이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 자신을 트랜스 여성이라고 여겼던 디트랜지션한 브라질 남성으로, 2019년 무렵(19세에) 여성화 호르몬을 시작했고 2024년 말에 디트랜지션을 시작했으며 2025년 3월 몇 달 전에 호르몬 치료를 중단했습니다. transgender_surgeries 서브레딧을 본 것, 전환 결과를 조사한 것, 불쾌감이 전환의 전제조건이 아니라는 것을 깨달은 것이 디트랜지션으로 향하는 주된 요인이었습니다. 저는 또한 아동기 트라우마, 내면화된 동성애 혐오("동성애 교정"), 그리고 제가 3세 때 아버지가 떠난 뒤 여성이 이끄는 한부모 가정에서 자란 것도 기여했다고 믿습니다. 저는 제 전환의 약 "99%"를 후회하지만 그것이 아동기 트라우마에 대처하는 데 도움이 되었다는 점은 인정하며, 되돌릴 수 없는 유방 조직 성장, 호르몬 관련 브레인 포그, 되돌리지 못한 법적 이름(Celine)과 여전히 씨름하고 있습니다. 지금 저는 트랜스 정체성을 선천적이지 않고 가변적인 것으로 인식하고 디트랜지션 위험을 치료 프로토콜에 포함시켜야 한다고 주장하며, 성인의 선택과 트랜스 친구들을 존중하면서 의학적 전환에 비판적입니다. 저는 여전히 양성애자이고 제 지향을 "모호하다"고 표현하며, 이전에 트랜스 여성으로 살았던 영향이 제 몸과 서류, 일상에 계속 미치는 것을 느낍니다.
전체 이야기
I started detransitioning recently — by late March 2025 I had been off HRT for about four months and had been actively detransitioning for roughly three months, and by my own account I had transitioned back in 2019, when I was 19. I am a Brazilian male who previously identified as trans and lived socially as a woman, and I had wanted genital surgery (SRS) as part of that fantasy of becoming "a beautiful and complete woman."
Growing up, my dad abandoned the family when I was 3, so I was raised by my mom and two older sisters — I describe myself as "created by womans" and as being too feminine to fit in with other men. I am bisexual, which I say contributed to my isolation from male friend groups; when I was more feminine it was easier to be accepted in women's groups, and I usually ended up around women. I also relate to the experience of having transitioned partly as a way of dealing with childhood trauma, and I have written "Trans the gay away! I did the same," suggesting internalized homophobia played a role in my own path.
What moved me toward detransition was research and seeing results. I say the subreddit transgender_surgeries "was actually one of the main things that led to my detransition" — seeing what a neovagina really looks like shocked me, and I had even made a post there while still identifying as trans asking people if they were satisfied with their results, concluding that most seemed to be lying to cope. I also did research into hijra and other third-sex traditions when I was thinking about detransitioning, and I had a moment of reflection when I saw non-dysphoric people transition and realized dysphoria and transition "don't need to be related." I also came to believe that without gender violence, if I could have felt comfortable as a feminine man, I might never have transitioned.
My process of detransition involved publicly coming out as detrans, which I saw as an important commitment so I wouldn't flip back. I laid out a plan for myself: accomplish the things I couldn't as a trans woman (money, a good job, a body I wanted through the gym), do the things I never allowed myself to do as a trans woman (like walking down the street without fear of being "discovered as man"), dig into gender outside of queer theory, and go beyond gender entirely to understand who I am in non-gendered parts of life. I also used an imaginative exercise of talking to my "trans version" or "woman version" to help integrate my feminine and masculine sides.
Medically, I was on feminizing HRT (estrogen) for an unknown duration, off it by around November–December 2024 (four months before March 2025), and I did not have bottom surgery — I say I would feel awful if I had "given up a perfectly normal, functioning sexual organ." I gained breast tissue on estrogen (I joke about having "gained big breasts" in response to someone else's lost breasts), and I note estrogen made me hungrier. I also describe brain fog from HRT, saying that after detransitioning I feel "more awake, yet nothing is as certain as it used to be," and that remembering my trans-identified life feels like remembering someone else's life. I say the dysphoria/feeling "comes back" sometimes but "eventually fades away," and that not being on HRT helps me not be so emotional about it.
A concrete ongoing problem is my documents: my legal name is still Celine in the hospital system and I have struggled to change it back. In July 2025 I went to the dentist and had to awkwardly explain the name mismatch to the receptionist, which left me "so fucking angry with myself" and angry at the system. I say there is always something in my body, documents, or people that reminds me of my trans past, and I don't want to deal with it.
On regret, I was asked directly whether I regret my transition and answered that while the "pretty answer" would be no, "I would rather stay dumb/ignorant if that would mean not getting traumatized," that transitioning did help me deal with some childhood trauma, and that overall "I guess I regret 99% of it." I also say I sometimes wonder whether I would transition if I knew then what I know now, thinking back to when I was 19.
Mentally, I describe myself as having been "so mentally unwell and brain-fogged by hormones" during my trans-identified years, and I advise others to treat their minds, noting hormones can worsen depression and anxiety. I don't report a formal diagnosis.
Sexually, I identify as bisexual. I say my sexuality is "a mess": I am often attracted to masculine females but assume they aren't interested in men, I can't see myself in a gay relationship because it seems "so sexual and shallow," I feel platonic love for feminine women, and feminine men are "cute, but soon get boring." I have commented that I was "trans the gay away."
Socially, some trans friends have given me a hard time, and I've had hostile exchanges with trans-identified people about detransition and about whether sex is binary — including people using intersex arguments on r/actual_detrans to tell me sex isn't binary, which left me feeling "actually gaslighted." I say I still have trans friends because I avoid the subject with them, and that some are "truly respectfull and nice" while the annoying ones are "the ones too hooked up with the ideology." I was blocked by the transgender_surgeries subreddit.
Attitudewise, I hold a critical view of transition as practiced: I believe doctors are largely "aiming for profit," that the ideology convinces people they need medical treatment for what is "just a result of a very sexist society," and that the risk of detransition "need to stop being a Taboo and be included in every treatment protocol." I would never tell a trans-identified person who has already had bottom surgery to detransition, saying it would bring them more grief than I experienced from hormones alone. I advocate that governments and laws recognize being trans as a belief or identity that can change, since it is "not inherent or forever for everyone." I have not described formal activism, but I do give advice publicly and offer my DMs to people considering stopping hormones.
As for my current status: I live as a man again, I describe myself as a "normal dude that avoids complaining" so he isn't seen as too emotional, and I am roughly two years into detransitioning as of late 2025.