공개적으로는 비판적, 사적으로는 부작용을 안고 살아간다
여성 · 탈전환285
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 2021년 r/detrans에 글을 올리고 2023년까지 댓글을 이어간 디트랜지션한 사람입니다. 저는 트랜스 커뮤니티를 취약한 젊은이들에게 되돌릴 수 없는 의료 시술을 강요하는 '컬트'라고 비판해 왔으며, 동시에 성인은 원하는 대로 해야 한다고 말합니다. 저는 과거에 '여러 인격'이 있었다는 것과 2021년에 팔을 다쳤다는 것을 서술했습니다. 제게 남아 있는 신체적 부작용의 세부 사항은 공개적으로 게시하지 않고 비공개 메시지로 남겨 두었습니다. 한때 제 플레어를 '전환을 단념한 남성'으로 설정했습니다.
전체 이야기
I posted a question thread in r/detrans in February 2021 that I suspected might get me banned, and it drew a long, heated discussion. I told people they could DM me because it was faster. In that thread I described my own experience of having had "several personalities," adding that "you learn who you are eventually." I also said I had been "a man inside a woman's body once," and joked that what happened afterward was that "she gave birth to me" — a line I used to make light of how I once thought about myself.
I was already detransitioned at that point, and someone asked me directly whether any side effects on my body had lingered. I chose to answer privately rather than publicly. I also mentioned having an injured arm at the time, which I said was why my replies came out short and abridged compared to other people's.
My views on transition are strongly critical. I described the trans community as a "cult" that bullies anyone offering constructive criticism of its standards. I wrote that people are "being irreversibly damaged as a substitute for actually having their own personal needs addressed and validated," and I quoted approvingly someone else's fear that if they had been born five to ten years later they would have been dosed with hormones and given irreversible surgeries while really needing therapy and someone to listen. I said I'm fine with adults transitioning if they consent and are over 18, but that the movement has "a fundamental issue" and is "cashing in on the suffering of misguided young people," and I called on them to "stop grooming children and vulnerable people into castrating themselves." I argued trans people "need to have a more well evidenced procedure for deciding who should and who should not be allowed to make the leap," and said the support they actually needed was "love and attention from your friends and a consideration for who you genuinely are. Not *this.*"
I was careful to say I wasn't trying to impose my will on anyone. I told one person that I'll "never [see] a transitioned female as the same thing as an ordinary girl" and that no amount of browbeating will change that, while insisting I hold that opinion privately and don't intend to stop anyone else. I also said that if someone wants to be a stealth trans person they should go ahead, even though I find "the entire practice nauseating," because "it's what works at some point" — my real objection, I said, is "the stupid cult aspect of it." I suggested to one person that they could "just be an effeminate guy or non binary" instead, and told another, who wanted children, "You will never have kids like you want, why mutilate yourself?"
I told people I wanted them to be happy and that I didn't want to see more people like them sad. I said my input was less valuable than detransitioned people's and that I should "stfu" and let them talk. I asked basic questions of others in the thread — what TIMs meant, what a trans-identified male is in this culture, why people were being pushed — and admitted the subculture confused me enough to give me "an aneurysm" over whether people meant biological males or females.
By April 2023 I was still posting in the same community. I told someone considering transition that "transitioning is just damaging yourself," that the whole thing is "astroturfed and made to make you feel like shit until you join them," and advised them to get their mind onto a hobby. I encouraged another person to keep living to see how far they got with crafts they'd listed. I said these stories on the subreddit give me "a panic attack." I noted I'd been auto-logged-in for about two years and had previously set my flair to "desisted male," which had vanished. I ended one exchange by saying "It's not over yet. The game's just beginning."
I don't discuss specific surgeries, medications, or dates for my own transition and detransition anywhere in this record, and I kept the details of my lingering physical side effects to private messages.