게이 남성으로 5년, 그리고 효과가 없다는 깨달음
여성 · 단념199
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 약 5년간 게이 남성으로 산 후 2023년 초에 트랜스로서의 정체화를 그만둔 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 가슴을 손상시킨 바인딩 외에는 의료적 조치를 취하지 않았습니다. 제 트랜지션은 진단되지 않은 자폐 가능성, 오토안드로필리아와 유사한 무언가, 5학년경 젠더 이념에 노출된 후 소녀들로부터의 소외, 그리고 나를 재창조하고 내가 사귀고 싶은 유형의 남성이 되고 싶은 욕구의 혼합에 의해 추동되었습니다. 디트랜지션은 남성으로 살아도 기분이 나아지지 않고 진정 원하는 것 — '시스'가 되는 것 — 을 결코 얻지 못한다는 내면적 깨달음으로 찾아왔고, 그래서 생물학적 성으로 다시 살기로 선택했습니다. 이제 디트랜지션을 신체적이라기보다 정신적 과정으로 보고, 다른 사람들에게 젠더 이념과 라벨을 놓으라고 조언하며, 남성성과 연애 전망에 대한 불안을 아직 다루고 있습니다.
전체 이야기
I stopped identifying as trans in early 2023, after around five years of living as a guy. I never took any medical steps — no hormones, no surgeries — but my breasts are damaged from a half-decade of inappropriate binding, and that is one of the few physical reminders I'm left with.
When I first posted about my detransition, I was consumed with worry that no man would ever want to date me. I felt like I wasn't 'good' at being a girl. Even though I had reconciled with being female, what I called the 'trans residue' hadn't gone away: I had a short haircut I was trying to grow out, I wore men's clothing, I had lots of male mannerisms, and the majority of my interests were typically male. I was planning to keep my masculine chosen name. During my transition — and still — I was often mistaken for a butch lesbian, and I was anxious that no straight man would want to be with such a masculine girl.
A lot of my desire to transition came from wanting to fulfill the role of a man. I did the whole gay guy thing, and it felt good to take on a more masculine role, both intimately and casually. I was still attracted to men, but I felt like I couldn't fulfill the role of a woman in a heterosexual relationship. I also worried that having identified as trans for so long would deter potential partners — I framed it as 'mental illness is understandably undesirable in a partner' and wondered why a guy would choose me over 'regular' girls who had always just been 'regular' girls. In the end I realized I was projecting my own insecurities onto potential partners who probably didn't care.
Looking back on why I transitioned, it's a lot of things. I think I might have undiagnosed autism or something similar, which affected my identity in regard to my sex. I think I experienced something akin to autoandrophilia — not that transitioning was a sexual thing for me, but the idea of myself as a man seemed very comfortable and familiar. I identified as a gay guy, and I was definitely trying to be the type of guy I wanted to date, maybe unconsciously because I felt like I wasn't 'enough of a girl' for that type of guy to want to be with me, so I tried to be him.
I also felt alienated from girls my age when I was introduced to gender ideology around 5th grade. I thought I must not be a girl because I identified strongly with boys, and I realized I didn't look or act the same as my peers. I resented my body a lot at that age — I wanted to be skinnier so my features would be less feminine. I liked the idea of being able to reinvent myself; it felt like I was healing or fixing myself somehow, because I thought I was becoming myself. Truly I was myself the whole time.
It took a long time to detransition because I was in denial. I realized that despite all the time I'd spent living as a guy, I still didn't feel any better, and I knew I could never get what I really wanted, which was to be 'cis'. As much as I wanted to be a biological male, I accepted that wasn't possible, so I started considering living as my biological sex again. The more I thought it over, the more appealing, bearable, and preferable it seemed. At one point, if there had been a button to make me a biological male I wouldn't have pushed it — but at any point during my transition, or even at the beginning of my detransition, I would have taken it. When I decided I didn't want to continue the transition process, that's all it was for a while, but I still thought that on some metaphysical level I was a dude. The more I settled into the fact I wasn't happy living as a guy, the more I realized I had been focusing on the wrong solution to the problem.
I've come to believe that detransition or desisting is much more of a mental process than a physical one. For me, detransition was a result of an internal change. I chased transition so desperately because of the desire to run away from myself, even though at the time I thought I was pursuing who I 'really was'. I loved the sense of control transitioning gave me, seeing physical changes was really cathartic — until I realized I still felt the same. In reality, the person I 'really was' was already there even though I couldn't see her. Transition will not 'fix' you and neither will detransition; if you're depressed or chasing something, it'll always slip away.
I don't think detransition means going the opposite direction and forcing yourself into the stereotypes you were running from. For me it was about no longer putting on a performance — I was no longer performing as a male and trying to force people's perception, but that did not mean I suddenly started performing femininity either. I've noticed people, myself included, thinking that desistance is just another type of transition or facade. The only way to experience a positive result, in my view, is recognizing you are already whole and don't need to change anything to be a certain way. If you hate yourself, you'll hate yourself regardless of what you do if you're chasing something.
The best advice I could give to most people on the subreddit is not to think of life as a process of 'transitioning' or 'detransitioning', or putting yourself in a box with an ultimate goal. You are not defined by whether you're transitioning or detransitioning, by calling yourself 'trans' or 'cis'. The only thing that made me start progressing was forgetting about gender ideology — hatred isn't a prerequisite for divorcing the ideology, but I know how hard it is to stop thinking in that lens.
I've also dealt with the difficulty of being perceived, which isn't made easier by the fact that my family isn't supportive of me. I hope to get to a place where other people's perception of me doesn't affect me negatively. I've primarily male friends, so I haven't experienced much hostility from other women — I've never been a fan of female friend groups, partially for that reason. I've advised others to stay away from dating sites and noted that transitioning holds many more negative implications for your body than a tattoo. I also clarified community terminology for someone, explaining that tucutes are the 'you don't need GD to be trans' people, the opposite of transmedicalism.
I'm still working through why I feel like my past makes me less valuable, and I recognize a lot of it is my own insecurity rather than something potential partners would actually care about.