모든 이야기

세 가지 호르몬, 그다음 2019년 말에 점진적 감량

남성 · 탈전환34
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 디트랜지션한 남성으로, 2019년 말부터 호르몬을 서서히 줄이기 시작하기 전까지 수년간 에스트로겐과 피나스테리드, 그리고 류프로렐린 아세테이트를 사용했습니다. 저는 대부분의 효과가 신체적으로 가역적이라는 점에 대해 공개적으로 말해 왔으며, 유방 조직이 주요 영구적 변화이고 생식 능력 회복에는 수년이 걸릴 수 있다고 지적했습니다. 저는 디트랜지션 공간에서의 젠더 비판 진영/TERF의 존재와 블랜차드의 AGP 이론 모두에 비판적이며, 해당 서브레딧이 디트랜지션한 사람과 의문을 품는 사람으로 제한되어야 한다고 주장합니다. 저는 가톨릭 신자로 자랐고, 적어도 다른 한 사람의 사례에서 가톨릭적 죄책감을 젠더 정체성 문제와 분리할 가치가 있는 요인으로 지적해 왔습니다. 현재 저는 디트랜지션한 남성으로 정체화합니다.

전체 이야기

I was born male and transitioned to female, spending a few years on estrogen and finasteride before deciding to detransition. By October 2019 I had been on leuprolide acetate (Lupron) for about three months as an anti-androgen, and I posted asking other male-to-female detransitioners how long it took to notice changes in mood, body fat distribution, hair, muscle growth, sexual function, and libido after stopping. I decided to come off the anti-androgen when my Lupron wore off in late October 2019 and asked whether it was better to stop estrogen cold turkey or taper over weeks or months. I ended up tapering down off estrogen and was nearly ready to go without it by mid-November 2019, pending blood tests showing an increase in testosterone from the leuprolide wearing off. I asked how long it took for body and facial fat to redistribute into a more male pattern, and whether anyone who had laser hair removal (rather than electrolysis) saw facial hair regrowth, since laser slows follicle growth rather than killing the follicles, and I wanted to avoid using minoxidil if possible. Someone suggested minoxidil works for beard growth but takes about two years of use. In late November 2019 I commented that cutting my long hair felt like a bigger step than coming off HRT after all those years of growing it, and that I could donate it to make it easier. I also noted that as a guy I look much better with short hair. I advised someone else going cold turkey that it would throw them straight into low testosterone symptoms, and recommended going off the anti-androgen first and slowly tapering estrogen over a month so testosterone could build up gradually. I said it seemed to take about five to six months for levels to return to normal, noting my own level had been around 400 at one point, which I was told was normal, though I joked that would only be normal for an 80-year-old cis woman with type 2 diabetes. By February 2020 I shared that pretty much everything goes back after stopping, that fertility seems to take quite a while, and that fat redistributes. I said I'd never heard of anyone losing erectile function other than one person who burned out on anti-psychotics. I told someone their skin will regrow over time, framing it as a second chance at skincare, and that they would have some breast tissue under the fat to deal with, noting the surgery is cheap and cosmetic because it's so common with bodybuilders. I stated that breast tissue is the only real permanent effect of male-to-female HRT, and that female-to-male detransitioners have it worse. In February 2020 I also guessed that someone's injections were some form of Lupron, sharing that in my experience it takes a little longer than other medications to come off but does wear off and return to normal, including the fairly brutal mental health side effects. I said it took me around two months to get back to normal testosterone levels, though I was only on monthly injections. I added that breast tissue can be dealt with easily since gyno is common among bodybuilders and the surgery is fairly cheap, but advised waiting until fat redistribution finished first, and that fertility may take a few years to return. I was raised Catholic, and in November 2019 I told someone else that Catholic guilt is very real and that they'd need to separate it from their feelings about forced fem porn consumption and gender identity, recommending they talk to a therapist. I have been critical of Blanchard's AGP theory, arguing it is unfalsifiable and therefore invalid, and I said there is no evidence whatsoever that AGP exists. I also said there is a reason counsellors don't take AGP seriously. I defended therapy as useful if someone has misidentified another mental health condition as gender dysphoria, but said it doesn't work as conversion therapy for genuine gender dysphoria, and that you won't know which until you talk to a competent therapist. I have been vocal about the makeup of the detransition subreddit. I described it as a TERF sub with TERF mods and said the abuse detrans men face there is part of the sub's design by allowing non-detrans people to post. I said support for detrans women disappears as soon as they're found not to be GC or radfem. I noted that CIS GC radfems make up the majority of posters based on a post-analysis, and that an influx of gamergaters and alt-righters has been notable since detransition got more awareness. I argued the sub should only be for detrans and questioning people. I also said that most 'GCs' aren't even radical, feminist or gender critical but are 'bored, middle class British housewives' who hate what the Express tells them, comparing them to UK equivalents of alt-righters. I stated that detransitioners make up collectively 1% of people who transition and that most transitioners are much happier and healthier after transitioning. I advised a parent to support their child through transition if necessary, and said trying to stop a child from transitioning usually doesn't end well. I also said there are more female-to-male detransitioners because females face less stigma for exploring gender identity than males. I criticized Charlie Evans for being included in a Newsnight documentary on detransition, saying you can't talk about detransition if your entire transition consisted of a haircut and a new blazer, and later called her a 'fame whore' for it. I described myself as a detrans male and said I have it quite easily relative to detrans women. I said nobody on the sub seems happy, that most are angry and bitter and externalize their insecurity onto the 'other' group, but that you can be happy and detrans so long as you know why you're doing it, accept responsibility for your own mistakes, and avoid getting caught in a cult. I also criticized GC circles as swapping one cult for another, saying that attitude leans toward the BITE model.