모든 이야기

동성애 혐오 가정을 벗어나기 위한 10년의 중성적 삶

남성 · 탈전환2.4천
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.

Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.

때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.

요약

저는 디트랜지션한(더 정확히는 디시스트한) 게이 남성으로, 의료적 트랜지션은 하지 않았지만 보수적이고 호모포비아적인 가정의 트라우마에 이끌려 약 10년간 디스포릭하고 중성적인 형태로 살았습니다. 저는 제 경험을 "젠더 이형증"이라 명명했고, 여러 해와 디트랜지션 이야기를 읽은 끝에 그 대부분을 극복하여 자연스러운 남성성에 편안해졌습니다 — 다만 디스포리아는 결코 완전히 사라지지 않고 아직도 유발 요인을 관리합니다. 테스토스테론은 보디빌딩을 위해서만 사용했지 젠더 긍정을 위해서가 아니며 수술은 받지 않았습니다. 이제 저 자신에 대한 젠더 정체성 개념을 거부하고 스스로를 Joseph이라 부르며, 트랜스 운동에 대해 비판적이되 미묘한 견해를 가지고 진짜 트랜스 사람들은 여전히 지지합니다. 저는 디트랜지셔너의 목소리가 서사에 포함되어야 한다고 옹호하는 디시스트한 게이 남성입니다.

전체 이야기

I was born male and I am gay. I grew up in a very conservative, religious household — my dad was, in my words, a "bible-bashing monster," and the gays were hated in my family. I was expected to date girls, make babies, and have a family, all things I knew I wasn't capable of. As I hit puberty, people started commenting on the hair growing in and how I would have to start "being a man." I was shamed for being effeminate by close family members, and my dad would force short military-style haircuts on me. I was practically traumatized by every short haircut. I would sneak razors from my sisters and shave off my body hair, and I shut down completely after a while and got into a lot of trouble. I became mortified by biological manhood as well as social manhood. I never hated being male — I just hated being viewed as a man. I coined my own issue "gender dysmorphia" because it was all gender and body related: I hated my body hair, hated haircuts that were too short, didn't like gaining muscle, couldn't keep a beard, and had to wear boyish or androgynous clothing to feel comfortable. If anyone touched my body or facial hair or pointed it out, it made me viscerally disgusted with myself. I couldn't even let myself have a beard until I was 25; before then I kept my face clean-shaven, grew my hair out, and dressed very androgynously. My natural expression was masculine, but I was fighting it the whole way. The dysphoria got in the way of a ton of growth, including keeping up a weightlifting habit. I never went on hormones or had surgeries for my dysphoria, and I was never influenced to deal with it in any particular way. There were no words for what I was going through back then, so the only option was to let it run its course. It wasn't until I got out on my own that things started to get better — my friends accepted me, I found out the world was far more accepting than home, and I realized I didn't have to be a man for anyone. I couldn't let myself have a beard until about 25, and that was an odd milestone — the first time I was able to keep a beard without freaking out. I do not consider myself someone who transitioned, and I now describe myself as a desister rather than a detransitioner in the strict sense. I see myself as detrans by virtue of taking on a form that my dysphoria made me take — my "dysphoric form" — but I acknowledge "detrans" doesn't quite fit. I have used testosterone, but not for gender-affirming reasons: I took it to help me lift more and gain muscle faster because I wanted to get bodybuilder big. It was entirely about getting my body into a state I'd enjoy more, not about being more "manly." I noticed the T made my mind "simpler," which helped with my depression because becoming simpler made me less susceptible to the mental spiraling; it also killed my creative drive, made me more masculine in my pursuits, increased my sex drive, and made sex far less emotional. It did nothing to my sexual orientation — I am gay and stayed gay. I only started to figure out where my dysphoria came from years later after I began to overcome it, and once the trans debate came into vogue and I was forced to compare my own experiences to what I heard others were going through. Reading detransition stories on this community helped me unpack it and realize it was all due to trauma. I hid all of this in my everyday life because it was embarrassing and made me feel too vulnerable; this community was the first group of people I ever actually talked about it with, and the conversation was cathartic to the point that I might have cried if I hadn't been at work. The dysphoria never really goes away — it stays like a scar, but understanding my past and being away from the source gave me power over it. It took almost a decade and a half, but as of the past few months (writing in 2024) I have been able to maintain body hair without it making me feel gross. I'm almost 40, and this is the first year I've actually been able to keep hair on my arms. I've been able to build muscle and have a beard for almost 10 years, but the horrible feelings never quite went away completely. I've figured out some of my triggers — being touched or looked at a certain way, and things tied to sexual experiences; there are certain things I can't do in bed without setting it off. Still can't do body hair in some contexts. I've been lifting weights hard again and pumping up fast, and part of me is concerned the discomfort will kick in again, but I've been going farther this time than ever before. I also struggled more broadly with body image: I hated being so pale, hated how long my legs were, and even hated being human — I used to imagine I just wasn't human on the inside. The idea of being a beautiful woman or a beautiful man has crossed my mind; I envy both parties sometimes, and I'm 37 and still have these feelings at times. One good outlet was art — I placed my aspirations into my characters, which grew beyond self-inserts into their own people, and I no longer crave those lives after doing so. I also worked as a furry artist at one point and was paid to draw things that, in hindsight, should have alerted me to the problems rising up. I have no gender identity — I just have a gender expression that used to be compromised by my conservative family, and that led to gender dysphoria for almost 10 years. I eventually overcame most of it with time and became comfortable with my natural masculinity. I validate myself by accepting who and what I am; I don't label myself, I call myself Joseph. I feel Joseph more often than I feel being a man. Reconnecting with the biology I once despised lets me feel more human than I ever felt. Mentally, I've dealt with depression, which the testosterone seemed to help with temporarily by making me "simpler." I was afraid to become a man to the point of hating my increasingly manly body, and I usually only felt comfortable around women and other boys who were different. I don't have a formal diagnosis mentioned. I have no surgeries, no irreversible medical changes from transition, and no fertility concerns raised. I have never been suicidal or self-harmed as far as my posts describe. On sexuality: I am a gay man, and I was almost exclusively attracted to straight guys at one point, which I describe as not being built for the thing I was wired to need. My solution was to learn to appreciate gay men and femininity in men more, which helped me accept myself. I am very much attracted to natural men and have refused to accept a medically masculinized female person into my intimate life; I refuse to allow anyone to describe my sexual orientation as a genital preference — it is attraction to adult male sexual development. I now hold nuanced but critical views on transition. I support body modification to feel comfortable and even support it being covered by insurance for the type of gender dysphoria that doesn't go away, but I want a line drawn between someone who will benefit and someone who will regret it. I believe genuine trans development may be real and biological, similar to gay development, and I still support trans people, but I am highly critical of the activist movement, which I believe runs on the idea that gender identity matters more than biology, seeks dominance rather than a middle ground, and creates detransitioners by over-affirming. I think detransition experiences need to be part of the narrative. I have advocated for new flairs like "dysphoric male/female" on this community and spoken up in support of detransitioners being heard. I want a middle ground: trans acceptance combined with trans people accepting they are different and not entitled to binary validation, and gender-critical people accepting that trans people's feelings are real. I describe myself as a bit left of center politically. I have experienced hostility online, including "reaching out" messages after saying gender presentation doesn't entitle a person to sex. I have a former friend who is a transwoman who discovered two years into her transition that she had a rudimentary womb, and I grew up with someone who is now trans who turned out to be intersex — both of which inform my view that biology can influence gender. Currently I am a detransitioned/desisted gay man, comfortable in my natural masculinity though the dysphoric feelings never fully vanish.