 불쾌감, 신체 이형 장애, 자폐 의심, 심한 사회적 불안, 우울증과 여전히 씨름하고 있습니다. 내면화된 여성혐오, 컬트 전술과의 비교, 그리고 형제자매의 가슴 수술 회복을 지켜본 것을 제안한 치료자가 제 디시스트에 결정적이었습니다. 저는 신체 이미지와 불쾌감에 연결된 자살 사고를 겪었으며, 2025년 1월에는 '30세까지 자살할지도 모른다'고 썼습니다. 지금은 트랜지션과 젠더 이데올로기에 강하게 비판적이며, 디트랜스 공간에서 디시스트한 사람들을 옹호하고, 페미니즘을 통해 젠더 규범에 순응하지 않는 자신감 있는 여성이 되려 노력하고 있지만, 제 성적 지향은 계속 변하며 저를 혼란스럽게 합니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female and grew up in a small conservative-leaning rural town, homeschooled until I was 10 with almost no interaction outside my family. My parents were emotionally neglectful and left me largely to be raised by the computer, while my two older siblings — both of whom later transitioned to male — bullied me constantly for liking anything girly, and even my mom seemed annoyed or mocking when I enjoyed girl toys. I made a lot of gender-neutral characters as a kid and couldn't imagine myself growing up to be a woman, though I now think that was just a very narrow view of what a woman could be.
When I entered public school at 10, I was extremely socially inept from the lack of interaction, and I was bullied constantly. I was a chubby, autistic girl with none of the female socialization other girls had — I wasn't taught about shaving, makeup, or even bras — so I couldn't relate to or make friends with other girls and drifted toward the boys, who seemed to get more respect by default. In 6th grade I met my current best friend, who started identifying as trans female in 7th grade, and around then I started identifying as trans male/nonbinary too, though I was really only out online and to a few friends. I fell hard into gender ideology: I had a Tumblr trans discourse blog at 13 with 1000+ followers, complaining about transmeds and pushing MOGAI, having panic attacks while arguing with much older strangers online.
My oldest sibling, who is autistic and was always the meanest to me, came out as trans male around 2014, and my parents seemed to use this as an excuse for why they were so hard on me for liking girly things. Around age 14, that sibling gave me what I describe as the worst trauma of my life, including forcing me to come out as trans to our parents simply because they believed I was — their reasoning was that I went by 'egg' online and didn't like wearing leggings. My other older sibling came out as trans male when I was about 15, and I was extremely mad and jealous, feeling like they were copying me. Both siblings eventually got on testosterone; the oldest had complications from it that contributed to more trauma I don't want to discuss.
I identified as trans for about 5-6 years (elsewhere I say 7 years identifying), from roughly age 12 to 18. I graduated high school in 2023 still identifying as nonbinary-ish and going by a different name, though I wasn't really out to most people. Around 17 the whole gender thing fell apart for me, all the cracks came loose, and I realized what I had been doing. I decided to desist at 18, and now at almost 19 I'm identifying as a girl again, getting over my misogyny. I never accessed any medical transition — no hormones, no surgery, no birth control — so my detransition was purely social/identity-based. I never got my name legally changed, but I still use 'Cal' with friends and as an internet name because I like it and it feels natural.
A big part of what moved me toward desisting was my first therapist: when I told her I thought I was trans, she suggested I might just have internalized misogyny and should reconsider. At the time I considered her transphobic, but she was right. I also read an article comparing trans community tactics to cult tactics (from ourduty.group), which was extremely eye-opening during my 'peaking' and desisting process. Another wake-up call was seeing a picture of a 13-year-old asleep on anesthesia being wheeled back for a mastectomy and realizing that was what I had desperately craved for years — a blunt picture of what I now see as medical abuse. In early 2024 I made a vent art piece about 'accidentally ruining it all by trying to escape to an impossible fantasy,' with arrows representing self-hatred pointing at everything I thought was bad and could be fixed.
