r/detrans의 외부인, 무엇이 사람들을 끌어들이는지 묻다
여성 · 단념489
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 전환을 되돌린 여성입니다... 아니—저는 전환을 한 적이 없는 여성입니다. 저는 젠더 비판적인 아내이자 어머니로, 사람들을 전환으로 이끄는 것이 무엇인지 이해하려고 외부 관찰자로서 r/detrans에 글을 썼습니다. 트랜스로 자신을 규정한 적은 없지만, 아동기 우울, 학대적 관계, 양극성 장애가 있는 어머니라는 저만의 이력이 있습니다. 저는 전환을 확언하는 의료·심리 전문가, 데이트에서의 미공개, 가족을 압박하기 위해 사용되는 자살 위협에 강하게 비판적입니다. 저는 되돌릴 수 없는 의료적 해악, 전환 되돌림 데이터의 부족, 청소년과 취약한 사람들에 대한 성역할 메시지의 영향에 대해 우려를 표명했습니다. 저는 전환을 되돌린 사람들을 용감하고 희망을 주는 존재로 칭송했고, 2020년 중반 이후에는 조용한 관찰로 돌아갈 가능성이 높다고 말했습니다.
전체 이야기
I have never transitioned myself — I want to be clear about that up front. I'm a woman, a mom and a wife, and I came to this community as an outside observer trying to understand what leads people toward transition and, in some cases, back out of it. I've said repeatedly that I'm 'not a trans person' and 'not trans myself just trying to figure out what leads many people down this path.'
I've always been a bit of a tomboy in my own life: I love working outdoors, I like sports, I dress comfortably — half the time I'm wearing my husband's T-shirts and basketball shorts. I don't act the way traditional women have been taught to act and speak, and I'm 'not a 1940's house wife.' But none of that has ever made me feel like anything other than a woman. I 'very much embrace being a woman' — my own version of it. That conviction is basically the core of why I post here: I don't believe that enjoying things coded for the opposite sex means you are the opposite sex.
I have had my own struggles, though. I've dealt with depression on and off 'due to my childhood,' and there are days where I think 'why can't I just be normal and not have to deal with this shit.' I've also been in abusive relationships — I dated a lot of men who treated me badly before I found someone who respects me, and I tell people from experience that it's better to be alone than to be treated like shit. My mother was bipolar manic and required long-term medication; when she stopped taking her meds she would 'go crazy again,' and when she was on them she could function and live a normal life. That experience made me a strong believer in combining medication with talk therapy rather than either alone.
I came to this community mostly to listen and occasionally to comment. I told one person they 'deserve to be treated as a human being and with compassion,' and I've said I see 'a bunch of people that are hurting and trying to figure out who they are and where they fit into this world.' I do follow gender-critical spaces, but I've insisted that being kind comes first — 'I believe in being kind to people first.' At the same time, I hold fairly firm views: I think gender dysphoria is real and 'a true mental illness,' but I believe a lot of people transitioning today are actually going through an identity crisis, confused by gender-role messaging from childhood. I've written that 'sex isn't fluid' and that I don't think we should consider gender fluid either — you're male or female, and what you enjoy doing shouldn't require 'a thousand different labels to justify your essence.'
I'm sharply critical of the medical and mental-health professions on this issue. I've said removing the mental-illness classification 'did a disservice' to people struggling with these thoughts, and that doctors 'encouraged them to just transform and expected all their mental problems to disappear.' I've compared it to what would happen if therapists told schizophrenic patients their hallucinations were real — 'Mental health professionals are supposed to help keep people grounded in reality and not fantasy.' I've pointed to the dark experimental histories of both medicine and psychology and argued it 'would make sense that this is an experiment that could go wrong as well,' and I've said I hate that doctors are doing this to people. I've also raised medical risks: I warned someone against a hysterectomy, saying the risk of prolapsing intestines through the vagina goes up after such a procedure and that birth control to stop periods would be a better first step. I brought up my grandmother, who got breast cancer we believe was due to taking hormones during menopause, with no family history of it. I've argued that trans people need regular checkups with gynecologists rather than assuming that seeing an OBGYN confirms someone is female, and I've stated that scientists have found no difference between the male and female brain.
I'm also critical of what I see as coercion in dating and disclosure. I've called non-disclosure of trans status 'sexual deceit' and 'lying and it's fucking shameful,' and I've told someone who wanted a straight female partner that they 'can't just have a straight woman' — that transition motivated by wanting to avoid being a lesbian is 'sexual coercion.' I've suggested that some people transition to escape their sexuality: 'You just want to say I'm a man and it's ok I'm not a lesbian if I'm a man.'
On the question of suicide threats, I've drawn an analogy to abusive relationships: 'Abusers threaten to kill themselves to control the narrative,' and I've argued that trans individuals threatening suicide to parents or families functions to 'scare the parents into allowing their children to take hormones.' I acknowledge it 'might very well be true for some individuals,' but I question it in many cases.
I've been encouraged by detransitioners and desisters, telling them they 'give hope to people out there by telling them it is possible to love their body and be comfortable not following the expected gender norms,' and calling them 'brave' and 'good work.' I've worried about the lack of data on detransition: 'I'm also curious why we haven't seen a lot of data on people going back to their normal state.' I've expressed concern about teens and impressionable people, including those with mental illness or on the autism spectrum, being led into hormones and surgery. After a burst of comments in mid-2020 I said I would 'more than likely go back into lurk mode' unless the community was okay with me commenting positive things from time to time.
I've given ordinary advice too — hair care, therapy suggestions, encouragement to volunteer and stay busy, and the reminder that 'we grow and change and go down so many paths but what's most important is turning into the best possible version of ourselves that we can be.'