모든 이야기

테스토스테론 10년, 그러고는 장기들이 말을 했다

여성 · 탈전환1.6천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 디트랜지션한 여성으로, 여러 해 동안 남성으로 살았고 22세부터 10년간 테스토스테론을 사용했으며 심장, 간, 눈 문제와 위축을 겪은 뒤 의학적 전환을 중단했습니다. 지금 저는 제 전환을 자기혐오, 내면화된 여성혐오, 기독교 양육, 그리고 남성적인 신체에 대한 열망이 내가 트랜스라는 뜻이라고 믿은 오해에서 비롯된 것으로 봅니다. 디트랜지션 초기에는 낯선 사람들이 여전히 저를 대개 남성으로 불렀고, 저는 슬픔과 자기 수용, 다시 여성으로 보이는 어려움과 씨름하고 있습니다. 저는 남성화와 유방 조직의 부재를 후회하며 그것이 부치 여성으로 사는 삶을 어렵게 만듭니다. 저는 이성 호르몬에 공개적으로 반대하면서도 제 디트랜지션은 대체로 사적으로 유지합니다. 저는 다른 사람의 전환에 여전히 비판적이며 이전보다 정치적으로 더 좌파입니다.

전체 이야기

I was born female, and looking back I can see that my discomfort started long before I had any language for it. As a kid I was made fun of for being hairy and I had a complex about being taller than my 4'11" friends, and I at least wore clothes from the women's section and wasn't afraid to wear what I wanted. I also had a 'teenage boy' voice even before hormones, despite being a 20-year-old girl. I started hormones at 22. In hindsight I was far too young — I didn't understand the world or the negative health effects this would have on me, and I wasn't fully informed about what I was doing, and neither was anyone else. I identified as a binary man for a long time and I liked the changes: I liked seeing myself get more masculine, I had a beard and a flat chest, and I passed easily — I could be stealth about 99% of the time depending on how I dressed. HRT was, in a purely cosmetic sense, 'very good' to me. But internally I never adapted to being a man. I'd look in the mirror and like how I looked as a man, but it didn't feel like 'me.' Socially I felt alienated from both men and women, and I had a hard time with relationships. I spent my whole life chameleon-style, trying to assimilate and be the best masculine man I could be, flying under the radar in different situations — and I started to feel like a fake version of myself. I was constantly, obsessively connecting gender and masculinity with every facet of my life. What actually moved me toward detransition was medical. I was on testosterone for 10 years, and only about 3 years in I started having health concerns. My side effects from testosterone were heart palpitations, shortness of breath, muscular chest pain (no diagnosable heart issues), severe dry eyes, vaginal and uterus atrophy causing pain, higher cholesterol and blood pressure than is normal for my age and fitness level, and at one point elevated liver enzymes indicating liver damage. Even as a healthy, active vegetarian I couldn't get those numbers down. I was gaslit by my doctor into believing it was an anxiety disorder. I heard of a couple of other people in my circle with the same liver issue, and the doctor diagnosing it very quickly left the practice where he'd been treating all of us. The catalyst was simply: 'How can this be my true self if it's going to hurt me to be this way?' Alongside that, I realized I still felt like a woman — not that I wanted to be one, but that I just am one, and that feeling never went away. I don't believe it would ever have gone away, even if I'd gotten phalloplasty. Nothing would have made me feel 'man enough.' That's when I realized that for me, transition was a lie. I also came to see the emotional effects of testosterone as unnatural for me — it 'mellowed me out' for a while, but feeling so level all the time also felt flat and detached, and I came to see it as limiting my emotional maturity. I became very 'flat' and wasn't able to cry. I also did a lot of thinking about how I got here. I was always pretty aware of the difference between the sexes and aware of sexism and misogyny, but what got me was the misconception that a female who wants her body to be more masculine is supposed to transition to be a man. I genuinely believed that what I was feeling was 'dysphoria' and that when you feel dysphoria the right choice is to transition, regardless of any other factors. In hindsight I now see that as internalized misogyny and being a butch lesbian — I was very uncomfortable with my genitalia because of internalized misogyny. I also grew up in Christianity, and I see now how an ideology that tells women they're supposed to be helpers for men and that their job is raising children could not have impacted my feelings about my gender and body from a young age. I had an emo style in high school, and at the time I just felt like I wanted to be a boy; now I see it as misogyny. I also self-harmed when I was younger, before transition. I also think neurodivergence played a role: in my 10 years in the trans community, nearly every other transmasculine person I met either had autism or ADHD, and I used to consider myself one of the exceptions until I realized I'm probably not neurotypical either. I think if girls were diagnosed younger and told that discomfort with puberty can be part of autism, it would change things. I also believe I was young and impressionable when I found out about this stuff — if I hadn't been, I wouldn't have thought it made any sense. If I had been born a few years earlier or later, or had waited until my late 20s, I never would have done it. I'm at the beginning stages of going off testosterone now. Detransition has been a long process and it's mostly internal so far — I've been letting go of pretending to be someone I'm not, and the biggest change has been internal. I'm generally read as male by strangers due to how masculinized I was with T and the way I dress, and I may never be able to pass as female again. I'm living in a kind of between-gender state, and I'm usually not happy or comfortable like that. I regret that it makes it harder to pass for a butch woman, having no boobs at all and masculinization from T; I wish I had gone for a more androgynous look with my transition. I also experienced much more hair loss than many people, and I'm trying micro needling for it. The sadness hits hard — like a sledgehammer. I've told others that a huge part of what gets us into all this in the first place is self-hatred and the inability to accept ourselves as we are, and I know how impossible that feels because I'm going through it too. I didn't realize how harmful my negative feelings about myself were until I went too far with transition; I finally realized I genuinely just hated myself, and that 'that's all transition is about — hating yourself enough to try to become a different person.' I promised myself when I started to feel regret that I would do no more harm. I'm working on being kinder to myself and having more love for myself despite my circumstances, and on voice training. I don't want to be publicly known as someone who went through all this — it could affect work and the way family and friends treat me. I think it's often harder for FTMTFs like me to reintegrate than for MTFTMs. I've thought about writing about it under a pen name. I've been active in detrans communities, sharing my medical side effects and encouraging others to at least try stopping hormones, and I've said this motivation is so future generations can make better choices. I'm more left-wing now than before, because rather than seeing trans ideology as progressive, I now see it as a harmful way to conform to conservative social norms. I don't believe nonbinary or genderqueer identities are real, and I think transmedicalism is just as much of a lie because it's predicated on the idea that transition is the medically healthy option for some 'true trans' people — in reality I believe cross-sex hormones are not physically healthy and that what happened to us can be seen as a tragedy, even medical malpractice. I do think people should be allowed to make their own rules about how far to detransition, medically or socially, and I try to be supportive of others wherever they are in the process.