In October 2024 I accompanied my older sibling to get a double mastectomy. Sitting in the waiting room I was crying, flip-flopping between 'I don't want them to regret it' and 'I want it so bad,' and I said I wanted to shoot myself in the head. After seeing the reality of the recovery — drains, crying, inability to move arms for 30+ minutes — I concluded I don't want top surgery, though I said I might consider a breast reduction in my 20s. My sibling later made a comment to me like 'you could be one of those people getting top surgery but looks exactly like a girl,' and told people 'everyone knew you weren't trans,' which felt like being used as a validation prop for an ideology I don't believe in.
I still struggle with latent dysphoria. In September 2024 I wrote about getting a 'dark, sick, aching, angry jealousy' when I see photos of FTMs — wanting a deep voice so I'd be respected, a jawline so I'd look less fat, a flat chest so I wouldn't have to deal with bras. In October 2024 I posted that it's hard to accept: 'I want to be a guy so bad,' I don't want to be a wife, sister, aunt, woman, ma'am, or lady — only 'girl' feels okay. In January 2025 I had a bad day of dysphoria where I was crying wanting to cut off my clitoris and call my therapist to try to get testosterone. In May 2025 I wrote that a comment invalidating desisted people triggered me enough that I thought 'maybe I should get top surgery or smth to be taken more seriously,' though my logical brain knows it won't help.
Mental health: I've been isolated and depressed for a while, I have heavily suspected (undiagnosed) autism, and severe social anxiety. I'm extremely conflict-averse and people-pleasing — at 16 I had a constant headache and vomiting for a week and didn't tell anyone until I got double vision that lasted 3 months. I've dealt with body dysmorphia and binge eating disorder; I've lost weight (from the 200s down to about 160 lbs at 5'5) and worry about loose skin and stretch marks that Medi-Cal won't cover, which has made me suicidal at times. In January 2025 I wrote that no one will ever love me, that I'll become an old fat ugly cat lady and kill myself by 30. In October 2024, in the hospital waiting room, I said I wanted to shoot myself in the head. I've also said I don't really care about my health and just want to become worthy of love on the outside.
Sexuality has been confusing. I was 'hypersexual very early but also not' — obsessed with certain fictional scenarios (always male) but with no attraction to real people. Before desisting I was pretty sure I was only into guys, but after desisting at 18 my sexuality seemed to flip: at 19 I suddenly felt interest in women and sexual attraction to real people for the first time. I've realized I hate the thought of PIV sex and that penetration only felt like something I'd 'have to' do. I'm still unsure of my orientation — I find men visually attractive but am disgusted by the idea of their genitals, and the idea of sex with a woman sounds more interesting but I'm barely visually attracted to them. I'm a virgin with barely any dating experience. I've wondered whether my lack of attraction to femininity is internalized misogyny/homophobia or just that I never learned those girl things and can't relate to women with that socialization.
I live in the same town, house, and room I've lived in my entire life. I'm autistic with severe social anxiety, unsure if I can get a job or go to college, with no friends to help. Both my older siblings are trans, my two best friends from school are nonbinary and/or on estrogen, my new therapist is a lesbian who had a cosmetic mastectomy, and my high school of ~250 kids had 4-5 other trans kids I knew of. I've said the best thing I'm hoping for is to live with my ftm brother when they move out, because I feel too 'brain broken & useless' to support myself alone.
I'm now strongly critical of transition and the trans community. I've written long posts arguing that transition is the wrong treatment for dysphoria, that gender is just stereotypes, that 'no female feels like a woman,' that bottom surgery is 'purely insane,' and that the affirmative model is morally questionable — though I think low-dose hormones and maybe top surgery 'can be okay eventually' for consenting adults who've had real counseling. I've shared articles comparing the trans community to a cult and written extensively about cult-like tactics, language manipulation, and what I see as misogyny in trans spaces. I've advocated for desisted people's voices to be taken seriously within detrans communities and pushed back on both left- and right-wing politicization of detransition. Becoming more feminist has helped me, and I want to be the kind of cool, confident, respected GNC woman that my younger self could look up to — someone who could show girls they don't have to become male to be valued.