모든 이야기

호르몬 16개월, 여전히 여성스러운 게이 남성

남성 · 탈전환1.5천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 남성으로 태어나 여성스러운 게이 남성으로 정체화했으며, 2022년 중반쯤부터 약 16개월간 호르몬으로 의학적 전환(MtF)을 했고 수술은 언급되지 않았습니다. 2023년 6월부터 8월까지 저는 남성화와 '트윙크 데스'에 대한 두려움, 온라인 LGBTQ 커뮤니티의 영향, 아버지와 어머니의 학대적인 전 남자친구에 관한 어린 시절 경험에 이끌려 디트랜지션을 두고 오갔습니다. 저는 심한 우울증과 반복되는 자살 사고를 겪었고, 22세까지 살 것이라 기대하지 않았으며 어머니가 나를 살아 있게 하는 존재라고 말하기도 했습니다. 치료비를 감당할 수 없어 자원봉사, 축구, 주의 분산으로 대처했습니다. 마지막 게시물 당시에도 호르몬을 계속하고 있었지만 내적으로는 여성스러운 게이 남성으로 정체화했고, LGBTQ 커뮤니티를 거부했으며, 전환보다 성별 비순응이 첫 번째 선택지가 되어야 한다고 주장했습니다.

전체 이야기

I was born male and have identified as a feminine gay man, though for over a year I was medically transitioning as a trans woman. By my own count I had been transitioning (MtF) for 'over a year' and later '1 year and 4 months' as of August 2023, meaning I started hormones around mid-2022, when I was about 20. I never mention surgeries; the changes I describe are from hormones only — breast growth and fat redistribution, which in the last month or two before my August 19, 2023 post had become pronounced enough that I felt I was reaching a decision point. I was still in 'boymode,' had slimmed my eyebrows, and was growing out my hair. My whole account is a running battle with myself. I write things like: 'I tell myself I'm happy being a man but every day I find myself subconsciously pursuing transition. It's so ingrained in me.' And: 'The process of transition was the only reason I didn't kill myself and now it seems to be driving me towards killing myself.' On July 2, 2023 I posted that I was 'tired of waking up every day, still with the thought that I can become a woman,' that I 'need to end it,' that I 'never thought I'd make it to 21 but really don't see myself at 22,' and that I 'want out so badly.' On July 19, 2023 I wrote I was 'going to bed crying everyday,' that I felt like 'a freak,' that I was 'losing any and all hope,' felt like 'numbing myself to cope with this hell,' and that I didn't 'want to experience this life anymore.' The main thing keeping me here is my mother: 'My mom is one of the things that's kept me alive until now. I really don't want to cause her pain, so it's hard to go through with ending things.' Several factors feed into my wish to transition. The biggest is fear of masculinization and aging as a man — I wrote about being terrified of 'balding etc.' and about 'twink death,' posting on July 5, 2023 that this fear is 'one of the main factors as to why I feel I can't fully go through with detransition,' and describing myself as 'only 21 but I feel like an aging actress who is desperate to keep her appearance the same.' I was, by my own admission, 'literally starving myself to try and lose weight to become more twinkish/feminine.' I also linked it to how men are perceived: 'In my mind men are aggressive, dangerous and intimidating,' shaped by 'being bullied for being sensitive,' my 'mom's ex boyfriend verbally abusing her,' and an incident where 'he cut his finger while drunk he splashed his blood all over our apartment walls, which was really scary.' I wondered whether 'a mix of online perception and how my dad treated me when I was younger' was informing my thinking, and described my dad as a 'brute' who would berate my mom 'as to how she failed as mother because he's an asshole.' Online communities were central. I spent 'all of my time inside online, unless I have to go to work or college.' I posted nsfw pictures presenting as a trans woman from age 17, dollying myself up with 'dark eye shadow, red overlined lips, false eyelashes, intense blush and a 28 inch wig,' because I 'knew that I could derive love and affirmation that way.' I now see that as the peak of the 'love' I received, and I'm angry about it: 'The most love/support I received was when I was a 17 year old posting nsfw pictures as a trans woman online. Now I'm 21 and realise I'm not trans despite the rainbow community telling me otherwise.' I came to believe 'the vast majority of the trans community is homophobic and misogynistic,' that it puts 'feminine gay men and masculine women lowest on the totem pole,' and that the west 'covertly forces people to transition through the guise of celebration, community and belonging.' I also suspect financial motives: the medical industry supports transition because 'why would they want to lose their cash cow,' and I believe many trans people are 'trapped by sunken cost fallacy' yet still 'advocate for transition as the first option by relaying a fake experience.' I also describe a salvation-like pull: 'when did this idea of salvation become attached to transition because I've been captured by it?' and a romanticised image I 'can't separate myself from, in that one day it will all click and I'll be a happy trans woman.' I recognize this as running away from a lack of self-love: 'my biggest issue might be lack of self love and transition might in my messed up mind be a way to run away from that,' and as binary thinking: 'I probably thought that I either have to be a man or woman because of my monkey brain. I can just be androgynous/non binary.' On the process of detransition, I was still going back and forth throughout June–August 2023. I described feeling 'freed' and 'lifted out of a storm' when I leaned toward stopping, but also that 'a part of me refuses to let go of transition.' I noted I was 'quite an impulsive person' and wanted to 'wait for the euphoria of passing to pass.' I wanted therapy but 'can't afford it right now,' and I tried distractions — volunteering with at-risk youth the summer before last, which 'felt good' but 'still wasn't enough' while I was 'really really depressed' and 'binge eating every day.' I used to play football/soccer and was 'happy for the hour plus' but 'stopped because of my transition.' I've taken '30 liberty caps' as my only psychedelic experience. I came out only to my mom and family, and worried she'd have an 'I told you so' moment if I stopped. I was on Grindr as a feminine-looking man and found 'people weren't really interested or they just thought I was ftm.' As of my last posts in August 2023 I was still on hormones, still identifying internally as a feminine gay man, and had come to accept I'd 'most likely never find love' as one — 'which I'm okay with now' — while firmly refusing to transition to get it. I no longer identify with the LGBTQ community: 'I'm just a gay man, I'm not a part of any community.' I now argue that 'gender nonconformity should be the first option, not transition,' and compare recommending transition to recommending heroin: 'Some people can function and even thrive in life while using heroin but I'd never recommend it to anyone.'