T 2년, 그리고 스스로의 조건으로 중단을 선택하다
여성 · 탈전환122
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 디트랜지션한 여성으로 2년간 테스토스테론을 사용하고 2020년에 끊었습니다. 이제 남성으로 정체화하지 않고 본래 이름으로 돌아갔지만 여전히 논바이너리라고 느끼고 they/them 대명사를 사용하며 몸의 변화(낮은 목소리와 얼굴 털)를 받아들입니다. 홈스쿨링으로 성별 규범에 맞지 않던 어린 시절, 대학에서의 성별 중립적 법적 개명, Tumblr 영향을 받은 젠더퀴어 정체성을 거쳐 10대 후반/20대 초반에 트랜지션했습니다. 스스로의 결정으로 호르몬을 완전히 끊었고, 그것에 대한 어머니의 동정은 짜증 나며 제 여성성 실험은 일부러 어머니에게 숨겼습니다. 지금은 "소년 모드"와 "소녀 모드"의 달을 번갈아 보내고 디트랜스 커뮤니티와 계속 연결되어 있으며, 디트랜지션한 여성을 위한 동료 지원 워크숍을 열었거나 계획하고 있고, 다른 이들에게 되돌릴 수 없는 의학적 변화를 피하라고 조언합니다. 자살 사고나 자해 보고는 없습니다.
전체 이야기
I was born female. My early childhood was happy — I have warm memories of my dad lovingly calling me by my birth name, which was unique and obviously female. Around age 13 I wanted to shop for boy clothes, but my parents wouldn't let me, in the name of "protecting me from people who would hurt me for cross dressing." I resented that: I wanted to be my authentic self and face any bullies myself rather than be deprived to shield me from hypothetical ones. I was homeschooled in a very liberal west coast region, so I never actually encountered those bullies.
Around puberty I suddenly thought "it's time to present female now" and tried painting my nails and wearing a skirt, then quickly reversed: "no, I want to wear clothes from the teen boy department." My mom told me trans people exist and I was oddly excited, asking questions she didn't expect like "do they get puberty twice?" My identity was all over the map in my teens and early 20s — "soft butch" lesbian, genderqueer, gay FTM. In my late teens I found the Tumblr art school community and thought I was genderqueer. My teen years under my birth name sucked; I wanted to believe that suffering teenager had died when I changed my name.
In college I legally changed my name from my unique female birth name to something common and gender-neutral (unofficially first, legally about four years later). I asked to go by he/him, said I was FTM, and started testosterone in my early 20s — around 2016-2018. My first endocrinologist offered T but cautioned me: "while binary trans folks may do well on HRT, nonbinary folks may not like it as much. Make sure you're sure about this." I was on prescribed T injections for two years. I developed a deeper voice and facial hair, and came to pass consistently as a man about 99% of the time without any FTM surgery. I never had top or bottom surgery — I have a small chest, so my chest dysphoria was minimal; I used to wear binders but got claustrophobic in them.
What helped me going in was my parents saying "we love and support you equally whether you're trans or cis," which left me an "out" to desist without shame; seeing a balance of positive and negative transition outcomes (happy results, but also botched surgeries, complications, detransition); and actually meeting detransitioners so I knew that was a real path with real people, not just a hypothetical transphobic argument. What didn't help was adults standing in the way of harmless reversible changes like nicknames or cross dressing, or suppressing my ability to do those things "to protect from theoretical bullies."
I stopped T about a year before August 2021 (so around 2020), entirely by my own choice. When I said casually that if I'd been born a few decades earlier I probably wouldn't have attempted transition because stigma would have outweighed my mild curiosity/dysphoria, my mom teared up, put a hand on my shoulder, and gave me a look of absolute pity that sickened me. My mom had read a book (something like "Damaged Bodies") and became convinced I was tricked by The Left into damaging my body with T; she pities me and expects me to detransition. I resent her pity — no one tricked me — and since then I have not let her see me experimenting with my feminine side, because "they do not get to see female me until they accept male me wasn't a mistake."
I experimented with going by my birth name again, wanting to hear what it sounded like from people who care about me and to associate it with good memories, while staying "newname" at work (where I was successfully stealth as a man in a fairly male industry) and with my parents. I've described my life now as alternating "boy mode" months (T-shirts, pants, growing out my beard) and "girl mode" months (shaving my face, dresses, skirts, makeup). My legal name is still the androgynous one, giving me flexibility, though I've been using my birth name unofficially. I go by they/them so no one has to flip-flop pronouns. I found a journal from when I was 15 saying: "some times I will be girl mode, some times I will be boy mode. The only rule is that I shouldn't do anything in boy mode that I will regret when I swing back to girl mode, and vice versa" — I think that was the moment I had it all figured out.
I've been wary of identifying as nonbinary because I don't want to be seen as a "snowflake," and wary of identity-hopping too often. I tend to chameleon into whatever crowd I'm with, waiting to see what pronouns people naturally use rather than imposing them — possibly an autistic survival reflex. The exception is if I feel forced into a narrative: if people try to force me into a "victim of internalized transphobia" narrative I double down on my femaleness; if people try to force me into a "victim of leftist propaganda" narrative I double down on my transmasculinity. Sometimes I like to think of myself as a "bearded lady," owning my difference with a cheeky smile.
I've had a long-term relationship with a partner I described as a nonbinary AMAB male who consistently identifies as they/them; we recently (as of September 2025) amicably separated for reasons unrelated to gender, but they remain important to me. I'm primarily attracted to androgynous and femme male partners. Practical difficulties of my situation include dating while trying to find someone attracted to female anatomy but not turned off by my voice and beard, and being on my period while needing a public women's restroom with a beard.
In late 2023 I watched the Netflix Twin Flames documentary and was disappointed to see a genuine example of cis people being pressured to transition. In 2025 I became concerned when my ex started hanging out with trans women, one of whom I felt was recklessly experimenting with DIY hormones (combining or alternating estrogen and testosterone shots) and offered to inject my friend with estrogen, which my friend accepted. I raised concerns about lack of endocrinologist oversight, bloodwork, HIV risk from sharing injection equipment, my friend's depression history, recent breakup and layoff, and possible pressure from a kink (forced feminization). I hold a strong moral stance that medical transition should only be done for your own inner peace, never to please someone else.
In June 2026 I attended a female-only solstice women's festival in Oregon, introduced to me by someone from a virtual detrans women's support group — the first time I'd ever met detrans women offline. Being in a female-only space with a wide range of gender expression (butch women my age and butch elders) was like an "internalized misogyny detox." Being called "she" and "woman" has a history of causing me dysphoria, but there I was free of outside influences reinforcing it and could build new positive associations of belonging and sisterhood. I plan to host two workshops there: a one-off detrans women's peer support group and a community conversation about detransition for unfamiliar attendees.
I advise others not to make permanent changes like hormones and a mastectomy if they can avoid it, because it makes life trickier and you may regret it in girl mode. I've urged a teenager considering chest surgery to give it a few years, research complications thoroughly, and remember that leaving your body as-is might be right and is absolutely okay. I'm familiar with mastectomy risks through my cis mom's breast cancer mastectomy (she had drains for weeks and a complication that sent her to the ER) and a trans male friend whose top surgery he said was botched.
Current status: I am a detransitioned/desisted female who stopped T, stopped identifying as male, and resumed my birth name, but I still feel non-binary, accept my body changes, and use they/them pronouns.